maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N900 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   Returning my N900 (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=44327)

UNderworld 2010-02-15 01:18

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slender (Post 526626)
Hmm. Accelerated h.264 video? Tv-out connectors out of box. Streaming video to internet. What do you mean by FB integration? Facebook? You got chat out of box and hermes from extras that pulls out nicely also stuff.

Tv-out came 2/3 years ago with my N95... nothing new... yes facebook is cooked and delivered with WM6.5 / HtC HD.. working better :D ..

volt 2010-02-15 15:53

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 525774)
Nokia is simply compling with the European directive for microUSB charger. I can change a tip on a multi charger and achieve the same. I think you will find the same issue occurs with newer Blackberry devices too.

The N900 and certain Blackberry models, and I am sure, probably countless other devices have microUSB plugs that requires a "smart" charger that can negotiate for power. This means that a standard USB charger that provides standard USB power and cannot negotiate about that, requires a cable where two of the leads are shorted. In other words, the standardization to microUSB has lead to most standard USB chargers being useless.

If you believe that this will NOT come as a surprise to almost every owner of a standard USB wall/car charger, then you are living in a very special world.

I can assure you that this is not mentioned in a single of the reviews that this thread says we need to read before we're deaned worthy of buying the N900.

And if you expect EVERY PERSON who wants to buy the N900 to realize they need to research EVERY THING about the device that might influence their usage on this MICRO level, as to "can I expect the microUSB cable I already have to be compatible to the microUSB cable that I would need to charge this device in my car", then noone would ever get to the point where their research is done and they can buy a device.

And no sain man would expect people to read "MicroUSB charger" and think "I need to research if MicroUSB is compatible with MicroUSB". Seriously. I mean. Come on!

I tell you, some here have a totally twisted expectation to what people should be expected to know. Is your spare time worth absolutely nothing to you?

volt 2010-02-15 15:57

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 525780)
Sorry to burst your bubble but you are not entirely correct on this one. I spent literally about 5 minutes with Wikipedia checking this and found the answer before the N900 was even released. Nokia also answered my email the same day. As both the web and email seem to be standard tools on the internet I am puzzled as to how you failed to find a simple solution.

Big mouth.

I challenge you to show me how someone without knowledge of bluetooth protocols can figure out if a Pioneer DEH-P9800BT can syncronize contacts with a Nokia N900. If you send an email to either company, they will simply say "It is not on our list of supported devices, please check back later".

Edit: or, as is my repeated experience with Pioneer, not answer at all.

schettj 2010-02-15 18:26

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 527569)
If you believe that this will NOT come as a surprise to almost every owner of a standard USB wall/car charger, then you are living in a very special world.

Yay, I am living in a special world!

This world has existed for at least two years. Dumb USB Chargers are so 2008.

"standard" usb wall chargers are now compliant with this brave new world. $5 dumb wall chargers can still be purchased, even if they don't work.

I've lost track - has everyone who said they were going to return/sell/beat to a pulp their n900 done so already?

Fargus 2010-02-15 19:03

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Guber99 (Post 526084)
Its the most competitive market that Nokia wants back. You dont know how lonely I am with Nokia smartphones.........

More postings without factual backup. This was covered in a thread last week.

Fargus 2010-02-15 19:05

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rushmore (Post 526183)
Some N900 users are a kick :)

Reasons to return the N900 if you are more a smartphone user and less tech.

1. Laggy more than it should be (pressing icons and nothing happens or a delay)
2. Weak 2G radio (unless the three I had were all defective)
3. Minimal apps available and not looking much better (in regards to commercial apps)
4. To get the most out of the device you need to be more tech oriented- this device is not for consumers that just want apps and a smartphone.
5. Very weak portrait integration that will likely not get much better
6. Lack of picture mms that more people use than email attachments on smartphones
7. Weak map integration

And all of this is coming from a rube like me who LOVES the N900 due to its media ability and handy as a Mini-Me netbook. Still, I use my G1 as a smartphone and the N900 as everything else.

BTW, I hope I am wrong as heck about the long-term app status, portrait mode, mms picture, etc, but the longer this stuff takes to happen, the less likely it will. Maemo 6 and new devices are on the horizon.

Sounds a very fair assessment - thanks for not ranting! :)

Fargus 2010-02-15 19:09

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Guber99 (Post 526543)
It succeeds for unemployed and teenagers........I agree......from that standpoint this is a restricted device and disengeniously advertised..........

Or anyone else that doesn't use a personal device on a specific setup.

Fargus 2010-02-15 19:10

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gerbick (Post 526552)
The Nokia N-Series is for multimedia... that's what it's always been designated for. Bringing enterprise business into the mix is not part of the deal. That's the E-Series.

Been that way for years.

I've mentioned this several times before to him but he always ignores it as it doesn't suit his viewpoint.

gerbick 2010-02-15 19:12

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 527946)
I've mentioned this several times before to him but he always ignores it as it doesn't suit his viewpoint.

Oh? Sorry for taking that away from you. ;)

Fargus 2010-02-15 19:13

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronaldo (Post 526588)
i dont understand why this thread is so long.

Dont like the phone? does not work for your needs well dont buy it and return it. problem solved. stop crying about it

You would have thought this was a sensbile grown up option wouldn't you?

YoDude 2010-02-15 19:14

Re: Returning my N900
 
N900 research tools... >> CLICK <<

Fargus 2010-02-15 19:17

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 527569)
The N900 and certain Blackberry models, and I am sure, probably countless other devices have microUSB plugs that requires a "smart" charger that can negotiate for power. This means that a standard USB charger that provides standard USB power and cannot negotiate about that, requires a cable where two of the leads are shorted. In other words, the standardization to microUSB has lead to most standard USB chargers being useless.

If you believe that this will NOT come as a surprise to almost every owner of a standard USB wall/car charger, then you are living in a very special world.

I can assure you that this is not mentioned in a single of the reviews that this thread says we need to read before we're deaned worthy of buying the N900.

And if you expect EVERY PERSON who wants to buy the N900 to realize they need to research EVERY THING about the device that might influence their usage on this MICRO level, as to "can I expect the microUSB cable I already have to be compatible to the microUSB cable that I would need to charge this device in my car", then noone would ever get to the point where their research is done and they can buy a device.

And no sain man would expect people to read "MicroUSB charger" and think "I need to research if MicroUSB is compatible with MicroUSB". Seriously. I mean. Come on!

I tell you, some here have a totally twisted expectation to what people should be expected to know. Is your spare time worth absolutely nothing to you?

Actually it has been on the main news in Europe quite a few times, personally I like to have a look at it occasionally.

I also was merely pointiung out that Nokia were compliing with a requirement for the data pin shorting. If you wish to rant please find a posting that at least has the same tone to start with.

Fargus 2010-02-15 19:20

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 527579)
Big mouth.

I challenge you to show me how someone without knowledge of bluetooth protocols can figure out if a Pioneer DEH-P9800BT can syncronize contacts with a Nokia N900. If you send an email to either company, they will simply say "It is not on our list of supported devices, please check back later".

Edit: or, as is my repeated experience with Pioneer, not answer at all.

I simply emailed Nokia support in the UK and asked if the N900 would work with my Car Kit and gave them the model. I had a polite phonecall from them the next day and they talked me through what it would and wouldn't do.

If they state it isnt on the list of supported devices then the answer is likely to be no. If it does then you are lucky, that's a normal reaction surely?

Fargus 2010-02-15 19:21

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gerbick (Post 527952)
Oh? Sorry for taking that away from you. ;)

LOL. No problem at all - just thought you might like to know it won't make any difference, if the answer isn't as wanted then it's ignored.

volt 2010-02-15 23:20

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 527979)
I simply emailed Nokia support in the UK and asked if the N900 would work with my Car Kit and gave them the model. I had a polite phonecall from them the next day and they talked me through what it would and wouldn't do.

If they state it isnt on the list of supported devices then the answer is likely to be no. If it does then you are lucky, that's a normal reaction surely?

Pretty much any list of compatibility I have ever seen have only consisted of devices that existed at the time the products marketing material was created. In other words, none of the phones I have had, that have worked in various degree with the car radio, including the N900, has ever been on the list of supported devices. The same goes pretty much for any motherboard compatibility list I've ever seen, they are never updated once they are put out.

volt 2010-02-15 23:28

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 527971)
If you wish to rant please find a posting that at least has the same tone to start with.

As a matter of fact, I do not wish to rant. And you're ranting every bit as much as me. It is the blatant black/white lack of understanding here that is my issue. I for one are not returning my N900 because I think it's a quite good device, but it has a long number of issues. Some which are harder than others to predict before you learn about it.

The ranting in this thread and similar threads, and I've seen some huge fonts, are from some that seem to feel personally insulted if a persons pre-sales research didn't include printboard schematics. You can only research so much before you either have to buy it or not. I have spent a lot of time reading about this phone before I got it in mid December. And I think the people saying "you got what you deserve for not doing research" are plain rude.

I tend to take side against rude people, and answer in their own language. It's a flaw, I know.

I can see that your information collection moved from Wikipedia to the European News broadcasting. Either way, before I got this phone I had no idea what AT commands were, and that the car stereo relied on them to transfer contacts. As a matter of fact, I don't think one in a hundred people would know. Now that I know, I feel I have wasted valuable time finding it out. Truth is, most people want to know if their stereo can "hook up to their phone", and if it can receive stereo bluetooth audio. That's as much information as most people would want to know. Having to first research A2DP, then AVRCP, then AT messages, just to find out if there is a chance that it'll work in practice too... That's not doing too little research. That's doing too much research.

Fargus 2010-02-15 23:32

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 528425)
Pretty much any list of compatibility I have ever seen have only consisted of devices that existed at the time the products marketing material was created. In other words, none of the phones I have had, that have worked in various degree with the car radio, including the N900, has ever been on the list of supported devices. The same goes pretty much for any motherboard compatibility list I've ever seen, they are never updated once they are put out.

Well, I had a good response from Nokia but then I suspect from other feedback on here Nokia USA are less helpful than the European contingent. Maybe an email to the UK email might be more helpful?

Unfortunately most manufacturers want to move onto the next best thing. Maybe you could let others know in the Wiki what does and doesn't work so Google etceteras can pick it up and help others?

volt 2010-02-15 23:39

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 528436)
Maybe you could let others know in the Wiki what does and doesn't work so Google etceteras can pick it up and help others?

That is a quite valid suggestion. However, I'll just leave this thread instead because I simply do not have the time and energy to start doing research on updating wikis.

volt 2010-02-15 23:44

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by YoDude (Post 527960)
N900 research tools... >> CLICK <<

Knockout in round 1 :clap:

Guber99 2010-02-16 01:39

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 527979)
I simply emailed Nokia support in the UK and asked if the N900 would work with my Car Kit and gave them the model. I had a polite phonecall from them the next day and they talked me through what it would and wouldn't do.

If they state it isnt on the list of supported devices then the answer is likely to be no. If it does then you are lucky, that's a normal reaction surely?

Hey Fartus, I guess nokia UK is better than nokia US, yet its a much bigger market.........go figure

Guber99 2010-02-16 01:40

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by YoDude (Post 527960)
N900 research tools... >> CLICK <<

Great stuff Dude! Lovet it

Texrat 2010-02-16 01:58

Re: Returning my N900
 
Hey Guber99, can we count on you to troll at MeeGo.com, or do you have other plans?

Guber99 2010-02-16 02:04

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 528587)
Hey Guber99, can we count on you to troll at MeeGo.com, or do you have other plans?

You think the Meego will be Amigo to my N900.....provisioning and all? I do like your new Avatar

Texrat 2010-02-16 02:13

Re: Returning my N900
 
Sorry, I saw that word and my eyes glazed over.

Fargus 2010-02-18 09:14

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Guber99 (Post 528572)
Hey Fartus, I guess nokia UK is better than nokia US, yet its a much bigger market.........go figure

Well apparently from your posts about their market share it isn't. The mobile markets in Europe are a lot more developed than the US in general probably due to population density making the investment in cell networks more viable earlier. The use of CB radio and the like in the US also reduced the chance for product development earlier.

I'm assuming the name change for me was just a typo rather than a purile attempt at insult.

Fargus 2010-02-23 16:10

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UNderworld (Post 526485)
lol its just like I have to write codes to the ECU to make the tomtom work:confused:. What about people who dont go on forums? they will never b able to use the camera..
It works over gtalk on SOME situations. there is no gtalk in uk:confused: and the "in some situations" looks like the tomtom will only work in London, and it MAY NOT work in Manchester, or Liverpool, or Birmingham...

Actually this is more a limitation of GTalk protocol and services rather than the N900. The camera works fine in the UK over Cell and WiFi for GTalk conversations assuming that the client you are talking to can cope with Video conversations too. The N900 can't magically fix something at the other end of the conversation.

The camera works, whether developers decide to include it in their applications is another thing. If you find an application that you would like to use the camera for then ask the developer to add it. Some protocols such as Skype are closed asnd therefore only the owner of that protocol can add it or provide information to allow others to do so - that isn't anyone else's fault.

Fargus 2010-02-23 16:11

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Guber99 (Post 526534)
This is supposed to be device about communication, that integrates YOUR communication, and it fails in the most common use of communication: EMAIL!!!!

It uses email fine, just that the security aspects of some combinations of provisioning don't.

Fargus 2010-02-23 16:13

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Guber99 (Post 526543)
It succeeds for unemployed and teenagers........I agree......from that standpoint this is a restricted device and disengeniously advertised..........

I'm not unemplyed and I've not been a teenager for a considerable length of time. I use the N900 for sensible emails not for those that need to be secure as the device itself can be removed from my person, same as any other phone. If the company in question needed serious security around their emails then they wouldn't be allowing use by a) a privately owned mobile and b) by a mobile in the first place!

Fargus 2010-02-23 16:16

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UNderworld (Post 526558)
I heard the Music player (part of multemedia) doesnt do its job properly.. tags:confused:
front cam is another example of multimedia:confused: which doesnt work out of the box....:eek:
whats left for multimedia? "being open-source" doesnt make it a multimedia device.. only flash integration???

Multimedia strictly speaking means more than one so technically a screen AND audio means multimedia!

Front Camera works fine, some of the apps don't support it, that's all. Ask the developers of the apps that you want to support it.

Tags in music - mine work fine but then I didn't want that to be the main purpose of my device or I would have bought an MP3 player instead!

Fargus 2010-02-23 16:18

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UNderworld (Post 526571)
I Agree. N series is for multimedia..
N95 had its own style of sliding both ways - one way for multimedia keys..:cool:
N900 however, u cannot even pause a song without unlocking the screen.. not even with the headset... U cannot skip tracks with the headset..
Also I havent noticed it, but I read the music doesnt stop playing when u receive a call ( i have no idea to what extent this is true)..
It even fails in the area of being a N-Series Phone...

So now you are complaining that there is too much media? LOL. Sorry - couldn't resist that!

If the phone doesn't mute the music then this is indeed something that either the phone app software or media player should address. Not sure if this is that the phone app isn't broadcasting a message to say that a call is in progress or the media player is ignoring it.

Fargus 2010-02-23 16:19

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gerbick (Post 526579)
If you said that it doesn't work with Skype out of the box, I'd agree. But look around, there's folks using it with Mirror as well as with Google Talk. So... we're just going to have to disagree there.

I am, however, personally pissed off it doesn't support video calling via Skype out of the box. That's one of the main reasons I won't buy a N900.

That's a limitation with Skype not releasing that information for the protocol.

Fargus 2010-02-23 16:21

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UNderworld (Post 526599)
My old phone had all that (except full flash). It played music and videos better. with better control.. had better FB integration - no need for 3rd party apps....
And Any new phone/smartphone has these capabilities nowadays. and they r better in a lot of other ways... Theres nothing special about the "multimedia" bit on this phone... or did i miss something??

So which phone was it that supported Facebook without a 3rd party application? Not seen one on the marketplace so far.

Fargus 2010-02-23 16:24

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UNderworld (Post 526709)
Tv-out came 2/3 years ago with my N95... nothing new... yes facebook is cooked and delivered with WM6.5 / HtC HD.. working better :D ..

Are you seriously putting WinMobile up as a contender for a mobile phone operating system? It has to be the most derided mobile OS going! Even the industry think it is a joke! Well if you want a WinMobile then fine but don't expect sensible battery life or it to last long before crashing!

Fargus 2010-02-23 16:27

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 528444)
That is a quite valid suggestion. However, I'll just leave this thread instead because I simply do not have the time and energy to start doing research on updating wikis.

So basically you can't be bothered to help others but have time to rant and rave about something? Only needs a couple of lines not a complete article.

UNderworld 2010-03-07 13:20

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 542900)
So which phone was it that supported Facebook without a 3rd party application? Not seen one on the marketplace so far.

any phone with Windows Mobile 6.5 does this nowadays.... ;)

UNderworld 2010-03-07 13:23

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 542908)
Are you seriously putting WinMobile up as a contender for a mobile phone operating system? It has to be the most derided mobile OS going! Even the industry think it is a joke! Well if you want a WinMobile then fine but don't expect sensible battery life or it to last long before crashing!

i replied THIS question of yours, without doing down the OS route.. it does support FB .. WITHOUT 3rd party apps;)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 542900)
So which phone was it that supported Facebook without a 3rd party application? Not seen one on the marketplace so far.


UNderworld 2010-03-07 13:26

Re: Returning my N900
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fargus (Post 542908)
Well if you want a WinMobile then fine but don't expect sensible battery life or it to last long before crashing!

LOL as if the battery life on the N900 is better (or even sensible) than WInMo devices.:rolleyes: ... in 3 weeks, my n900 has been freezing and need reboot more than my htd hd did in 1 year

TekHousE 2010-03-11 17:12

Re: Returning my N900
 
Still posting here?

Don't you have your new phone by now?

I love the N900. But then again I knew what it was BEFORE I bought it. Sure it has some growing left do with some aspects, but I just used Open Office on a PHONE! How cool is that?

buxz777 2010-03-11 19:00

Re: Returning my N900
 
no ones right or wrong here the n900 is like marmite some love it some hate it

underworld is entitled to his opinion and if he doesnt like the n900 i dont really see the point in arguing with him

there is no doubting the n900 falls short in some smartphone areas but make up for it in tablet features

its a hybrid device , step four of five of the cycle , going from tablet to phone or phone to tablet and not everyone is going to like it

i do really enjoy my n900 but i do find some thing annoying like underworld , however i seem to find alot more positives from it as well and i really enjoy seeing a device evolve which the n900 is and has been from day one thanks to alot of great coders and devolpers and linux pros helping everyone get the most out of it

it reminds me of the n95-1 when it 1st came out , maps was rubbish , firmware was a bit buggy , not many apps lurking around at release yet it evolved into a all time great and it was great fun going through the evoloution process , i understand some want the finished article straight away but to me the n900 is totaly useable day to day so waiting for new stuff doesnt really matter as it works fine as it is but will defently get better with time :-)

i dont think the media player is that bad ether to be hobest , yeah there is no graphic equaliser but the sound is good through decent headphones , it has a massive memory soon to be around 64gb via extra sd card , plays divix/avi out of box , streams , higer on screen res for videos then most phones , album art , supports alot of codecs , lyric support compatible , tv out compatible , to be honest ive been using s60 media player for quite some time and the n900 isnt no worse then that media player , the n97 doesnt even support streaming of video or music

at then end of the day the n900 isnt perferct and for some it isnt even good but for many of us the n900 is a solid decent phone with a excellent foundation to be built on and i look forwards to all the evolving and new apps and idears that are thrown the n900s way

shame you didnt like it underworld mate and hope you like your new phone better if its a totally new o/s though maybe make sure you know what the o/s does and doesnt do before purchse buddy itll save the returns and stuff

good luck with the next one

out of intrest what phone are you looking at next


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:55.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8