maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Competitors (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   N900 vs Iphone. (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=31039)

myk 2009-12-26 01:09

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
One thing I really like about iPhone is the ability to change the SIM without a reboot.
Its so annoying that Nokia always puts the SIM under the battery.

But mostly I just miss a decent mapping app (google maps), and calendar/contacts sync that works.

The iPhone even has a much better command-line environment, including zsh.
(No point comparing n900 to an un-jailbroken iPhone, is there?)

But all is forgiven when I use the web browser.

Quote:

Originally Posted by yorg (Post 441723)
And by being open, the N900 can catch up really fast IMHO!

I see this is your first Maemo device :-)

mysticrokks 2009-12-26 08:15

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
so myk what calender/contacts software so you use on your pc..

i use outlook and works perfectly on both machines

Le_Petit_Lapin 2009-12-26 13:01

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
I wish people would stop saying that the n900's browser can just go to a flash site like youtube and be able to play videos in the browser like you would be able to on a desktop pc.

It cant. Its all jerky and skips while playing, which, unless you have an incredably ancient desktop pc, is not at all what you'd expect from a "desktop browser".

So please stop perpetuating this myth, as it will only lead to unsatisfied customers.

yorg 2009-12-26 13:12

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Le_Petit_Lapin (Post 442079)
I wish people would stop saying that the n900's browser can just go to a flash site like youtube and be able to play videos in the browser like you would be able to on a desktop pc.

It cant. Its all jerky and skips while playing, which, unless you have an incredably ancient desktop pc, is not at all what you'd expect from a "desktop browser".

So please stop perpetuating this myth, as it will only lead to unsatisfied customers.

I don't know if it is a myth. I know that I can go to a site and watch on line tv streaming without problems. Youtube may be jerky, but it must be a software issue since I can see other flash videos/streams ok.

edit: the problem seems to be with embeded videos. Watching videos in full screen seems to work much better.

snedley 2009-12-26 14:24

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
I have both phones as well, and carry both, and while I agree with just about everything the OP posted, I still find myself reaching for my iPhone more often. For example, the camera is too often too slow in snapping a pic, and I have a devil of a time getting it to show in the picture gallery. I often have to go into file manager to find it. Sometimes when a call comes in, it's stuck in sleep mode and takes so long to become responsive that I sometimes miss the call. If I'm in a place I am not familiar with and want to find a restaurant or a Kinkos or whatever, the iPhone will find my location quickly and light up what I'm searching for.

Then there's the email app.... Arrgh, iPhone blows it away.

So yeah, technically the N900 is miles ahead and I'm thoroughly enjoying having root access to it and doing neat things, but for the average person for everyday use, the iPhone just works. i.e., my wife has an iPhone and I'd never dream of telling her she should get an N900 instead.

noobmonkey 2009-12-26 14:29

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Le_Petit_Lapin (Post 442079)
I wish people would stop saying that the n900's browser can just go to a flash site like youtube and be able to play videos in the browser like you would be able to on a desktop pc.

It cant. Its all jerky and skips while playing, which, unless you have an incredably ancient desktop pc, is not at all what you'd expect from a "desktop browser".

So please stop perpetuating this myth, as it will only lead to unsatisfied customers.

have you got a broken n900? Or you are just grumpy lol...


I can go to youtube and watch it without jerky'ness. All fine :)

ok iplayer and some other sites don't work that well.. But youtube is fine :)

bugelrex 2009-12-26 15:07

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by snedley (Post 442119)
... Sometimes when a call comes in, it's stuck in sleep mode and takes so long to become responsive that I sometimes miss the call.

I haven't experienced this yet, just so I know what to expect, is it:
- one 1 or 2 rings only come through and the caller gives up
or
- that the phone app takes several seconds to launch to show the answer button

Guber99 2009-12-26 16:05

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gerbick (Post 316997)
No, it was not. However, I got one (never used) because I was in line for 20 minutes for a very simple swap from the first gen to the 3G that was pre-arranged with the AT&T district manager.

Tethering has yet to be turned on with AT&T, that was correct. But it's there... if you know what you're looking for. No jailbreak necessary either.

Transferring files to other machines - either use AirSharing or DataCase. Swap files via wifi. I was quick enough to get AirSharing and DataCase for free when they first debut.

I can't say whether or not the iPhone has stereo sound or not - I just don't honestly know the correct spec - but there are two speakers at the bottom. But I'd never listen to those speakers for music... no way.

iPhone comes with Maps preloaded. Maps, GPS, and directions.

iPhone has internet calling - Fring, Nimbuzz, Skype and GV Mobile (I got it before it was pulled). All are free (there's a pay for version of GV Mobile).

The GSM and data bands... Apple supports all of the major ones in the US. Nokia N900 supports the T-Mobile only ones so far - talk about locked in.

There are probably a few other points, but those stood out. But honestly, great work sachin007.


iphone does not support Tmobile GSM band.......N900 does

Guber99 2009-12-26 16:08

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sachin007 (Post 317018)
I understand.... but i am willing to make changes to the text if you can provide me the correct details
And the second thing will never change unless apple changes its policies on a number of things.

My problem with N900 is lack of search function, l can not get my corporate email (which I get easily on iphone, nokia e71 and e51), and iphone has a FANTASTIC search function. N900 has many loose ends to tie before it can be compared to iphone

fatalsaint 2009-12-26 18:48

Re: N900 vs Iphone.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Guber99 (Post 442172)
My problem with N900 is lack of search function, l can not get my corporate email (which I get easily on iphone, nokia e71 and e51), and iphone has a FANTASTIC search function. N900 has many loose ends to tie before it can be compared to iphone

Well .. there is that... or it could be said:

the iPhone has a completely different business model and totally different mindset to adopt before it can compare to the N900.....

Which do you think will happen first ;)?


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:52.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8