maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N900 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   Why can't N900 play videos smoothly? (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=48454)

shadowjk 2010-03-27 18:14

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
N900 plays 480p .mp4 files downloaded from youtube perfectly smooth for me.

BTW, 600MHz P3 is much faster than 600MHz Cortex A8 for general compute.

byte_76 2010-03-27 18:17

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mikec (Post 584482)
The N900 plays Videos beautifully, and at better than DVD quality remember the resolution of the display. However the codecs will not support anything over 800x480.

Try some that I made up

on the fast cars thread

http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php...ight=fast+cars

Many of these were transcoded from FLVs

Thanks I will try these and report back.

My videos definitely have a lower resolution than 800x480 otherwise, as mentioned, they would not play. The quality is close but not quite DVD quality.

The Vivo videos on YouTube are the kind of quality I'm reffering to. Does anyone agree with me that it is reasonable to think that N900 should be able to handle that?

extent 2010-03-27 18:26

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
it may also be down to the player you are using and not the N900s capabilities-try a dedicated player if there is one for the files you want to play, or try kmplayer. you could also wait for the official release of vlc player, which should be able to handle almost all video files, and give an indication of whether the N900 is really up to the job or not. the N900s built in player seems to jump/skip with some videos that work fine on a pc, although strangely it does not seem to always be a high bitrate or high resolution issue with all types of video

slobodsky 2010-03-27 18:59

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
If you want smooth playback you have to transcode videos if they aren't in right format for standard player. It plays videos with DSP and more optimized for ARM while mplayer plays all with CPU. I use MPEG4 and MP3 codecs and avi or mkv containers. 800x450@25 fps and 3Mbit/s plays fine. I think you don't need better quality for this screen.
I played a 192Kb/s MP3 song with standard player and CPU load was about 40% @250MHz. Mplayer did the same with 70% @500MHz (through pulseaudio). And note that N900 don't use DSP for audio. All of this is just low level optimization for particular CPU.

LuckTR 2010-03-27 19:22

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
I have a great deal of movie backups in from avi, xvid for SD video and some h264 with AAC sound for HD. SD files are all various resolutions, none over 720x480 (DVD) moderate bitrates (1500 Kbits max. I think). My N900 plays them no problem. Just copy and paste o.O for the HD part, I am using format factory (free) to recompress to .mp4, resize from 1920:1080 to the screen resolution of 800:480. bitrate usually down to 2000Kbits. I am talking stock N900 here.

tonypercy 2010-03-27 19:35

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by byte_76 (Post 584489)
If I try to play large files which tend to be good quality, say 700MB movie for example (avi), the files do not play properly. The video is smoothe but slow, which causes it to fall behind the audio. This gets worse the longer the video plays. I'm using Mplayer with SiB.

I do not run anything else in the background while playing videos.

I have checked the CPU usage when videos are playing and it runs at 100% almost constantly until I stop the video and then it drops down to less than 5%

I have managed to play some videos smoothly but it's almost always the low quality videos. The videos that I really want to play almost always have video / audio sync issues.

As for flv have you read?

http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=43993

I'll address the other question when back on a PC. Most likely the resolution is too high though. My avi's are dvd rips.

tonypercy 2010-03-27 19:37

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
I also watch vids in offline mode.

achiral 2010-03-27 19:56

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by byte_76 (Post 584475)
Is there a simple way to check the details of my videos to find out if they are within a reasonable resolution and bit rate? The specific files I want to play on my N900 are flv files and I don't know where to see the info in question.

Do you get them by stream, or are they on the 32GB internal Memory, or are they on a SD Card?

attila77 2010-03-27 19:56

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
To get the facts straight:

1. Forget MHz/GHz. In the 21st century it is an almost completely meaningless indicator due to differences in processor architectures. Forget it. Really.

2. Only the built-in media player uses hardware acceleration. If you don't play it in that, it's not accelerated (=it's slow).

3. Flash will gain acceleration in 10.1 when it gets released for ARM.

byte_76 2010-03-27 22:42

Re: Why can't N900 play videos smoothly?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by achiral (Post 584625)
Do you get them by stream, or are they on the 32GB internal Memory, or are they on a SD Card?

My media files are on the 32GB internal storage.


All times are GMT. The time now is 05:44.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8