maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   MeeGo / Harmattan (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=45)
-   -   Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=69654)

patlak 2011-02-11 14:58

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ele-Mental (Post 942450)
Im uninstalling easy debian and power kernel. im gonna run it stock speed from now on...

Keep power kernel, just run it at the stock 600mhz with the lowest supported voltages of your N900. Will surely live even longer :)

ivlok 2011-02-11 15:13

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
I love my n900. But the writing is on the wall. Looks like we have 2 companies trying desperately to become relevant again. Can you smell the desperation? I can. MS sees its dominance in the desktop becoming less and less relevant in a world that doesn't need a desktop as much anymore. Nokia's has failed miserably in the smartphone world. Had they focused more on the n900 and maemo they may have been an option for consumers. After their failure to support the n900, why would anyone expect more from WP7. Pride goes before the fall and the unmitigated arrogance and ineptitude of these companies are coming home to roost. After the last few fails of these companies, and they way they have treated the "eco-system", I can't imagine any developers wanting to bother with these companies. They'll need to sell at least half a billion phones for anyone to bother. Epic tragedy.

ConiKost 2011-02-11 15:25

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
MeeGo is dead :(

jackburton 2011-02-11 15:28

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Will the existing Maemo closed-source components possibly be opened now?

madmaze 2011-02-11 15:29

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by patlak (Post 942473)
Keep power kernel, just run it at the stock 600mhz with the lowest supported voltages of your N900. Will surely live even longer :)

or just get a second one =) they are getting cheaper and cheaper

eiffel 2011-02-11 15:30

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jackburton (Post 942541)
Will the existing Maemo closed-source components possibly be opened now?

No chance at all now, unless WikiLeaks gets hold of the source.

twodice 2011-02-11 15:31

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
I actually like the idea of nokia and ms. Nokia still make the best hardware for me.Their build quality is great too

Lets not forget samsung take ages to release updates - e.g all the galaxy range ( and yes i own a tab and a galaxy s)

sony ericsson - look at the x10 and others, no 2.2 for them at all and no xda devs port so far.

lg - piss poor in general.

htc are ok but still make hardware which is questionable in terms of durability - screen issues and the old htc tytn 2/ nearly all htc phones video driver problem for which i have not forgiven them ( i owned a tytn2).

the only other option is th eiphone and ill be lloking closely at the iphone 5 but id rather a nokia build with wp7. ultimatley we all more or less started with win mo anyway so its just continuing the trend.

theres no need for anyone to abandon ship unless you think for some reason the grass is greener on the other side.

still happy with my n900.

mrojas 2011-02-11 15:38

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by joppu (Post 942471)

Holy crap...

msa 2011-02-11 15:39

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
i used to like wp7 (as far as i can tell), but i read in the wp7-wiki, that it doesnt allow custom ringtones...?! thats a dealbreaker for me.
to be clear: does that mean custom ringtones in general or custom ringtones for individual contacts?

ceaboust 2011-02-11 15:41

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
http://www.blogcdn.com/www.engadget....e-30-of-38.jpg
It was going to be MeeGo instead of "Windows Phone".


http://www.blogcdn.com/www.engadget....e-32-of-38.jpg
MeeGo R&D cut by a lot.
MeeGo will be turned into an "experimental" OS (just like maemo was...)

This sucks.
I'll ignore nokia for a couple years, probably won't visit this forum anymore (whats the point? lol)
I've started developing my android app and I've installed android on my old phone thanks to the XDA devel guys.
Good times.

bugelrex 2011-02-11 15:44

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
From a business standpoint, what choice did they really have?

- continue with Symbian. With the rate of market share loss it it would be single digits marketshare in 4 years
- focus on Meego. Chances are, the team on meego are the same team on Maemo. The team did not have the experience/prosessionalism to produce a finished/polished produce for mass market.
- If Meego failed (unpolished produce, 3rd party devs not adopting it) the company would be in dire dire trouble because of Symbian adoption rates
- go with Android, Google would probably not provide any special support.. treating them the same as motorola,HTC etc

If the Maemo team had taken the effort to produce a polished N900, i think the decision to go full bore with Meego would have been a no brainer.

madmaze 2011-02-11 15:45

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ceaboust (Post 942575)

http://www.blogcdn.com/www.engadget....e-32-of-38.jpg
MeeGo R&D cut by a lot.
MeeGo will be turned into an "experimental" OS (just like maemo was...)

My favorite aspect of this is how symbian completely disappears and how much the entire budget gets slashed

gerbick 2011-02-11 15:57

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Symbian needed to go sooner or later.

I just wonder who's more hated. Muburak or Elop right now.

I predict a riot.

Bratag 2011-02-11 16:00

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by twodice (Post 942552)
I actually like the idea of nokia and ms. Nokia still make the best hardware for me.Their build quality is great too

Lets not forget samsung take ages to release updates - e.g all the galaxy range ( and yes i own a tab and a galaxy s)

sony ericsson - look at the x10 and others, no 2.2 for them at all and no xda devs port so far.

lg - piss poor in general.

htc are ok but still make hardware which is questionable in terms of durability - screen issues and the old htc tytn 2/ nearly all htc phones video driver problem for which i have not forgiven them ( i owned a tytn2).

the only other option is th eiphone and ill be lloking closely at the iphone 5 but id rather a nokia build with wp7. ultimatley we all more or less started with win mo anyway so its just continuing the trend.

theres no need for anyone to abandon ship unless you think for some reason the grass is greener on the other side.

still happy with my n900.

Hey don't get me wrong - I still think Android needs some serious work. Mainly in the form of Google stepping up and putting in some mandatory compatibility requirements from phone version to version. But its the best of a bad bunch now. Personally I will be running my N900 into the ground before I go for another phone.

Guess the community supported patches etc are looking pretty damn good now eh :)

patlak 2011-02-11 16:03

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gerbick (Post 942618)
Symbian needed to go sooner or later.

I just wonder who's more hated. Muburak or Elop right now.

I predict a riot.

Does Windows have to go? Does Symbian have to go? Why would the most popular OS have to go, UI? Simplest thing to fix, it's just spoilers on the car, under the hood Symbian is a Veyron SS. Elop canned it as soon as he became CEO, however he did release dead devices with a sinister laugh.

Brock 2011-02-11 16:05

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gerbick (Post 942618)
Symbian needed to go sooner or later.

I just wonder who's more hated. Muburak or Elop right now.

I predict a riot.

today its elop

patlak 2011-02-11 16:05

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by madmaze (Post 942589)
My favorite aspect of this is how symbian completely disappears and how much the entire budget gets slashed

Elop gonna get raped by all satisfied Symbian users. There is a lot.

Frappacino 2011-02-11 16:06

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bratag (Post 942625)
Guess the community supported patches etc are looking pretty damn good now eh :)

Isnt TMO still funded by Nokia at the moment ? If not who provides the funding to run TMO ?

If no TMO repo how are community supported patches going to be managed ?

ivlok 2011-02-11 16:08

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Maybe Elop tenure won't be that long
http://www.google.com/finance?client=ob&q=NYSE:NOK

patlak 2011-02-11 16:08

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ceaboust (Post 942575)
http://www.blogcdn.com/www.engadget....e-32-of-38.jpg
MeeGo R&D cut by a lot.
MeeGo will be turned into an "experimental" OS (just like maemo was...)

This sucks.
I'll ignore nokia for a couple years, probably won't visit this forum anymore (whats the point? lol)
I've started developing my android app and I've installed android on my old phone thanks to the XDA devel guys.
Good times.

Why so much in WP7 R&D? Isn't that Microsoft's job? I wonder where them moneyz will go...

Brock 2011-02-11 16:10

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by patlak (Post 942654)
Why so much in WP7 R&D? Isn't that Microsoft's job? I wonder where them moneyz will go...

i can tell you. Its going into the pocket of the devil (elop)

Brock 2011-02-11 16:11

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ivlok (Post 942652)
Maybe Elop tenure won't be that long
http://www.google.com/finance?client=ob&q=NYSE:NOK

i hope that the board of directors will mention this and think about what elop did to one of the greatest companies in europe... ruining it...

patlak 2011-02-11 16:12

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Brock (Post 942658)
i can tell you. Its going into the pocket of the devil (elop)

His pocket must be hell..

mrojas 2011-02-11 16:12

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by patlak (Post 942643)
Elop gonna get raped by all satisfied Symbian users. There is a lot.

If I had been in the press conference, I would have thrown my shoes at him.

bugelrex 2011-02-11 16:14

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by patlak (Post 942634)
UI? Simplest thing to fix, it's just spoilers on the car, under the hood Symbian is a Veyron SS.

Its true, its much easier to fix than the stuff under the hood. It was so simple, Nokia screwed it up twice in 3 years even with a HUGE r&d budget!
The UI overhaul on n97, horrid.. horrid experience
The UI overhaul on n8, more consistent but still feels like early 2000.

There's absolutely no reason to expect them to be successful a 3rd time round. The problems are probably due to
- 10+ year old Symbian code turned to spaghetti, code changes very difficult to make without a domino effect over the rest of the code
- poor poor project management and 9am-5pm paycheck Symbian developers who are there just to fix bugs.. not rock the boat

i get the impression the Symbian software department was so fundamentally broken it could not be fixed without mass firings

patlak 2011-02-11 16:19

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrojas (Post 942664)
If I had been in the press conference, I would have thrown my shoes at him.

Only the cheap kind. He would suffer so much being touched by them cheap ones, or we should just pay that experienced Arab who threw them at Bush, he won't miss this time.

volt 2011-02-11 16:20

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Goodbye my friends,
it's hard to die
when all the birds
are singing in the sky...

patlak 2011-02-11 16:26

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bugelrex (Post 942668)
Its true, its much easier to fix than the stuff under the hood. It was so simple, Nokia screwed it up twice in 3 years even with a HUGE r&d budget!
The UI overhaul on n97, horrid.. horrid experience
The UI overhaul on n8, more consistent but still feels like early 2000.

There's absolutely no reason to expect them to be successful a 3rd time round. The problems are probably due to
- 10+ year old Symbian code turned to spaghetti, code changes very difficult to make without a domino effect over the rest of the code
- poor poor project management and 9am-5pm paycheck Symbian developers who are there just to fix bugs.. not rock the boat

i get the impression the Symbian software department was so fundamentally broken it could not be fixed without mass firings

S^4 was supposed to be a huge overhaul. The team probably took their time to create a UI that would last another decade. The OS is the most optimized, can't go wrong with that.

N97 didn't have any new UI, it just introduced widgets. When it was first introduced in the trailer, most were impressed. Slow hardware gave Symbian bad rep. If they continiued the OMAP 2420 route, all would have been perfect.

canabal 2011-02-11 16:28

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by twodice (Post 942552)
I actually like the idea of nokia and ms. Nokia still make the best hardware for me.Their build quality is great too

Lets not forget samsung take ages to release updates - e.g all the galaxy range ( and yes i own a tab and a galaxy s)

sony ericsson - look at the x10 and others, no 2.2 for them at all and no xda devs port so far.

lg - piss poor in general.

htc are ok but still make hardware which is questionable in terms of durability - screen issues and the old htc tytn 2/ nearly all htc phones video driver problem for which i have not forgiven them ( i owned a tytn2).

the only other option is th eiphone and ill be lloking closely at the iphone 5 but id rather a nokia build with wp7. ultimatley we all more or less started with win mo anyway so its just continuing the trend.

theres no need for anyone to abandon ship unless you think for some reason the grass is greener on the other side.

still happy with my n900.

Google Nexus S. That is all.

Ele-Mental 2011-02-11 16:31

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
I think Android is about to get a whole lot of developers.

anpk 2011-02-11 16:39

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
This is the end of nokia. Its sad that nokia did not realize that people gravitated towards nokia because of its open software and non locked features (a la n900).

I hope it does well, but I personally will probably never buy another nokia with that blue screen of death OS.

gerbick 2011-02-11 16:41

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ele-Mental (Post 942699)
I think Android is about to get a whole lot of developers.

If you mean Symbian, agree.

If you meant Qt, disagree.

haffid 2011-02-11 16:43

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
we have a peace of history and art on our hands the powerfull n900 the legendary last good phone of nokia

extendedping 2011-02-11 16:56

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 942681)
Goodbye my friends,
it's hard to die
when all the birds
are singing in the sky...

But for Meego there was no season in the sun...

DrSteve 2011-02-11 16:56

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ele-Mental (Post 942450)
Im uninstalling easy debian and power kernel. im gonna run it stock speed from now on...

Wait a minute, what does EasyDebian have to do with device lifespan? :confused:

v13 2011-02-11 16:57

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
You may wish to vote for keeping meego as described here. Just for the fun of it.

Ele-Mental 2011-02-11 16:59

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gerbick (Post 942727)
If you mean Symbian, agree.

If you meant Qt, disagree.

Well Symbian is the devision being scratched.

Nyrath 2011-02-11 16:59

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
from here
http://communities-dominate.blogs.co...microsoft.html

Quote:

Does Nokia gain a superior OS out of Microsoft? No. Phone 7 won't even be able to run all the features that current Nokia premium phones have. So right from the start, this means moving Nokia abilities down a notch.

But competitive advantage? Differentiation. Well, who else is committed to Phone 7? Lets see - Samsung, LG and SonyEricsson. So whatever Microsoft is developing, Nokia cannot even have any significant advantage - on its premium phones - that Samsung, LG and SonyEricsson don't know about. They gain all the delays of Microsoft while gaining also the eyes and ears of most of their biggest competitors to see all the development. When before, on both Symbian and MeeGo Nokia would have had their development to themselves. Yeah, *****ic move.

ammyt 2011-02-11 17:00

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by joppu (Post 942471)

Ummmm, what are the features that are actually left?

tape_ape 2011-02-11 17:04

Re: Goodbye Meego, goodbye Nokia
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 942681)
Goodbye my friends,
it's hard to die
when all the birds
are singing in the sky...

stolen from another blog referring to Microsoft and Nokia ...

TWO TURKEYS DON'T MAKE AN EAGLE


All times are GMT. The time now is 15:17.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8