maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Competitors (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016 (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=96464)

Ksero 2016-02-22 23:22

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Merienth (Post 1499513)
Just a sidenote rant: What the hell does last 10-20 days :eek: to deliver a phone,... the only product they sell?:mad: I nearly went back for the Z30 with 2 days on local and 5 days for amazon/ebay reseller. I hope they use their 10 days well, and polish it with some gold dust, or wthever.

I put the order on 2/1/2016, today they changed status from Paid to In Picking. I have little hope that I will receive in this week.

Edit: Ah, Jolla website use format MM/DD/YYYY, so it was 1st February.

pichlo 2016-02-23 11:11

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ksero (Post 1499529)
I put the order on 2/1/2016

Second of January? That's nearly two months!!! :eek:

Even if it were the first of February, it is still longer than the 20 days they give themselves. I find it outrageous in this day and age.

NokiaFanatic 2016-02-23 11:20

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
You'd be mad to buy a Blackberry. It's only a matter of time until Blackberry drop support for it.

chenliangchen 2016-02-23 12:09

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NokiaFanatic (Post 1499573)
You'd be mad to buy a Blackberry. It's only a matter of time until Blackberry drop support for it.

Nokia/MS dropped support of Maemo/MeeGo long ago, does it madden you or the users here?

chenliangchen 2016-02-23 13:07

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by californication (Post 1499516)
Hey! Please say, why? In my case I still don't know what to choose too. People say that BB is dead and unsupported. This things are discouraging me from BB. I want a good android support in just a few apps. Tbh I'm interested in Skype app only :D
And a native good folder music player. I haven't seen just a simple player like easyplayer from n900 :eek:

Z10 out performs Jolla in multiple ways, all listed below. In short, if you need to do a lot hacking or Linux terminal access then Jolla wins, other than that Z10 almost beat Jolla on every aspect. (Including native music player you mentioned.)

Hardware:

- Z10 has a much sharper screen.
- A better size.
- Feels more comfortable.
- Battery slightly smaller. (Only by 200mAh) However it's very easy and cheap to get another one or two official batteries. You can even get an official charger kit with another battery, it can charge battery directly with that kit, it also gives option to re-charge your phone from the battery in the kit and not swapping battery. It's very convenient, you can decide if you need to swap, or recharge.
- Z10's camera is not the greatest these days but better than Jolla's.
- Better build quality, better internal spec. (I don't care, but it's better.)
- Z10 natively supports all SD format. (You can fuse exfat on Jolla as well, not a problem.)
- Z10 supposed to work all over the world, including US.

Software:

- BB10 is more mature than Sailfish OS, By far. Less buggy.
- BB10 is polished in every aspect. Including much much better native gallery, music player, file management etc. It's far better than Jolla's native ones (even 3rd party perhaps). Native browser is also much better.
- Native app is better in BB10 (although not much) compare with SFOS. Unfortunately no native built skype.
- BB Hub is awesome (in BB10 only)

Android support is similar on both sides:

- Inside BB10 back bar can easily be hidden, gives more screen space.
- BB10 has a 4.3 runtime instead of 4.1 in Jolla.
- Jolla has a smoother experience in android overall.
- Jolla can install native Google play services, where BB10 can only use play store for downloading.

To sum up in everyday use Z10 is far better, but if you want something different and toy to play with, Jolla is a good toy, but both HW and SW are way behind.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Merienth (Post 1499521)
Just consider a WP. It has skype, music player and support. :D

Some pepople here might stone me to death and even funnier I bought a Jolla just now...

But if you find your Android apps counterpart, and don't care "walled garden" either, Windows might be ok.
It is not more unstable than iOS, and has nowdays a better app pool than BB.

Music Player in WP is not better than an alpha build.

Zune used to be fine on WP7, but since WP8 MS rebranded it into Xbox Music (Now Groove...) and native music player just sucks. It losts library and album arts and very buggy and slow. Mixradio's local player handles it better. I used to have a sd with 2000+ music and native player never scanned correctly, but MixRadio can. Groove on W10M is better than Xbox music but not by much. They are definitely worse than native BB10's.

californication 2016-02-23 17:11

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Wooow. Thanks! But this native player doesn't play music by folders, doesn't it? :p
Can I ask what model of Z10 you have? STL 100-1 or other? I heard there are a few differences.
And what with a call speaker? It's more louder than in n900? I'm really curious :D

tommo 2016-02-23 17:27

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by californication (Post 1499621)
Wooow. Thanks! But this native player doesn't play music by folders, doesn't it? :p
Can I ask what model of Z10 you have? STL 100-1 or other? I heard there are a few differences.
And what with a call speaker? It's more louder than in n900? I'm really curious :D

Stl 100-1 is the 3g version so I would really avoid that one. 100-2 is what we have in the UK and probably Europe and is the 4g model, 3 and 4 are for USA I believe so it depends where u are from or going!

nodevel 2016-02-23 17:34

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by californication (Post 1499516)
Hey! Please say, why? In my case I still don't know what to choose too. People say that BB is dead and unsupported. This things are discouraging me from BB. I want a good android support in just a few apps. Tbh I'm interested in Skype app only :D
And a native good folder music player. I haven't seen just a simple player like easyplayer from n900 :eek:

Just to chip in with the situation on Jolla:

Skype is one of the very few Android apps I use and it works fine - audio, video, chat, even my Bluetooth headphones. The version I have installed sometimes crashes when not used, but that is probably caused by the fact that I didn't allow it to access my contacts and to run as daemon. It never (IIRC) crashed during a call, though, so it's worth for me to keep the settings this way :)

Plus there is a native Skype chat plugin for the built-in messaging application, so you can have Skype chat integration like on N9(00).

There are quite a few native music players and of course a folder based one - Talefish - which even remembers your last position. There may be more folder based players, but this is the only one that I tried.

kingstu 2016-02-23 18:53

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
I have gotten a few blackberry devices and the Z10 is rather inexpensive now. It has HDMI out which allows it to be a portable video player. There is a Blackberry Media dock which chargers it and allows HDMI out which I find to be very useful in that regard. (The Z30 has USB Host capabilities which also supports USB audio, besides mass storage to make transferring files very easy.) I find many genuine accessories as well as 3rd party accessories to complement the Z10 to make it more useable and more useful.

elastic 2016-02-23 19:00

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Huh - always this discussions about comparing two complete different approaches.

All in all the Jolla and the Z10 are both usable devices even for a daily use. It always depends on what you're expecting ;-) - even my historic N8 is still good for talking, sms, web browsing and email plus playing videos and music and providing a decent camera ...

If you don't care about a closed system, want the better camera and a nearly perfect messaging/communication experience plus you want to play videos from the device through hdmi to your tv - go with the Blackberry

If you want a open system (mas o menos), want to use the terminal, supporting Linux, need a geek factor or just like the OS and want support the underdogs - go with the Jolla

They are both good for nearly everthing, like most smartphones are this days. If you care about how many seconds it takes to open an app (like some people around) I would advice to look on all the high end android devices around and be sure you get 16GB ram plus the newest, fastest and octa-core cpu ;-) so you will be able to run 120 video chats at one time ...

Come on guys (and girls maybe) we are talking about phones - if WebOS hasn't been abandoned I might still be using my pre an if Nokia had ever learned to built a solid USB port I might never have given away my N9 (hope it's doing well HtheB?)

Again my buying advice: Test both and take the one that UI and specialities fits better to your needs - both will do a decent job, and even if the OS will be not longer developed it will take some time before you'll have to replace it ...

Sorry for all the text - I just can't read any more about how bad this or that OS or the relevant hardware is ... It always depends on the user - my girlfriend didn't like Symbian, didn't like Meego, didn't like BB10 and Android neither - now is so happy with WP8 as there just nothing more she has to do as using and very rare updates (how boring ;-) )

Tsippaduida 2016-02-23 19:49

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by joejolla (Post 1499460)
Hello, where can I buy the Jolla Phone for 135€?

Don't know about 135 €, but if 100 € is not too much, check this out:

https://pood.elisa.ee/webshop/private/device/JOLLA

You might need to pay something for the delivery.

elastic 2016-02-23 20:12

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tsippaduida (Post 1499636)
Don't know about 135 €, but if 100 € is not too much, check this out:

https://pood.elisa.ee/webshop/private/device/JOLLA

You might need to pay something for the delivery.

If I get it right it's 100,- with 24months contract for new customers, 115,- for existing customers and 135,- for everyone without contract - all € - so if you don't need an Estonian sim - it will be 135,- no idea if they ship outside Estonia ...

californication 2016-02-23 20:12

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
I think I first try a BB and after Intex will release their phone I'll try Sailfish OS. It's hard to try Sailfish based phone, they are physically hard to find just for test.
Both are worth a lot.

@nodevel
I haven't see Talefish... oh it's a audio book player. Haha. Funny that it could be really good music player for me I guess :D

ibrakalifa 2016-02-25 01:17

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wrm (Post 1499398)
A year ago i had to make the same decision :) and got Jolla. With some memory managament tricks, its a perfect replacement for N9, just dramatically faster. Edit: downside of Jolla - screen and camera.

No one come closer to N9 UI, NO ONE, stupid Nok*a...

Tsippaduida 2016-02-25 12:10

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by elastic (Post 1499638)
If I get it right it's 100,- with 24months contract for new customers, 115,- for existing customers and 135,-

Could be, I was a bit hasty. They offer as identification option mobile-id (certificate in your SIM), but my Finnish mobile number doesn't work. Also tried to log in with my Finnish bank credentials (they support SEB, Swedbank, Danske and Nordea), but even that failed. I guess I would need Estonian bank credentials...

Too bad, I have not planned an trip to Estonia in the near future and I think I will not bother with it just to get fourth Jolla. Estonian mobile-id would be interesting though, not sure if I can get one just like that without Estonian ID. Now I regret that I haven't moved forward with Estonian E-residency.

Merienth 2016-02-25 22:04

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ksero (Post 1499529)
I put the order on 2/1/2016, today they changed status from Paid to In Picking. I have little hope that I will receive in this week.

Edit: Ah, Jolla website use format MM/DD/YYYY, so it was 1st February.

My shipping started 3 days after payment. ;):):D:D:D
I think they prepared some stock for MWC..

pasko 2016-02-25 22:48

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Merienth (Post 1499840)
My shipping started 3 days after payment. ;):):D:D:D
I think they prepared some stock for MWC..

Hi.
No, they didn't. Mine was paid on february the 8th and shipping started today.... I hope i'll get it next week.
Regards.

Merienth 2016-02-25 23:31

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pasko (Post 1499842)
Hi.
No, they didn't. Mine was paid on february the 8th and shipping started today.... I hope i'll get it next week.
Regards.

That doesn't contradict what I wrote. Because they might have prepared the stock to arrive for MWC, so they can deliver, when some more order might arrive usually.

Just a theory only...:)

Ksero 2016-03-19 00:18

Re: Jolla vs Z10 which to buy in 2016
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Merienth (Post 1499840)
My shipping started 3 days after payment. ;):):D:D:D
I think they prepared some stock for MWC..

So, do you received your Jolla Phone? I run from Z10 because of battery issue.
I tried Nexus 5 and SailfishOS, but it's to big for me. I wish to see 4.2 inch or smaller smartphone with SFOS on the board. Really! N9 is too old. :(
For now I will stay with Jolla until someone will port SFOS to smaller smartphone.


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:58.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8