maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Jolla1 & TOH (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=56)
-   -   Jolla User Experience Thread (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=91875)

att 2013-11-29 16:30

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrsellout (Post 1390715)
If I'm not mistaken, the 'first use videos' showed there is a wizard, but probably a reviewer would get a device that's already set up.

Yes, the Welcome wizard will teach you to use the gestures/UI. You can also access the same material from Tutorial app.

att 2013-11-29 16:47

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lumiaman (Post 1390700)
How about all the crashing he describes? Several people have mentioned it here too. That is unacceptable for a competitive OS, no matter how beta it is. To produce such a device just give it to developers, clearly not ready for prime time. N9 all over again. Based on these reviews, Jolla folks have NOT learned their lessons. Too bad. But this is not a good beginning. They had sooo much to prove and they put out an alpha device. Inexcusable.

I don't know what is your purpose for these messages. If you are truly concerned, you can try to help Mer and Jolla people in many ways.

Based on your definitions iPhone, Android and Windows Phone have all been total failures. iPhone was so bad at the beginning that Steve Jobs' lauch event for iPhone was very precisely planned and written. For example Jobs changed iPhones multiple times during the event so people wouldn't see iPhone actually crashing all the time. Even WP/Lumia cannot hold your definitions.

There has been problems with Jolla and I hope that Jolla's people will fix them soon. I will be writting some feedback for Jolla when I have time. Hopefully soon. I want to influence to the journey of Jolla.

juiceme 2013-11-29 17:08

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Of course there are going to be bugs, the Jolla device/SailfishOS combination is in beta phase. I am even collecting a bug list here so the glitches can be collected and solved easier.

However, what I have not yet once encountered is spontaneous crashes/boots. I do not understand where you get those from :)

About the UI concept; I use N9/Harmattan extensively, as it was my only mobile OS for 2 years before Jolla, and I find the Sailfish gestures very familiar, an extension of what I have been using all the time. The UI is very easy to use and adapt to, and really natural for me.

shmerl 2013-11-29 17:11

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
I hope Jolla gets the hint, that collecting bugs that way instead of a proper bug tracker doesn't look good for them :)

mariusmssj 2013-11-29 17:11

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
So, Jolla, what are you working on now? 'There are things that the world hasn't seen yet' ZDNET

buenavista62 2013-11-29 17:18

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Regarding E-Mail sync I've got a question: Why is for instance the iPhone able to receive emails as soon as they come (don't need to set a sync intervall) and N9 (and Jolla) aren't. What differences are there that the iPhone is able to do it and Jolla not?

ggabriel 2013-11-29 17:23

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by buenavista62 (Post 1390747)
Regarding E-Mail sync I've got a question: Why is for instance the iPhone able to receive emails as soon as they come (don't need to set a sync intervall) and N9 (and Jolla) aren't. What differences are there that the iPhone is able to do it and Jolla not?

It uses push. Perhaps even this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Push-IMAP

juiceme 2013-11-29 17:26

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by buenavista62 (Post 1390747)
Regarding E-Mail sync I've got a question: Why is for instance the iPhone able to receive emails as soon as they come (don't need to set a sync intervall) and N9 (and Jolla) aren't. What differences are there that the iPhone is able to do it and Jolla not?

I am not familiar with iPhone, does it work that way with all accounts or does it need some "special apple email account" to work with; specifically what is the mail protocol used?

What I use myself, is maybe the most common portable combination, imap/ssl for incoming mail and smtp/ssl for outgoing mail. IMAP is a client-originating protocol, so the client needs to poll the server for mail.

Either apple uses some server-notification method or it polls the IMAP server with short interval (few seconds?) for incoming mail. If it is the latter, I am sad for the battery usage :o

Penguin 2013-11-29 17:26

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
I found gestures difficult to understand when someone else (from Jolla) presented those. I tested few of them with demo phones on Wednesday and already earlier two weeks ago, but it still felt like learning curve is significant. Wednesday when I got my Jolla I did exercises in wizard (available in tutorial app too) and since that this has been the most intuitive UI.

I love that you can use this with left or right hand and all gestures work naturally with both hands. I even switch the Jolla from hand to another depending what else I am doing while using it.

Browser experience is currently a disappointment. It lags and same intuition is not tangible in that app. Of course same gestures work, but I would expect to be able go pages back and forward just by swiping and that location bar and other controls could show up just with simple tap and other simple gesture. May be I will learn but currently I feel some inconsistency in the browser.

About battery lifetime.

9:30 (EET) this morning I took my Jolla from charger with full 100 % charge. I installed Skype (Android app) from Amazon AppStore and chatted with a friend for 10 minutes and browsed different settings may be 15 minutes.
11:30 battery level was 85 % after being rest if the time idle
11:55 I switched Location OFF from settings at battery level
76 %
12:26 battery level 1 % down since switching location off
12:30 my Jolla started jamming so badly I had to restart it. Battery level 72 %. I used phone to read twitter notifications and to use twitter with browser for 20~30 minutes (WiFi).
13:42 battery level 69 %
17:00 battery level 54 %. reading messages 15 minutes while connected via 3G. Download and installation of What's my IP address from Jolla store (3G and Jolla in moving car).
19:14 battery level 35 %
19:25 battery level 33 %. Playing with display brightness settings and switching to manual and minimum. I can barely see any difference between minimum and maximum.
20:29 battery level 26 % after 3 minute Skype audio call and idling an hour.

juiceme 2013-11-29 17:30

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ggabriel (Post 1390751)
Quote:

Originally Posted by buenavista62 (Post 1390747)
Regarding E-Mail sync I've got a question: Why is for instance the iPhone able to receive emails as soon as they come (don't need to set a sync intervall) and N9 (and Jolla) aren't. What differences are there that the iPhone is able to do it and Jolla not?

It uses push. Perhaps even this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Push-IMAP

But wouldn't this mean that the device has to be on DCH (or at least on some common signalling channel) all the time, it would reserve radio resources all the time...?

ggabriel 2013-11-29 17:36

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by juiceme (Post 1390755)
But wouldn't this mean that the device has to be on DCH (or at least on some common signalling channel) all the time, it would reserve radio resources all the time...?

I'm not 100% familiar, just stating what I have/use. My iPhone does use IMAP with push, and guess what? It uses _a lot_ of battery. Apple is very good at giving you updates that make it worse even.

I believe iOS 5 made the push function way worse than it was in iOS 4, at least in my experience. iOS 6 even worse than 5, and I haven't upgraded to 7 because I need to read yet again the T&C's and I can't be asked.

My N9 (that's my personal phone), however, uses a schedule, but not for technical reasons, I just don't want ot be bothered every-single-time I get an email :-)

Penguin 2013-11-29 17:41

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by juiceme (Post 1390752)
I am not familiar with iPhone, does it work that way with all accounts or does it need some "special apple email account" to work with; specifically what is the mail protocol used?

What I use myself, is maybe the most common portable combination, imap/ssl for incoming mail and smtp/ssl for outgoing mail. IMAP is a client-originating protocol, so the client needs to poll the server for mail.

Either apple uses some server-notification method or it polls the IMAP server with short interval (few seconds?) for incoming mail. If it is the latter, I am sad for the battery usage :o

IOS7 (in iPhone and iPad) supports push messages from iCloud and Exchange server but IMAP works either with scheduled polling or manually depending on account specific configuration. IMAP protocol supports push with IDLE and NOOP commands (http://www.isode.com/whitepapers/imap-idle.html)

kollin 2013-11-29 17:41

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Zendesk works, i encourage you guys, post all of your problems there!
Here is my conversation with zendesk:

Code:

##- Please type your reply above this line -##

[Jolla Service and Support] Re: Caldav/cardav sync?

Your request (#1259) has been solved. To reopen this request, reply to this email or click the link below:
https://jolla.zendesk.com/requests/1259

----------------------------------------------

Jolla, Nov 29 13:14 (EET)

Hi,

thank you for your message.
At the moment we do not support this, but we're working on it so that we can support it in the future.

When you add your google account your google calendar should automatically be updated.

Have a great day!

Sincerely,
Jolla Customer Care

Yst=C3=A4v=C3=A4llisin terveisin,
Jolla Asiakastuki

Join the Movement @ jolla.com
Like @ facebook.com/jollaofficial
Follow @ JollaHQ

----------------------------------------------

kollin, Nov 25 19:28 (EET)

Hello,
Would you tell me please: Is it going to be possible to sync my Jolla device with google calendar and contacts via caldav and cardav?
Thank you!
Best regards:
Kamen Dokov

--------------------------------
This email is a service from Jolla Service and Support.

;)

mikecomputing 2013-11-29 17:41

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pycage (Post 1390569)
In daily use, I found the battery life to be comparable to N9, maybe a little better.
Probably future upgrades will improve this. In some rare cases Alien Dalvik might wreak havoc. You'll notice this when your device gets warm and the battery level drops noticeably fast. A reboot or restarting the aliendalvik.service fixes this, though.

...or not using androidapps ;)

Now seriously,seems there is no native spotify app for example?

I guess the we the community can make that happen using the officially libspotify API.

I mean as much as possible must be ported tto sailfishos. The more the better for all.

I am definitivly willing to pay for apps even closed if its native apps.

kinggo 2013-11-29 17:46

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
paid apps are not allowed in the harbour, at least for now, if I'm right. :confused:

Thoke 2013-11-29 17:46

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
One thing I'm interested at is that will the battery life of the Jolla phone be better when the ACL is not installed/running.

ggabriel 2013-11-29 17:47

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mikecomputing (Post 1390766)
Now seriously,seems there is no native spotify app for example?

I think work in progress https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0CBXylyjzA

att 2013-11-29 17:49

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kinggo (Post 1390768)
paid apps are not allowed in the harbour, at least for now, if I'm right. :confused:

I have understood that Jolla Store (harbour) doesn't currently support payments but you can still implement your own payment solution inside the app.

Penguin 2013-11-29 17:54

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by szopin (Post 1389761)
Love the peekabo by 1020 inm the third photo. Old age catching a glimpse of new one. Also uber orange.. Though my bet is on oversaturation by 1020

Depends on the screen used to view. On my 1020 the original photo looks more orange than the real Other Half. On my iPad screen the photo looks less orange than the actual. Anyway the actual color is really uber orange. Or Poppy Red as the official name of color was written in package label.

mikecomputing 2013-11-29 17:56

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pycage (Post 1390666)
I still don't have a good idea of how to do it right. Flooding the screen with hundreds of entries is probably not the right thing to do. :)
Suggestions are welcome.

make it optional atleast?


https://github.com/nemomobile/eventfeed

shmerl 2013-11-29 17:58

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by buenavista62 (Post 1390747)
Regarding E-Mail sync I've got a question: Why is for instance the iPhone able to receive emails as soon as they come (don't need to set a sync intervall) and N9 (and Jolla) aren't. What differences are there that the iPhone is able to do it and Jolla not?

E-mail didn't yet get a proper open and standard protocol for duplex e-mail notifications (push). The only close approximation is IMAP IDLE, which is close in the idea to XMPP BOSH. It's not really a proper solution, just a workaround but it works good enough until better protocols will be designed. Jolla should probably support it.

It's weird though, that in this day and age such thing isn't ready still.

UPDATE: There is apparently this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemonade_Profile

Lumiaman 2013-11-29 18:06

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by att (Post 1390728)
I don't know what is your purpose for these messages. If you are truly concerned, you can try to help Mer and Jolla people in many ways.

Based on your definitions iPhone, Android and Windows Phone have all been total failures. iPhone was so bad at the beginning that Steve Jobs' lauch event for iPhone was very precisely planned and written. For example Jobs changed iPhones multiple times during the event so people wouldn't see iPhone actually crashing all the time. Even WP/Lumia cannot hold your definitions.

There has been problems with Jolla and I hope that Jolla's people will fix them soon. I will be writting some feedback for Jolla when I have time. Hopefully soon. I want to influence to the journey of Jolla.


Hey dude, which century do you live in. It's been 7 years since Jobs and iphone. Certain things are taken for granted now by the average Joe. The 99 percentile will not be happy with beta and alpha versions of email app. The current Jolla is clearly a developers tool, not very day device for average Joe.

MartinK 2013-11-29 18:08

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Well, if someone calls you, you are identified at once. So the same should be true for emails. The only issue could be the volume of the incoming email, making this infeasible (SPAM DDoSing the mobile network ;) ).

kinggo 2013-11-29 18:11

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by att (Post 1390771)
I have understood that Jolla Store (harbour) doesn't currently support payments but you can still implement your own payment solution inside the app.

uh....... that is something I really hate. A very sneaky way to actually rip off customer who was lured with "free" app just to realize that after XY levels there's no more unles you pay something.
It makes sense for buying tables (an actual whole new game) in pinball arcade but buying 5 moves in candy crush for 1.20$ is :eek:

ggabriel 2013-11-29 18:12

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
FWIW: http://www.engadget.com/2013/11/29/a...;ncid=rss_semi

(they'll have a video at some point)

kinggo 2013-11-29 18:18

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lumiaman (Post 1390783)
Hey dude, which century do you live in. It's been 7 years since Jobs and iphone. Certain things are taken for granted now by the average Joe. The 99 percentile will not be happy with beta and alpha versions of email app. The current Jolla is clearly a developers tool, not very day device for average Joe.

well, certain things were granted in 2007 also. Certain thing were granted when WP7 came out. What's your point?

qwazix 2013-11-29 18:19

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Regarding the verge review, the guy is complaining that gestures from outside do different things than gestures inside an app.

Duh! Then what would be the point of outside gestures? If they weren't really nice and productive neither apple (ios7 control center), google(chrome) mozilla(latest FirefoxOS), nor BlackBerry (BB10) would have implemented them.

So it isn't even unfamilliar (which he confuses as unintuitive) while the exact same gestures on the N9 were unfamilliar back then.

Comparing everything with android and saying they should go with it is stupid, it's like saying that all other car manufacturers should stop producing their cars and quit because the corolla is the most popular car in the world.

Regarding email push, N9 had perfectly good push email functionality. (In fact it was the only part of fenix I liked) My gmail messages appeared faster on the N9 than the GMail web interface.

ggabriel 2013-11-29 18:21

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
engadget also complains about the UX, but they are known to be fandroids, so...

Personally, it took me 5 minutes (yes, 5) to get used to the N9 and I could never go back. In fact, I keep trying to wake up my iPhone with a double tap. I estimate that Jolla will be another 5 minutes to get used to. The question is whether I could still go back to the N9 seemlessly ;-)

EDIT: engadget is still trying to upload their video. They are probably using an S3 or something or other ;-)

malkavian 2013-11-29 18:24

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by juiceme (Post 1390752)
I am not familiar with iPhone, does it work that way with all accounts or does it need some "special apple email account" to work with; specifically what is the mail protocol used?

AFAIK, Apple have one or more servers to get messages from all user push services, and resend them to his/her mobile. The advantage of this is that the phone have an unique push channel openned, consuming less battery in net connections and a bit less CPU and memory to mantain push channels opened. Also affect less to the lack of decent multitasking.

jalyst 2013-11-29 18:36

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
*cross-post*

Quote:

This really deserves it's own thread, & is probably not entirely on-topic here, but see this: Play Store for Jolla
(my absence didn't last long, ugh....)

shmerl 2013-11-29 18:43

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Playstore is surely useful for those who rely on Android heavily. I still didn't get, why Jolla couldn't at least ask Google about making it officially. Is there some internal tension inherited from Nokia days? Or Google is too strict with requirements for official deployment?

kollin 2013-11-29 18:54

""Google play " for jolla!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jalyst (Post 1390798)
*cross-post*

From here: http://jollafin.blogspot.fi/2013/11/...for-jolla.html


Quote:

Play Store for Jolla
You need: Time, Jolla and Computer
WARNING: You do this youself. I dont give guarantee, but it works on me.
TAKE BACKUP FROM /opt/alien/system
  1. Enable Jolla Developer Mode and allow SSH-connection.
  2. Download http://goo.im/gapps/gapps-jb-20121011-signed.zip and extract it.
  3. Plug your Jolla with USB to computer in normal mode.
  4. Copy system-folder from your extract files to Jolla.
  5. Open SSH-connection to your phone and login.
  6. Write "devel-su" and press enter. After that, write your password.
  7. Write command: rsync -av --ignore-existing /home/nemo/system /opt/alien
  8. Reboot phone
  9. Install Google Play services to Jolla
  10. Install Google Play Store to Jolla
  11. Start Play Store and do updates
.
;)

thedead1440 2013-11-29 18:59

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shmerl (Post 1390800)
Playstore is surely useful for those who rely on Android heavily. I still didn't get, why Jolla couldn't at least ask Google about making it officially. Is there some internal tension inherited from Nokia days?

If you have been reading around, Google are using Play as their way of closing things up so if you want Play and related services you would need to be a signatory of Open Handset Alliance which would prohibit Jolla from using any OS other than Google's Android...

rob_kouw 2013-11-29 19:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by qwazix (Post 1390791)
Regarding email push, N9 had perfectly good push email functionality. (In fact it was the only part of fenix I liked) My gmail messages appeared faster on the N9 than the GMail web interface.

Right so. I have no trouble with mail on my N9, reading 2 Exchange accounts, 1 GMail, 2 IMAP. OK, there is no copy/paste from e-mails received. Hope Jolla solved that and copied the approach on Accounts, which enables me to switch off mail sync for some accounts while in holiday.

(Lumiaman, what are you looking for? You don't seem to find much happiness here. Must be terrible to be drawn in here time and time again.)

att 2013-11-29 19:01

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shmerl (Post 1390800)
Playstore is surely useful for those who rely on Android heavily. I still didn't get, why Jolla couldn't at least ask Google about making it officially. Is there some internal tension inherited from Nokia days?

It might have been a strategic decision. They want to offer an option for the operators to implement their own stores (both sailfish and android), and they might have wanted to encourage third parties to do native sailfish applications.

tissot 2013-11-29 19:02

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shmerl (Post 1390800)
Playstore is surely useful for those who rely on Android heavily. I still didn't get, why Jolla couldn't at least ask Google about making it officially. Is there some internal tension inherited from Nokia days?

Well yeah maybe at least asking them would have not hurt, but Google wants it all. There was example talk about when Nokia joined WP, that one of the reasons they did not join Android was that Nokia could not make Nokia Maps default on their phones. Or think about Kindle and how that isn't licensed by Google.

What do you think Google would think about Jolla's own OS and it not using Google maps?
Personally I don't need or want any Google services to my Jolla, so I'm fine.

jalyst 2013-11-29 19:03

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kollin (Post 1390803)

I already linked to that post in my last post, but I focused on the comments.
One can just scroll up from the comments to see what you've posted...

Quote:

Originally Posted by thedead1440 (Post 1390804)
If you have been reading around, Google are using Play as their way of closing things up so if you want Play and related services you would need to be a signatory of Open Handset Alliance which would prohibit Jolla from using any OS other than Google's Android...

Yeah that's well known, but in one of his recent interviews Stefano(?) intimated that they didn't even "try" to have discussions with them.
They just ruled-it-out automatically, that seems wildly irresponsible to me...

qwazix 2013-11-29 19:06

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Thank god they didn't. Look what happened to acer. If I wanted google controlling my phone I'd buy android (where I incidentally have more choice and better specs).

Thoke 2013-11-29 19:07

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
No company is going to help their competitor to succeed.

mikecomputing 2013-11-29 19:07

Re: Jolla User Experience Thread
 
Anyone tested BT headset?


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:22.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8