maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   General (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=90116)

The Wizard of Huz 2013-05-18 15:13

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hurrian (Post 1344534)
[/I]....QQ... , which is also known to have a government backdoor.

As do Skype and Windows among others. Actual it is the first thing MS did after buying Skype, build in a backdoor for the government agencies.

Fuzzillogic 2013-05-18 15:35

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by The Wizard of Huz (Post 1344558)
Just for the sake of information, what closed standards of Apple are you talking about? What standards is Apple using that are closed?

Ah come on, almost their entire ecosystem is closed and now they're slamming extra locks on them as well. Much of their stuff might be reversed engineered or """open""" now (iTunes, iPhone docks, iMessaging, AirPlay) but just about all of it is under their exclusive control. Even well-established protocols as bluetooth have been implemented only partially at best. (Well, at least it was in older iPhones, which wouldn't allow dial-up/PAN networking, couldn't send/receive files etc)

What's more, their devices are locked up as well. Only Apple-approved software can be installed on iOS-devices, and can only be obtained from Apple. You need to pay up to be able to develop for your *own* device. And now they're expanding this scheme to the desktop as well!

mikecomputing 2013-05-18 15:37

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
Yet another reason to **** google :mad:

But I guess DanRamos and other still will say Google is SOOOO OPEN!

The Wizard of Huz 2013-05-18 16:36

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fuzzillogic (Post 1344573)
Ah come on, almost their entire ecosystem is closed and now they're slamming extra locks on them as well. Much of their stuff might be reversed engineered or """open""" now (iTunes, iPhone docks, iMessaging, AirPlay) but just about all of it is under their exclusive control.

On the software side I had never problem exporting music or other data from this platform (Mac). But apart from macs I don't use other Apple hardware. But I do know about iOS software install. The same as on WindowPhone. Or Windows RT. And don't even get started on the "Secure computing" (treacherous computing as Richard Stallman calls it) thing they are pushing. That is a HUGE blow to beginner linux users, who won't be able to just pop in a live cd and install something else than Windows.
And everybody excepts this behavior. Even linux users. They say what they always say, if you can't work around it you're a noob. (yeah I am aware that there is a work around to circumvent secure boot).

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fuzzillogic (Post 1344573)
Even well-established protocols as bluetooth have been implemented only partially at best. (Well, at least it was in older iPhones, which wouldn't allow dial-up/PAN networking, couldn't send/receive files etc)

The same as Nokia was doing until they started losing market share fast. The time when Motorola, Ericsson and Palm would work with any bluetooth device. But Nokia phone only worked nice with Nokia accessories.
But I agree that Apple should give full Bluetooth access.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fuzzillogic (Post 1344573)
What's more, their devices are locked up as well. Only Apple-approved software can be installed on iOS-devices, and can only be obtained from Apple. You need to pay up to be able to develop for your *own* device. And now they're expanding this scheme to the desktop as well!

Since when do you have to pay to be able to develop for your own Mac?

I guess they are following MS's lead there, to buy development tools to develop for your own desktop?

The Wizard of Huz 2013-05-18 16:38

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
Is there any good open source alternative that does the same or more as Airplay? Is DLNA an alternative. Not much do I know about Airplay.

NetBUG 2013-05-18 17:22

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
Yes, DLNA is a proper technology.

BTW Google did not still drop XMPP support yet.

Fuzzillogic 2013-05-18 17:32

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
AirPlay is meant to stream the A/V output of a device to another device, e.g. tv or stereo. While DLNA could do the same, DLNA is more meant as media server and player. The N9 does it remarkably well, thanks in great part to the built-in Rygel server. TweakUp and PushUp enhance its functionality even further.

DLNA is the commercial variant of UPnP. DLNA is more strict and has certification. But it's an open protocol and I use it several times a week to watch media stored in my linux nettop on my Samsung-tv, which has remarkable support for DLNA.

Weird thing is that Android doesn't seem to have DLNA/UPnP support out-of-the-box. It's up to the manufactures as HTC, Asus and Samsung to add this. From what I've seen that's not always as seamless as on the N9 and N95(!)

Also, Samsung is now promoting their own protocol for media sharing between their Android devices and tv's. I don't know whether this is an extension on DLNA, more like AirPlay, or something different altogether. It does however seem to be yet again another proprietary protocol adding to the vendor lock-in problem. Given their huge success with their mobiles it might seem like a good business strategy (like Apple, Microsoft, Google), but again bad for consumers.

Quote:

Originally Posted by NetBUG (Post 1344606)
Yes, DLNA is a proper technology.

BTW Google did not still drop XMPP support yet.

They won't drop XMPP (yet!), but they will drop XMPP-federation, according to Ars Technica.

Hurrian 2013-05-18 22:43

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by The Wizard of Huz (Post 1344589)
(yeah I am aware that there is a work around to circumvent secure boot).

Code signing and boot security has its own place in the users' toolkit.

Personally, I've added my own keys to UEFI, and am signing my bootloaders and kernels, and I've enabled Measured Boot, which means that binaries I didn't sign/don't have a trusted signature aren't run. (a la Aegis)

The problem is when manufacturers take away your control of the security mechanism, locking you in and taking away your ability to not-be-babied.
(See: iOS code signing, Surface RT, Verizon Droid*)

shmerl 2013-05-19 08:30

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
This really stinks. I'm not using Google Talk server, but my contacts do, and now they'll be cut off. Google are really evil now.

pali 2013-05-19 08:38

Re: Google drops XMPP support in its new chat/Talk/Hangouts
 
@shmerl: I do not see reason for people (like you) who do not using gmail jabber account - to create one. If gmail people in your jabber contact list really want to talk/chat with you, they will find some way... And if not - consider if they really want to talk... I really do not see any reason why we should be slaves of google's world...


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:49.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8