maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N800 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=25)
-   -   Why I won't buy n800's for my employees (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=8673)

iball 2007-08-10 01:15

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Ok, I'm just tired of folks whining about that one TINY functionality that was never intended for the device.
Seriously folks, you got microb now, use Google apps or something.
So everyone needs to stop whining about it and actually DO something about it.
Like porting over some of the better open source PIM applications.
For all my PIM needs, my N95 works just fine and syncs contacts and calendar info seamlessly over BT to my Mac.

loki 2007-08-10 01:21

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iball (Post 67192)
Ok, I'm just tired of folks whining about that one TINY functionality that was never intended for the device.
Seriously folks, you got microb now, use Google apps or something.
So everyone needs to stop whining about it and actually DO something about it.
Like porting over some of the better open source PIM applications.
For all my PIM needs, my N95 works just fine and syncs contacts and calendar info seamlessly over BT to my Mac.

sounds like a considered response :D
nice...

daihard 2007-08-10 01:24

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iball (Post 67192)
Ok, I'm just tired of folks whining about that one TINY functionality that was never intended for the device.

Nokia has two options. Side with you and ignore those "whiners," or listen to them and work out a solution for the future versions, if not right now. Just curious, how are you using your N800?

Quote:

Like porting over some of the better open source PIM applications.
For all my PIM needs, my N95 works just fine and syncs contacts and calendar info seamlessly over BT to my Mac.
Not everyone here is a programmer, in case you're wondering... ;)

iball 2007-08-10 01:38

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by daihard (Post 67195)
Nokia has two options. Side with you and ignore those "whiners," or listen to them and work out a solution for the future versions, if not right now. Just curious, how are you using your N800?

Reading ebooks, playing games, web browsing, occasional email use, Skype, VoIP, etc. Nothing PIM-related at all. That's what the cell phone and Mac are for.

Quote:

Originally Posted by daihard (Post 67195)
Not everyone here is a programmer, in case you're wondering... ;)

Neither are the thousands and thousands of Nokia S60/Mac owners. It's built into OS X by default.
Nokia even provides a downloadable N95 iSync plug-in from their website.
I've found syncing the N95 to a Mac to be far easier, faster, and less complicated than doing it in Windows XP/Vista.
And it relatively easy to add new BT devices to it as well. If Nokia decides to push ahead with a PIMP solution I'm sure it will follow the same set of industry standard support their smartphone range does and will sync up with the Mac easily as well.

daihard 2007-08-10 02:31

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iball (Post 67197)
Reading ebooks, playing games, web browsing, occasional email use, Skype, VoIP, etc. Nothing PIM-related at all. That's what the cell phone and Mac are for.

I don't want to pay extra for the data service provided by my cellphone carrier. The beauty of Internet devices like the N800 is to be able to use the existing Wi-Fi to pull information on the Internet. Apparently, this sentiment is shared by a lot of others on this forum, if for different reasons.

Quote:

Neither are the thousands and thousands of Nokia S60/Mac owners. It's built into OS X by default.
I am not sure why OS X is relevant here. Not everyone is a Mac user. The use of Google Calendar will set you free from any particular OS - that's part of the reason I'd love to be able to sync my GPE-calendar with Google Calendar.

iball 2007-08-10 03:08

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by daihard (Post 67211)
I am not sure why OS X is relevant here. Not everyone is a Mac user. The use of Google Calendar will set you free from any particular OS - that's part of the reason I'd love to be able to sync my GPE-calendar with Google Calendar.

It's relevant because after I said my N95 syncs perfectly with my Mac you then said not everyone here is a programmer.

And having a data plan with a cell phone provider or not concerns the PIM functions of a cell phone that syncs with OS X how?

But hey, I understand. You want Nokia to make an E800. Fine.
Perhaps that's what the next 800 "revision" will have when Sprint carries it with Wi-Max capabilities.

Now to address all the "we want real PIM" people:
Looking at the current Maemo roadmap for the N800 through the next two firmware releases, I'm not seeing any emphasis being put on PIM capabilities.
Join the developer mailing list and make that suggestion or get on the bug reports and list it as an "enhancement". Or port/create your own solution.
Posting your complaints here about a lack of PIM functionality in the N800 Internet Tablet isn't going to help get you what you want.

daihard 2007-08-10 03:19

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iball (Post 67220)
It's relevant because after I said my N95 syncs perfectly with my Mac you then said not everyone here is a programmer.

My comment about not everyone being a programmer was directed at your statement about porting/creating their own applications for the N800. :)

Of course, it would be nice if my cellphone carrier (Sprint) had the N95 available. That might even make me consider signing up for the data service, provided that the N95 is Linux-based and has the same flexibility that the N800 enjoys.

Quote:

But hey, I understand. You want Nokia to make an E800. Fine.
Perhaps that's what the next 800 "revision" will have when Sprint carries it with Wi-Max capabilities.
Well if Sprint does have a plan to carry the next-generation Nokia smartphones, I'm by all means very interested in it.

BTW, I have voiced my opinions on the Bugzilla list regarding the lack of the PIM capability of the N800. I'd also like to work on creating my own solutions, but I just don't have the time. I know, the same old excuse but it's true. :(

iball 2007-08-10 03:26

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by daihard (Post 67222)
My comment about not everyone being a programmer was directed at your statement about porting/creating their own applications for the N800. :)

Huh? That's now how it looks...go back and re-read your post again.

Quote:

Originally Posted by daihard (Post 67222)
Of course, it would be nice if my cellphone carrier (Sprint) had the N95 available.

They don't since it's a GSM phone and SPrint isn't a GSM carrier. Too bad for them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by daihard (Post 67222)
That might even make me consider signing up for the data service, provided that the N95 is Linux-based and has the same flexibility that the N800 enjoys.

Why does it have to be Linux-based? You want a Linux-based cell phone, go buy a Neo 1973 off the internet. Oh wait, Sprint doesn't carry it since it's a GSM-only phone.
There's TONS of software out there for the N95 (it's S60 3rd Edition, not Linux) and Nokia makes the SDK freely available for folks to roll their own software for it.
And I'd rather have an unlocked N95 on a month-by-month contract than a carrier-branded, locked N95 on a forced 2-year contract.
Makes it easier when one travels across the planet.

Quote:

Originally Posted by daihard (Post 67222)
Well if Sprint does have a plan to carry the next-generation Nokia smartphones, I'm by all means very interested in it.

I doubt it. Sprint is usually years behind the GSM phones in cell phones.
Switch to a GSM provider if you can.

Quote:

Originally Posted by daihard (Post 67222)
BTW, I have voiced my opinions on the Bugzilla list regarding the lack of the PIM capability of the N800. I'd also like to work on creating my own solutions, but I just don't have the time. I know, the same old excuse but it's true. :(

Excellent, it's been officially noted to Nokia then.
Whether or not they listen and implement is another story.

daihard 2007-08-10 03:39

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iball (Post 67228)
Huh? That's now how it looks...go back and re-read your post again.

It must be my bad, then. Well, you know my intention now.

Quote:

They don't since it's a GSM phone and SPrint isn't a GSM carrier. Too bad for them.
I realize that. Unfortunately, we're locked to Sprint partly because of the special discount we get from them based upon my wife's employer.

Quote:

Why does it have to be Linux-based?
Because I like Linux and the flexibility the Open Source model provides. Don't get me wrong - I'm not bashing Apple here. I do have a PowerBook myself. I'm just so much into the FOSS movement now, I'd love to have as much around me as possible Linux-based. But hey, it's just me...

Quote:

Excellent, it's been officially noted to Nokia then.
Whether or not they listen and implement is another story.
Thanks. I sure hope they listen. :)

iball 2007-08-10 03:49

Re: Why I won't buy n800's for my employees
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by daihard (Post 67234)
Because I like Linux and the flexibility the Open Source model provides. Don't get me wrong - I'm not bashing Apple here. I do have a PowerBook myself. I'm just so much into the FOSS movement now, I'd love to have as much around me as possible Linux-based. But hey, it's just me...


Thanks. I sure hope they listen. :)

I don't get this. If a company with a known history of supporting OSS releases a free-to-download-and-use SDK for a non-Linux operating system, that somehow makes it lesser than the FOSS model?
Someone even took the S60 3rd Edition SDK and ported the latest version of ScummVM to it! Nothing like having a small cell phone that plays Monkey Island 1-2-3 and Full Throttle.
I'm not seeing Microsoft releasing their Windows Mobile SDKs for "free use".
Gotta pay through the schnozz for those. Same thing with RIM and their Crackberries.


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:38.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8