maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Off Topic (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video! (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=87961)

qwazix 2013-05-14 05:30

Re: Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video!
 
It's not about purity. It's about quality and the fact that on the N9xx almost whatever you download is at least acceptable. BB10 is the realization of acl fear. Half of the apps on blackberry world are so bad ports that they are actually unusable and have to be uninstalled (possibly after they collect a bunch of your info). By unusable I mean literally, like controls outside of the screen, too small text etc.

onethreealpha 2013-05-14 06:51

Re: Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qwazix (Post 1343429)
It's not about purity. It's about quality and the fact that on the N9xx almost whatever you download is at least acceptable. BB10 is the realization of acl fear. Half of the apps on blackberry world are so bad ports that they are actually unusable and have to be uninstalled (possibly after they collect a bunch of your info). By unusable I mean literally, like controls outside of the screen, too small text etc.

My comment was a bit of tongue in cheek :)
I wouldn't agree that BB10 is the realization of acl fear.
the issues with BB10's android player are twofold; the fact that it's using gingerbread and thus limits the functionality and feature richness of some android ports to that which was available on the 2.3 builds and the laziness of devs who chose to use the auto packaging functionality of the SDK rather than port their native code over and rebuild using cascades (or an appropriate alternative within the SDK available).
I also strongly believe that a lot of the junk android ports (both native and those brough over from the ndk are from amatuers/beginners who merely downloaded code from various public repos and though they might make a quick buck, either froom the incentive options or BBworld sales.
ACL is different kettle of fish, and my only concern lies with how they will implement and integrate native Sailfish UI funcionality when running android apps through this layer

mariusmssj 2013-05-14 07:00

Re: Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video!
 
Marc Dillon on qwerty smartphones

as you can hear Jussi Hurmola is there as well

Hacker 2013-05-14 07:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by qwazix (Post 1343429)
It's not about purity. It's about quality and the fact that on the N9xx almost whatever you download is at least acceptable. BB10 is the realization of acl fear. Half of the apps on blackberry world are so bad ports that they are actually unusable and have to be uninstalled (possibly after they collect a bunch of your info). By unusable I mean literally, like controls outside of the screen, too small text etc.

I have had a completely different experience on BB10, though everyone here certainly wants Sailfish's Android approach to be as good as possible. But to be fair, as of March 2013, BB World had 80% native apps and 20% that were Android Ports; and of the Android ports, I've never downloaded a single one with the problems you describe. Sideloaded Android apps I use on the Z10, like Netflix and Instagram, definitely work and definitely add value. Ported apps downloaded directly from BB World also worked well for me, though slight slow performance was sometimes observed with all ports.

I'm not sure of Sailfish's Android approach, but I think BB10 gives me confidence that the job can be done reasonably well--and 4.x compatibility being on the way this year for BB10 makes me think the same could be true for Sailfish.

jalyst 2013-05-14 07:59

Re: Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video!
 
You sure on those percentages? I was sure they reached their large app count thanks to a larger % of Android apps than that.
I just hope Sailfish's implementation is better, or at the very least that it's comparable to BBX's...
If it's worse, then they've wasted a lot of time/resources/energy when they could've taken a different tack.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mariusmssj (Post 1343444)
As you can hear Jussi Hurmola is there as well

How do you know that's Jussi? Isn't it just a Finnish journalist?

mikecomputing 2013-05-14 08:17

Re: Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by HtheB (Post 1343401)
Marc Dillon answers: Why Jolla?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXqS8MbMFVU


Jolla's Marc Dillon on QWERTY smartphones:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tJ0btrtQ5Fc


This is great news!


Edit:
The whole interview will be online tomorrow (Tuesday)

I still say the first device is NOT QWERTY but maybe later.

mikecomputing 2013-05-14 08:24

Re: Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shmerl (Post 1343325)
Well, that's a start, but that's not the whole Sailfish yet. We are yet to see what will happen to the rest of the system, and especially core applications like e-mail client and the rest.

I doubt the apps like browser, mediaplayer, email will be open.

But atleast the apps that need to be updated and plugins for X/Y/Z webservice SHOULD be open. So we don't get same **** problems as in the case of N9 where dropbox plugin doesnt work since dropboxAPI changes. (Not using it myself but saw thread about this issue on TMO)

HtheB 2013-05-14 09:58

Re: Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video!
 
The whole interview with Marc Dillon with interesting questions:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9fX1-Y9AdQ

Kangal 2013-05-14 10:24

Re: Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jalyst (Post 1343459)
You sure on those percentages? I was sure they reached their large app count thanks to a larger % of Android apps than that.
I just hope Sailfish's implementation is better, or at the very least that it's comparable to BBX's...
If it's worse, then they've wasted a lot of time/resources/energy when they could've taken a different tack.

I think the BB CEO came out and said it.
Didn't give exact percentages but said something "roughly".

In any case, lets understate and say 70% are ports (Native, Qt, or otherwise) and 30% are Android Apps.

That's still a great figure. Especially when you factor in it surpasses 100,000. In fact, its phenomenal for a new start-up ecosystem.

Compared to WP8 which has about 150,000 all native apps, and more "top tier" Apps. But that took MS about 2 years to obtain.

The way I look at it as a point system:

Windows 7 - 90/100 (many AAA and indie "Apps" and Games, not touch friendly)
iOS - 60/100 (many AAA and some indie Apps, very polished)
Android - 45/100 (some AAA and many indie Apps, not quite polished)
PS3/Xbox - 40/100 (many AAA and few indie Apps/Games, very polished)
WP8 - 25/100 (few AAA and some indie Apps, quite polished)
Blackberry - 15/100 (few AAA and few indie Apps, not quite polished)

ranbaxy 2013-05-14 10:25

Re: Jolla Sailfish Is stunning! Now on video!
 
Sailfish UI leaked?

The new Sailfish phone UI leaked, May 20 will showcase the the first Sailfish phone, the screen not less than 5 inches.

http://www.newcellphonesblog.com/wp-...fish-phone.png

http://www.newcellphonesblog.com/wp-...h-phone-02.png

http://www.newcellphonesblog.com/wp-...h-phone-03.png

http://www.newcellphonesblog.com/wp-...h-phone-04.png


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:18.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8