maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Jolla Tablet (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=60)
-   -   Jolla Tablet (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=94241)

juiceme 2015-01-30 09:19

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by aegis (Post 1458811)
If I'm carrying a laptop with me I don't need the tablet.

Yes, which means that the tablet needs to replace the functions of the laptop.
As it happens, my laptop has no removable sd card that I'd need to swap with other devices; --> no need for that in the tablet either.

aegis 2015-01-30 09:38

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by juiceme (Post 1458797)
Some people might want to swap cards between devices but I feel that is pretty ancient procedure... once I stick a card in my phone or tablet is pretty much stays there.

Whereas I remove mine regularly as it's the quickest way to get music on to the card on my Mac. Remember that Macs do not support MTP. SFTP is OK too provided your phone has developer mode on and you've installed horndis on the Mac to get USB networking.

Quote:

Originally Posted by juiceme (Post 1458797)
A camera is a bit different animal, I have several cards of course that I rotate; when one is full and I have no chance to empty it to my laptop I'll just put it in my pocket and stick in another.
On the evening I will then transfer the goodies to my computer via USB cable, not by putting the card into the computer which has no slot for it anyway :)

So, what I'd like to see is ability for the tablet to replace my laptop in this scenario; to act as USB master host so I can connect my camera to it, I have no need to swap cards between the devices.

That is fine provided your camera still has battery life and it's how I usually work also with laptops. For a tablet it'd need to support the camera's mtp/ptp mode. You're then backing up your images from your cards using the camera as an expensive card reader. But, where are you backing up too? The tablet has less space than the camera. Do we have external USB drive support yet in Sailfish? And which filesystems? ;)

USB transfer is old school for cameras though. My camera has wifi. There's an android app to control the camera remotely and transfer files. It doesn't work on Sailfish however because I think it sets up an adhoc network between android and the camera. That kind of networking doesn't appear to be supported by Sailfish's android layer.

So as I said earlier, I bought a Sony Z3 compact tablet instead because it works in all of the possible usage modes outlined above already. I'm not happy it's running Android but it's the least bad option and maybe one day Jolla will get out a sailfish port. As a mobile photographers aid it works and Jolla shot themselves in the head here.

aegis 2015-01-30 09:42

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by juiceme (Post 1458812)
Yes, which means that the tablet needs to replace the functions of the laptop.
As it happens, my laptop has no removable sd card that I'd need to swap with other devices; --> no need for that in the tablet either.

Neither does mine. It's an 11" Macbook Air. I use a USB3 card reader Which is also what I use with my Sony tablet and a USB otg cable.

juiceme 2015-01-30 09:55

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by aegis (Post 1458816)
You're then backing up your images from your cards using the camera as an expensive card reader. But, where are you backing up too? The tablet has less space than the camera. Do we have external USB drive support yet in Sailfish? And which filesystems? ;)

So it looks like you probably cannot ditch your laptop yet, huh?

I was thinking of the use case where you want to quickly upload something (a picture or a video clip) to the net, maybe doing some cropping/rescaling/transcoding before doing that.

nthn 2015-01-30 10:08

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by aegis (Post 1458816)
Remember that Macs do not support MTP.

Oh wow, really? Maybe you should upgrade to a better operating system. All these people complaining about exFAT being a standard and Jolla won't support it (out of the box) etc, but then an operating system that is ludicrously expensive (well, actually the hardware) that doesn't even support MTP (out of the box) is okay? How do you even connect any device that isn't an iDevice to it? I don't think you can really blame Jolla that their device doesn't work as it should with Fisher-Price computers.

Copernicus 2015-01-30 10:16

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Urgenus (Post 1458809)
It is Jolla who desided to listen only the loud minority, who does not want Jolla work like every other modern device...

Hmmn. Maybe the loud ones are actually secret agents from Android- or Windows tablet companies who don't want Jolla and Sailfish to become mainstream. :D

This.

This argument is what's driving me nuts. Folks can post all day long that they don't like the design of Jolla's tablet. That's fine. What's crazy here is when they argue that Jolla tablet isn't sufficiently similar to all the thousands of other tablets out there today. Not that it is inherently worse, but simply that it is different.

If you want a device that is exactly the same as an Android tablet, then honestly, you should just buy an Android tablet. If your top concern is reliability, please do not choose the first tablet designed and built by a startup company using an entirely new OS. If you're looking for the latest & greatest apps, you should check out the iPad.

If the only way for Jolla to go "mainstream" is to slavishly copy every design decision made by the big guys, I see no point for Jolla to exist in the first place...

nodevel 2015-01-30 10:18

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nthn (Post 1458820)
Oh wow, really? Maybe you should upgrade to a better operating system. All these people complaining about exFAT being a standard and Jolla won't support it (out of the box) etc, but then an operating system that is ludicrously expensive (well, actually the hardware) that doesn't even support MTP (out of the box) is okay? How do you even connect any device that isn't an iDevice to it? I don't think you can really blame Jolla that their device doesn't work as it should with Fisher-Price computers.

Oh well... Sorry for being the captain obvious, but...

When Jolla is the size of Apple (or Microsoft), they can push their own standards and 'not support' whatever they want, because manufacturers will try to support them.

Mentioning MTP is quite nice, as it was also made by Microsoft and there were quite a few comments on TMO complaining about Jolla supporting it :D

nthn 2015-01-30 10:29

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nodevel (Post 1458824)
Mentioning MTP is quite nice, as it was also made by Microsoft and there were quite a few comments on TMO complaining about Jolla supporting it :D

Exactly, which is why I think it's completely stupid to say "man, **** Jolla for not supporting *proprietary standard* supported by Apple, but I have no problem whatsoever with Apple not supporting *other proprietary standard* that is supported by Jolla". Consistency, please.

Copernicus 2015-01-30 10:29

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nodevel (Post 1458824)
Oh well... Sorry for being the captain obvious, but...

When Jolla is the size of Apple (or Microsoft), they can push their own standards and 'not support' whatever they want, because manufacturers will try to support them.

Ah. So, all devices not (a) designed by Apple or Microsoft, or (b) slavish copies of devices designed by Apple or Microsoft, are an automatic fail?

Just when did this become obvious? (And why should I want to live in a world where this is obvious?)

nodevel 2015-01-30 10:36

Re: Jolla Tablet
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Copernicus (Post 1458828)
Ah. So, all devices not (a) designed by Apple or Microsoft, or (b) slavish copies of devices designed by Apple or Microsoft, are an automatic fail?

Just when did this become obvious? (And why should I want to live in a world where this is obvious?)

Mind = Blown

How did you get this out of my post will likely remain a mystery till the end of time :)


EDIT:
To elaborate... I was reacting to a post saying "why to blame Jolla when even Apple doesn't support standards" (I am not gonna dig into whether MTP is a standard) by arguing that you cannot compare a small company to a large one. You might not want to live in this reality, but it is a fact that companies support iPhone rather than iOS supports other companies. I never said it was good, but that's just how it is.

Anyways, back to the original discussion:
This thread became a nice practice for the "hey, let me show you why it is great that you cannot transfer files from your camera to the tablet, because you have been doing it wrong all along", but the point was: it was a stretch goal, possibly thousands of people have contributed to reach the stretch goal and then many of those or other bought the tablet because this feature was promised. That is the problem.

EDIT 2: Just read pichlo's comment after my edit and 100% agree. I don't use Windows, I do not have cards larger than 32GB (yet), I did not buy the tablet for this reason. But I am sure many people did and they are not likely to appear on TMO to raise their concerns.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:43.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8