maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Alternatives (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=36)
-   -   [ POLL ] What OS would you prefer on your N900? Maemo5, Meego or NitDroid? (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=57363)

ysss 2010-06-29 15:52

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by vivainio (Post 734237)
Yes, to quote from those:



Why would you be content if there was a new system that has feature parity but is also newer and therefore (hopefully) better? Are people that blow $500 on a phone of the kind that would be "content" and therefore not interested in moving on, if given the chance (without paying extra)?

Because maemo is the only OS currently guaranteed to run flawlessly and effortlessly on N900.

As I said, future 'upgradeability' (in this case, to MeeGo) is still questionable in terms of its ease of installation/migration, (official) support and whether 100% of the (hardware and commonly expected) functionalities will be present on it.

vivainio 2010-06-29 16:58

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ysss (Post 734252)
As I said, future 'upgradeability' (in this case, to MeeGo) is still questionable in terms of its ease of installation/migration, (official) support and whether 100% of the (hardware and commonly expected) functionalities will be present on it.

Yeah - but the poll question was staged in such a fashion that the new OS would have feature parity. In that blue sky scenario, most people would switch.

digittante 2010-07-01 06:00

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pelago (Post 733828)
does the OP want to rename the thread to match the poll?

Sure, but the mods beat me to it.

jjx 2010-07-03 22:04

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lwa (Post 734043)
i can understand wanting to install other OS' out ouf curiosity and I'll try both android and meego when released when i get around to it on my N900, but I dont understand the people who want android more than maemo... you already had the option to have android running 100% on your phone and turned it down ...by buying a N900 instead

If someone bought the N900 hoping that Maemo would evolve, excited by the potential, and now sees that Android is getting better while Maemo isn't evolving as they'd hoped... then it makes sense.

jjx 2010-07-03 22:08

Re: [ POLL ] What OS would you prefer on your N900? Maemo5, Meego or NitDroid?
 
Here's the poll option I would prefer:

- The community puts together a hybrid containing the best features of all 3, and able to run apps from all 3 side by side.

Also, the Meego poll option should be two:

- Meego in "closed kernel but can run commercial apps" mode.

- Meego in "open kernel but can't run commercial apps" mode.

geneven 2010-07-03 22:22

Re: [ POLL ] What OS would you prefer on your N900? Maemo5, Meego or NitDroid?
 
I'm getting a 32gb card soon and so wouldn't "switch" to anything. I plan to try Android (Nitdroid) just for fun. I am starting to dislike Nokia more as time passes, so I won't try MeeGo for awhile.

I've been thinking that a cell phone should just be a cell phone, so my next far-out device will probably be a larger tablet -- but not an iPad. I will probably buy the Shasta Kindle, whatever that is, whenever it comes out.

But my ultimate goal -- something bigger than the n900, something not associated with Nokia, and something with some kind of Linux on it.

Descalzo 2010-07-03 22:25

Re: [ POLL ] What OS would you prefer on your N900? Maemo5, Meego or NitDroid?
 
I refused to vote because I can't get multiple options.

But I looked at the capabilities of Maemo and of Android and came into this with my eyes wide open. I'm not a developer. I haven't tinkered with the Linux X-Term since like 1998, and I had an iPod Touch and family members with Android devices, but still went with N900.

I like what Maemo does. I love it. But I look forward to triple-booting. I'd boot iOS and webOS, too if they were available.

RolePlayGame 2010-07-03 22:27

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Venemo (Post 733281)
Haha!

I would rather run Maemo 5 until the end of my N900's life than to pollute it with Google's s**t. (This is only my personal opinion about Google, I don't mean to insult the NITdroid developers.)

By the way, if the guys who port Android put their effort into MeeGo instead, it would be much better!

By the way, if the guys AT NOKIA put their effort into MeeGo N900 instead, it would be much better!

maxximuscool 2010-07-03 22:32

Re: [ POLL ] What OS would you prefer on your N900? Maemo5, Meego or NitDroid?
 
i'd run all OSs in my N900, Android, Maemo, and MeeGo. Why? Because i want them all. And it is good for learning to use all of 3 OS in one go, make you familiar with the OS. Also I can shut the hell up the FAN boy! lol when he said look my Android device is better or my meeGo is better. I would say ftw? look at my N900! I can run those OS which is a better device!

qwerty12 2010-07-03 22:34

Re: [ POLL ] What OS would you prefer on your N900? Maemo5, Meego or NitDroid?
 
NITDroid because I consider Nokia's stance to be the same as Google's on privacy, with PR 1.2 anyway. On the upside, at least I'd know that the applications coming with NITDroid would be open. (Mind, I could probably say the same about MeeGo reference)

On the other hand, Maemo 5 has GTK which'd want to make me keep Maemo - just for that, even - but its libraries are already aging and it's way too closed source for my liking.


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:10.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8