Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

You have never heard of an Exit Poll???

Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

I voted for everyone. You're a fine group.

As for the order of my vote, well, it's hard to say... ;)

Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

Yes I have but that doesn't mean it wont confuse some people.

Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

Really?

Title of thread clearly states "Exit Polls"

"Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls..."

The question clearly asks "Who did you vote for"

"Who did you vote for Maemo Community Council"

On top of that they get an EMAIL telling them to vote and how?

Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

Go back and look at the previous threads when people have wanted to vote. Perhaps people who aren't eligible to vote will think this poll has some meaning (when, at best, it's just YASOP[1]).

Of course, the comments should disengage them of that notion; but it's a bit odd; we've never had one before; it could reinforce certain voting patterns; it's potentially confusing and it's not - actually - "fun".

Instead of asking why so many people are saying it seems a bit peculiar and perhaps should be taken down/not down; perhaps you could say why you're so attached to an idea?

If this was me refusing to listen, you'd've been jumping up and down accusing a council-led cabal of not paying attention to the legitimate concerns of the "real" users! :-p

[1] Yet Another Sub-Optimal Poll :-)

Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

Again referring to Europe, exit polls in the voting day are allowed but they can't publish the results while the voting period is open. Precisely to avoid the influence to undecided voters.

Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

I think the major problem is that the poll was created by one of the candidates. If someone not affiliated with the election in progress had created it, it wouldn't have been such a big issue.

Tim

Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

I can understand the logic perhaps IF I were an admin and had some control over what the votes in this poll were. However this is just people voting, if they think its crap don't give your vote. Or vote completely opposite how you voted in the actual election its really just for fun.

In the US exit polls are run as people exit the voting facility. They are run by candidates on both side. The republicans will go to a heavily republican population and say "WE are winning" Then dems go to a highly democratic population and claim the same thing.

I am coming to a neutral place and saying hey who did you vote for? I have no ability to change the votes shown in this poll.

Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

Why not? Anyone can arrange an exit poll and publish the results. The question is whether these results are authoritative enough to trust the outcome.

Well, they're not, because they, by design don't have the same authentication and integrity measures as the real election. Both those who are polled as well as those who poll are able to meddle with the outcome of the exit poll. Exit polls are also never anonymous.

No, the issue is publishing real results (even partly!) while anyone is still able to vote. The outcome of this exit poll is not the real result.

Therefore, if someone would use non-maemo.org server to make some kind of exit poll we cannot moderate that. There is nothing we can do to stop that.

(My dislike of exit polls notwithstanding.)

Re: Sept 2009 Maemo Community Council Exit Polls...
 

Right, but you didn't just start a poll, you published your own votes. That can have a certain tendency to sway other voters because they either (a) trust you, or (b) don't.

Tim