maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   The Other Half (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=59)
-   -   TOHKBD rev2 (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=93156)

MartinK 2014-10-30 16:52

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvl (Post 1445129)
no, but is sw development and hw pins are the same (but different position) making new product is super easy, r&d would be very low and prices would drop.

Well, most TOH parts are 3D printed, so it indeed shouldn't be that hard as long as the non-3D printed stuff fits with the rest. Welcome to the future! :D

bluefoot 2014-10-30 17:03

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rcolistete (Post 1445175)
See my numerical calculations bechmarks of NumPy comparing 3 note/netbooks and 6 tablets & smartphones. Jolla smartphone is faster than Nexus 4 in 3 of 4 benchmarks (both using 1 CPU core and Sailfish OS) . In 2 of 4 benchmarks, Jolla smartphone is faster than a Asus 1005HA netbook.

Compare how little RAM Sailfish uses with Android, how little battery drain, etc. Sailfish has many advantages over other Mobile OS.



I also think that Jolla needs to release Jolla 2 smartphone in 2015 to attract new Sailfish users. But not everybody needs/wants to upgrade every year. For example, my Nokia N9 from 11/2011 still works very well, including its battery, multitasking, etc. I also expect to use my Jolla smartphone for some (2-4) years.

This is getting offtopic so it'll be my last post on the matter, but:

- Benchmarks can be deceptive. Sailfish may have some theoretical performance advantages, but in practice I don't think they're really there yet, and it wants better hardware. I have a Nexus 4 (bought primarily to try Sailfish on). On stock Android, and certainly on CyanogenMod there is just nothing like the level of stutter and frame drops that there are on the Jolla, and few if any performance related hangs. It's a much smoother experience. Also, bear in mind you're comparing a now 2 year old phone which operates at 1.8x the Jolla's native resolution, with an OS that has a higher baseline of resource consumption than Sailfish and with a SoC that provides similar benchmark results on Android. Also, the Nexus 4 was £135 when I got one 3 months ago, before it was discontinued ... Jolla even with the €100 discount is ~£205. If anything your benchmark results paint a dull picture for Sailfish and make an argument for better hardware.

Sailfish with 1.1 is starting to eat more RAM. Also, given the poor situation with Sailfish apps, Dalvik is a reality that most users will contend with. This ups RAM requirements significantly. Moreover, 2-3GB of LPDDR3 or even LPDDR4 (LPDDR2 in Jolla) is not expensive or difficult to put in a mobile device.

Battery drain is gigantic on the Jolla in a number of apps and usage scenarios. I think any advantage you cite is again theoretical. For example, the Browser (a car crash in itself) is way more power hungry under normal conditions than Firefox is in Dalvik on the Jolla. It's also slower, suffers constant freezes and hangs and even takes longer to open. Albeit I haven't tried it with the 1.1 improvements, so perhaps it's a little better now.

Unfortunately my N9s (I had 2) have not fared so well. I wanted to move back to one when 1.0.7 completely wrecked any semblance of useful connectivity on the Jolla for me, whilst I was on holiday. Fortunately, 1.0.8 was released the morning after I got back, and gave me a useable device again. I say fortunately, as the USB/charging port on one N9 no longer works without a huge amount of coaxing, and the other one won't boot at all (it had only been used for about 3 months). Both were manufactured by the Chinese OEM, rather than the minority which were manufactured in Nokia factories.

dirkvl 2014-10-30 17:52

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave999 (Post 1445110)
How will the campaign start play out?

1. A new countdown
X. Dirk just open when ready
2. Surprise. Anything is possible

You want a new countdown?

Casanunda 2014-10-30 18:17

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvl (Post 1445187)
You want a new countdown?

You must know Dave999 loves contdowns.... :)

djbengan 2014-10-30 18:31

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
ehh, the kickstarter page is gone?!

bluefoot 2014-10-30 18:41

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvl (Post 1445187)
You want a new countdown?

Would highly suggest not launching this week. Tomorrow is the end of the working week and any (e)press will be resultingly limited.

If you intend to launch it soon, wait until Monday or Tuesday next week, and have a few e-mails to phone / tech news sites lined up to send out, to tip them about it.

Success of the campaign will partly rely on PR.

robnas 2014-10-30 18:53

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by djbengan (Post 1445191)
ehh, the kickstarter page is gone?!

NOOOOOOOOO!
I mean: Yes, it's gone, and: NOOOOOOOO, it's gone!
Or something.

@bluefoot:
drugs are bad, mkay?
*looks at own post*
That doesn't sound too serious...
Quote:

- Quite simply. By using it. Without the GPU idle and ZRAM modules from Warehouse, it's pretty piss poor.
No, it isn't. Period.

Dave999 2014-10-30 18:59

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Casanunda (Post 1445189)
You must know Dave999 loves contdowns.... :)

Yes, I would love another one.

Maybe with a twist with image or video every day. (media package.)I'm sure you got cool ideas. (If not this thread could help)

5 days to launch:
(Image or video)

4 days to launch:
Image or video)

3 days to launch
Image or video)

2 days to launch
Image or video)

1 day to launch
Image or video)

Launch

vistaus 2014-10-30 19:01

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
I'm gonna upgrade to the Jolla Phone 2 unless Jolla does something I dislike a lot or TOHKBD Rev 2 isn't compatible with the Jolla Phone 2.

bennypr0fane 2014-10-30 21:20

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by juiceme (Post 1444919)
The stuff you describe above is software, it can be changed easily afterwards to suit all the needs of the user. No need to worry about that.

There's a very important difference between "can be changed" and works out of the box. Does anyone know that better than past users of Maemo and present users of Jolla?
Oh the dreams I had for stuff that would become possible with my N900 in hand... Here and now, my questions are not about the dreams! :D
Hence, forgive me Dirk if I ask again if you didn't miss my previous questions, because this thread is moving pretty fast. Any word on the software?

jaybeeare 2014-10-30 21:38

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Hi Dirk, Kimmo, Andrew,

Did you consider the magnets on TOH may interfere with the on-board magnetometer? There are several ways in which this may manifest. There also is a way to minimise potential interference but not completely eradicate it I'm afraid. Of course this is only an issue if you care about a functional magnetometer though ;)

Cheers,
Jan

NokiaFanatic 2014-10-30 22:45

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by djbengan (Post 1445191)
ehh, the kickstarter page is gone?!

Link not working for me either.

Know it's already been said, but I am disappointed Jolla are not weighing in with support on this.

malkavian 2014-10-31 00:00

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
The DIY pack are all the pieces and you simply have to mount it with a screwdriver and maybe some glue for the magnets? Or it's more complex than that?

billranton 2014-10-31 08:12

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by djbengan (Post 1445191)
ehh, the kickstarter page is gone?!

If there's any sanity around here, it's gone because Jolla have snapped up Dirk to make the TOHKBD for them, and that was the point of this whole charade.

mjtorn 2014-10-31 08:19

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by billranton (Post 1445245)
If there's any sanity around here, it's gone because Jolla have snapped up Dirk to make the TOHKBD for them, and that was the point of this whole charade.

Let's just hope @dirkvl chimes in soon on what's up, as searching for toh or jolla doesn't find the same campaign under another name.

To me the TOHKBDrev2 feels more like a massdrop kind of project, that the customizations and all might be a bit heavy.

Thoke 2014-10-31 08:42

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NokiaFanatic (Post 1445225)
Know it's already been said, but I am disappointed Jolla are not weighing in with support on this.

How do you know they haven't, though? Kickstarter got nice pictures... One with Keira black ambience. Speculation, I know, but Jolla may already have helped Dirk in one way or another, we haven't (and may not) just heard about it. Clearly Dirk has established a deal with Lastucase at least, as there was many link promoting Lastucase on that Kickstarter.

szopin 2014-10-31 09:48

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bennypr0fane (Post 1445217)
There's a very important difference between "can be changed" and works out of the box. Does anyone know that better than past users of Maemo and present users of Jolla?
Oh the dreams I had for stuff that would become possible with my N900 in hand... Here and now, my questions are not about the dreams! :D
Hence, forgive me Dirk if I ask again if you didn't miss my previous questions, because this thread is moving pretty fast. Any word on the software?

https://github.com/kimmoli/tohkbd-archive
It's been inactive for a while, but if my memory serves there were initially issues with '?' char being appended in some cases, and Jolla got it fixed in the update right after first batch of rev1 KBDs was sent out (they also helped in writing it afaik, with much bigger group of owners getting the last tweaks should be easy, then again, not sure if the chip/connection will be the same, so a new daemon might be needed)

billranton 2014-10-31 10:28

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Wasn't there a together question thread months ago with contributions for Marc Dillon asking us which TOHs we most want, and the implication that Jolla would produce the more popular plus amd eighth one suggested by the community in another thread? I remember the keyboard came top, but there was solar and wireless charging tohs in the list too.

Could the whole funky other half setup just be a community oriented way of establishing a TOH division?

usr 2014-10-31 12:41

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Add stilus and I will buy it!

vistaus 2014-10-31 12:47

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by usr (Post 1445270)
Add stilus and I will buy it!

What good will that do? Any capacitive stylus is average at best. For real stylus input, a magnetizer is needed (like my hybrid laptop has) but that requires putting it under the screen which is a no-go unless you're really into modifying your Jolla that much... (with a chance of screwing it up)

dirkvl 2014-11-01 12:39

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Kickstarter update
We had a lot of good feedback/q's/tips/hints/suggestions/criticism/ideas from a lot of people. This was very helpful and we are now in the final stages of getting green-light from Kickstarter and are finalizing the page and making sure all info in there.

Development
Development continues of course! The hype around the campaign has drawn a lot of people to FunkyOH, so I finally have some 'dough' to spare for continuing development. Proto-pcb's and shells are not for free ;)

Technical update
The PCB in the Base part (that connects to the phone) will be extended in size to cover the entire area. This brings the following advantages:
- The PCB acts as a backbone for the casing and makes the whole construction a lot stronger
- Cleaner design and lots of area for PCB art
- The PLA casing *can* become soft and bend over time if it gets hot. Bending of the casing *can* result in a loss of connection. Extending the PCB over the entire area eliminates this risk entirely.
- The casing can be slightly thinner (0.2mm!) because all strength now comes from the PCB. For all thickness-weenies: this is the limit. Going any thinner requires thinner magnets, resulting in a shitty connection.

https://dl.dropbox.com/s/dou27jrvcn5...ohkbd-1-11.png

Answers to questions

Quote:

Originally Posted by bennypr0fane (Post 1445217)
There's a very important difference between "can be changed" and works out of the box.
...
Any word on the software?

TOHKBD will be shipped inside a box and will work after you take it out.

Quote:

Originally Posted by NokiaFanatic (Post 1445225)
I am disappointed Jolla are not weighing in with support on this.

Can people please stop saying stuff like this? I am getting lots and lots of help from Jolla on important issues, they answer difficult questions, pitch me ideas, help with marketing and the list goes on and on.
They do as much as they can without hijacking my project.

Quote:

Originally Posted by malkavian (Post 1445231)
The DIY pack are all the pieces and you simply have to mount it with a screwdriver and maybe some glue for the magnets? Or it's more complex than that?

Will be some more info on kick-page, but basically it is a pre-soldered pre-programmed TOHKBD without casing, magnets and wood. All files will be provided (all other people will get all files too, no worries!). This is an option for people that want to do customizations themself.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thoke (Post 1445250)
Clearly Dirk has established a deal with Lastucase at least, as there was many link promoting Lastucase on that Kickstarter.

Not so much a deal, more a fair price on large batches of wooden panels. They put a lot of work in developing stuff for Jolla too and are very friendly in the conversation. Besides the backplate is the thinnest and cleanest way to cover the bottom pcb, I also prefer to work together with companies that work that way.

Quote:

Originally Posted by szopin (Post 1445257)
not sure if the chip/connection will be the same, so a new daemon might be needed)

chip will be the same, so lots of stuff can be 'ported', but this daemon (with all extra features and multiple layouts) will we a bit more complex - to extremely understate it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by usr (Post 1445270)
Add stilus

http://media.giphy.com/media/yzp4EVsM2wMM0/giphy.gif
http://media.giphy.com/media/5T8tEJtCgvDuo/giphy.gif

minimos 2014-11-01 14:22

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Thanks dirkvl for the update!

About the question on Jolla supporting the project:
Quote:

I am disappointed Jolla are not weighing in with support on this.
cybette(@Jolla) also answered to a direct question on TJC about this subject:
Quote:

There are many ways we support community projects, and we are certainly supporting Dirk, Kimmo and Andrew in the TOHKBD campaign, with promotions, SW/technical support and more. So we share your thinking here!

Dave999 2014-11-01 14:38

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Dirk...Dont forget the beer-perk.

Buy me a beer for my hard work - 5 Euro ;)

Man...your next Leffe should be on me :D

Where is that 2nd countdown?
http://i.imgur.com/3FVlh0X.gif

dirkvl 2014-11-02 17:27

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Next bottom pcb is done and ordered a few.

https://dl.dropbox.com/s/rllxoksj94tjwit/eagle2.JPG

Time to solder the proto's i have now!

dirkvl 2014-11-02 23:42

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvl (Post 1445495)
Time to solder the proto's i have now!

Soldered.

Quick test

Will go to Kimmo tomorrow, he will consult the Toran Ra.
http://southparkstudios.mtvnimages.c...ran-ra-4x3.jpg

bennypr0fane 2014-11-03 00:39

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvl (Post 1445359)
Answers to questions

TOHKBD will be shipped inside a box and will work after you take it out.

Interestinggg. You're answering a software question with a statement about the packaging. Or is the box part of the hardware? :confused:

Casanunda 2014-11-03 09:43

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bennypr0fane (Post 1445528)
Interestinggg. You're answering a software question with a statement about the packaging. Or is the box part of the hardware? :confused:

Read again:
Question was "Will it work out of the box?"

Now read again dirkvl's answer.
Easier translation: It will work out of the box.

dirkvl 2014-11-03 09:47

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bennypr0fane (Post 1445528)
Interestinggg. You're answering a software question with a statement about the packaging. Or is the box part of the hardware? :confused:

for it to work out-of-the-box, by definition it has to have been in a box first.

pichlo 2014-11-03 09:54

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Casanunda (Post 1445561)
Read again:
Question was "Will it work out of the box?"

Now read again dirkvl's answer.
Easier translation: It will work out of the box.

To be fair, the question was exactly,

Quote:

Originally Posted by bennypr0fane (Post 1444895)
Dirk, can you confirm:
1.) in current OS version (Uitukka), the vkb can never be completely hidden? Otherwise, why don't you do that?
2.) 3rd party/community can't make the vkb go away completely, only Jolla can? Just saw that that known issue is in Tahkalampi!
May already gone in Uitukka? Anyone using it already? Haven't seen it in the changelog...

Dirk's reply avoids answering the real question by quoting the follow-up post instead.

Please note that I am just playing the devil's advocate here. I do not take sides and no longer care about TOHKBD rev2, but I can understand that different people may have different idea of what constitutes "works out of the box".

dirkvl 2014-11-03 10:07

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pichlo (Post 1445563)
Dirk's reply avoids answering the real question by quoting the follow-up post instead.

It is because I do not have a definite answer to that. But, developer proto's are going to jollahq and Kimmo today, so we will see what is possible!

It is very hard for me to do promises about sw, as this is not my expertise (to understate the situation).

Jeffrey04 2014-11-03 10:55

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
iirc, i saw there's a self assembly kit in the kickstarter page, does it include all the parts to assemble the kit? or just part of them? or is this option never made available :P

djbengan 2014-11-03 16:21

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeffrey04 (Post 1445570)
iirc, i saw there's a self assembly kit in the kickstarter page, does it include all the parts to assemble the kit? or just part of them? or is this option never made available :P

I read it as it's everything you need except the 3d-printed casings and no lastubottom.

mrsellout 2014-11-03 16:36

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by djbengan (Post 1445600)
I read it as it's everything you need except the 3d-printed casings and no lastubottom.

Nor the magnets:

Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvl (Post 1445359)
Kickstarter update

...
Will be some more info on kick-page, but basically it is a pre-soldered pre-programmed TOHKBD without casing, magnets and wood. All files will be provided (all other people will get all files too, no worries!). This is an option for people that want to do customizations themself.
...


Kabouik 2014-11-03 19:12

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvl (Post 1445564)
It is because I do not have a definite answer to that. But, developer proto's are going to jollahq and Kimmo today, so we will see what is possible!

It is very hard for me to do promises about sw, as this is not my expertise (to understate the situation).

You shouldn't be shy about that! :) There is no problem answering that you cannot know yet, and that Kimmo or Jolla might perhaps better answer (I said that a few pages ago but they didn't answer either so it's still welcome if you can at least share what you know as the project leader). It's way better than avoiding the question by answering to altered/summed-up questions, as Pichlo said.

I'm not taking sides either, don't worry! :D I was very interested in this question too, and I definitely think it is part of the "customer ready" experience that as ben advertized. Your answer, even if you cannot promise anything yet, is still very valuable because it shows you noticed the concern and that it might still be on the to-do/to-investigate list, with no promise it can be achieved.

dirkvl 2014-11-03 21:28

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
https://dl.dropbox.com/s/yeckp7v63htwkgi/accepted.jpg

Dave999 2014-11-03 21:36

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Now or never.

WoW...its finally the final countdown! :D

Brilliant. Simply brilliant. Joey tempest edition.

Well Done and good luck!

14 hours and counting...

Will the perks be the same as before?

If so press...
http://vertassets.blob.core.windows....pay_button.jpg

dirkvl 2014-11-03 21:58

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave999 (Post 1445676)
Will the perks be the same as before?

even better

Kabouik 2014-11-03 21:59

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
No tell us when you plan to click on that freaking green button. :<

dirkvl 2014-11-03 22:04

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
http://gifcountdown.com/europe-amste...ue/counter.gif

vistaus 2014-11-03 22:14

Re: TOHKBD rev2
 
Your time: is that my time? 'Cause it says Stockholm but I'm still in my own city Almere :P

Anyway: YEAHHHH Can't wait for it now!!!! Hopefully these 13 hours will fly by!


All times are GMT. The time now is 15:34.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8