maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Development (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=13)
-   -   Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reality (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=15962)

ertszi 2008-02-04 20:47

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Benson (Post 138111)
Don't think it'd work that well. DJS spoke of the NASCAR system using GPS and accelerometers. The accelerometers get you short time-scale, and the GPS long time-scale. You can't use (consumer-grade, wiimote-ish) accelerometers alone for long time-scales because of the double integration. Basically, your velocity error increases with time, and then your position error increases as the square of time, so you need GPS to correct it.

Well I have heard that WII remote accelerometer is very good, but how its performs at track is different story. It needs to bee tested.

There are ways to reduce this "position error as the square of time" dilemma at race track.
Simple way it's users sync as new lap starts users taps screen, preses button or plays a sound.
Little advance method would bee use WII IR leds, but if WII IR can't receive its more tricky.

As in map or navigation mode it should bee hard to correct your position every now and then. When we have tested results how long accelerometer error stays in reasonable rates. We can time gps or users syncs accordingly.

Does somebody actually know more about WII remote. How sensitive it is, can it be programmed in any way, Whats is power consumption in active use, Does it draw more or less power than gps receiver ?

ghoonk 2008-02-05 01:56

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ertszi (Post 138086)
Forget GPS and use WII remote. There is already many projects + maemo garage projects Py Axel Wii (http://pyaxelwii.garage.maemo.org/)

Well you could use gps for accuring and sync location coordinates when you are standing still (GPS accuracy as it best). I believe this could be great feature for maemo mapper as well. N800 users wouldn't even need gps because they could just point out start position at map layout. Thats assuming they know where they are.

Good idea, but let's not get ahead of ourselves here. I already have a Performance Box and this is one of the most accurate units out in the market for motorsport datalogging applications, using only a 5Mhz receiver, and built-in accelerometers to carry out lap timing and GPS datalogging. The log file can be analyzed using the PerformanceTools software suite on the PC, which prompted me to wonder if a similar application concept could be executed by the Internet Tablet.

As mentioned previously, this project is meant to offer a low-cost alternative to motorsport enthusiasts and not as a replacement for more accurate logging tools such as the PerformanceBox. Seeing that the cost of the N800 is going anywhere but up, with prices falling to under USD250 a unit, adding a USD99 GPS receiver and a USD75 16GB SDHC card will turn the N800 into a personal navigation device, a portable media player, a mobile internet tablet and a motorsport datalogging and analysis tool.

The challenge here today is not whether the Wii controller (which I agree is a great idea) would make a good enhancement to the setup, but if we can find a developer to help bring this idea to fruition.

My offer stands to help bring this project to light, and seeing that I lack the necessary skills for development, a partner is sought in this area to help make this concept a reality. I, for one, know that the iT has the capabilities for datalogging and analysis, as well as display of real-time information based on live data feeds from the GPS receiver as well as other sources such as an OBD-II port.

Benson 2008-02-05 14:18

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ertszi (Post 138145)
Well I have heard that WII remote accelerometer is very good, but how its performs at track is different story. It needs to bee tested.

There are ways to reduce this "position error as the square of time" dilemma at race track.
Simple way it's users sync as new lap starts users taps screen, preses button or plays a sound.
Little advance method would bee use WII IR leds, but if WII IR can't receive its more tricky.

As in map or navigation mode it should bee hard to correct your position every now and then. When we have tested results how long accelerometer error stays in reasonable rates. We can time gps or users syncs accordingly.

Yes, I meant INS with no GPS. With GPS for stability, the accelerometer data is great -- it fills in the details you don't get from GPS. Syncing at a fixed point on the track w/o gps is harder, if you're going by at >100 mph,you can't hit a button with reliable enough timing.
Quote:

Does somebody actually know more about WII remote. How sensitive it is, can it be programmed in any way, Whats is power consumption in active use, Does it draw more or less power than gps receiver ?
It's BT, so no power draw from the N8x0 at all. I'm sure it's less power total, but I assume you'd be hacking it anyway, and hardwiring it to power from the car, so I wouldn't think total power matters.

ghoonk 2008-02-05 14:46

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
Okay, we will need to assume that the unit will be plugged into the car charger. A Wii controller would offer the ability to measure lateral G and acceleration/deceleration.

Marcelo, do you know any developers who would be keen to take on such a project?

ghoonk 2008-02-09 04:18

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
I'm cross-posting this over to Apps in the hope for better exposure...

lardman 2008-02-09 10:53

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
How much are Wii controllers and an OBD2-Bluetooth connection? Can they both be connected at the same time?

If they are cheap enough, people might buy them and play around just for fun, otherwise cost is probably a limiting factor for most people, especially if they don't really have a goal in mind.

The other limiting factor in my case is that I don't think I have an OBD2 port. Buying a new car to rectify that little issue makes it even more expensive ;D

lardman 2008-02-09 10:59

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
Ok, so I see one can get a BT OBD2 scanner for ~£100.

Not too expensive, but certainly enough to need a definite project to use it with.

ghoonk 2008-02-09 14:23

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lardman (Post 140182)
How much are Wii controllers and an OBD2-Bluetooth connection? Can they both be connected at the same time?

If they are cheap enough, people might buy them and play around just for fun, otherwise cost is probably a limiting factor for most people, especially if they don't really have a goal in mind.

The other limiting factor in my case is that I don't think I have an OBD2 port. Buying a new car to rectify that little issue makes it even more expensive ;D

Most cars today have an OBD-II connector. What are you driving? perhaps it has a CAN BUS instead of OBD-II?

lardman 2008-02-09 23:46

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
It's probably proprietary (what little bus data there may be), a 1996 Renault Clio RSi.

I hope to buy something new(ish) in the next few months, then my interest in looking at OBD data will no doubt increase (vehicle driveability analysis was my PhD, this would have been useful back then :)

ghoonk 2008-02-10 04:08

Re: Motorsport Performance Application - looking for developer to bring idea to reali
 
You're right, Google doesn't return any relevant results on the 1996 Clio using CAN or OBD-I/II.

Any developers keen to take up this project? This has commercial potential, and I would be happy to assist in marketing the software across various online motorsport forums


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:47.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8