maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Community (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote? (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=27808)

qole 2009-04-01 17:52

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by penguinbait (Post 276543)
I then click on March 09 and get to here
http://wiki.maemo.org/Maemo.org_Sprints/March_09

At this point I appear to be looking at some data. Is this what Nokia is asking for community help with? Where do we submit our requests for help on a project? What determines whether or not a project gets community support from the council? What determines what the council members work on? How can the communtiy actually get involved in council decisions. How do I know what decisions the council is working on and how do I lobby my council for support or tell them how I think they should represent me on a topic.

(I fixed your link to March 09 Sprint above)

Yeah, that page is pretty cryptic to me too, I'm not sure why we should care about most of those tasks, and none of them look done, either. Well, except the election. So by the only metric that we have, it looks like the maemo.org team isn't doing so well.

(EDIT: The activity logs and the task lists don't seem to have anything to do with each other, either. Why are the team members working on things that have nothing to do with the tasks listed above? And if they are related, shouldn't they reference the task that they are related to?)

Also, Jaffa tried to plan the first sprint meeting of the new council, and we've already had two of the most important members of the, um, "paid side" of the team give "can't be there, but here's my report" responses.

So, yeah, I'm not sure what's going on, either.

Do you have something you want support for? Do you have topics you want representation on?

GeneralAntilles 2009-04-01 17:55

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by penguinbait (Post 276543)
I am not trying to be overly negative, but as someone who has been here since what seems like the dawn of time, I am not clear what I am supposed to get from the Council or how I am supposed to interact with the council. I honestly never heard anything about council and was amazed we were voting for new council when I am not sure the old one actually did anything. And again maybe they did lots, but I am not seeing it communicated to the general public or if it is I am just not seeing it.

I don't have the time to respond in detail at the moment, but if you're interested in being involved in community issues you should subscribe to maemo-community, and if you're interested in seeing what the Council's up to, you should pay attention to Planet (more specifically, the council blog).

penguinbait 2009-04-01 18:02

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qole (Post 276549)
(I fixed your link to March 09 Sprint above)

Yeah, that page is pretty cryptic to me too, I'm not sure why we should care about most of those tasks, and none of them look done, either. Well, except the election.

Also, Jaffa tried to plan the first sprint meeting of the new council, and we've already had two of the most important members of the, um, "paid side" of the team give "can't be there, but here's my report" responses.

So, yeah, I'm not sure what's going on, either.

Do you have something you want support for? Do you have topics you want representation on?


I guess I am looking for:

What the council is working on?

How can I give my input?

How can I get involved to help?

How can I request help? (what type of help can/should be requested)

Its just never really been clear to me. I understand the stated purpose, but I need a user manual???

timsamoff 2009-04-01 18:46

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by penguinbait (Post 276553)
I guess I am looking for:

What the council is working on?

How can I give my input?

How can I get involved to help?

How can I request help? (what type of help can/should be requested)

Its just never really been clear to me. I understand the stated purpose, but I need a user manual???

Most of this discussion (as GeneralAntilles stated) can be found by subscribing to maemo-community. (Here are the archives.)

Tim

penguinbait 2009-04-02 01:17

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by timsamoff (Post 276584)
Most of this discussion (as GeneralAntilles stated) can be found by subscribing to maemo-community. (Here are the archives.)

Tim

Thanks Tim, I appreciate the links, but I am asking for a little more.

So Council, can we work on a Maemo Council portal, or wiki, or some front end to all the workings of the Maemo Council. How do I get that on the agenda?

I just feel like I am asking some simple questions and their seems not to be any simple answers. If you guys feel my request is not needed I guess ignore me. I am just saying if you want to get people involved, I think a better job could be done. Perhaps I just have a misexpectations of the council?

Jaffa 2009-04-02 12:27

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by penguinbait (Post 276678)
So Council, can we work on a Maemo Council portal, or wiki, or some front end to all the workings of the Maemo Council. How do I get that on the agenda?

Improvements to the council homepage are planned, and suggestions on what you'd like to see are welcome.

There's also been the suggestion of communicating council "business" more vigorously via Twitter (#m.occ) and on the current Sprint page's "daily reporting" section.

Quote:

I just feel like I am asking some simple questions and their seems not to be any simple answers.
Sorry, I think we've answered any specific question accurately and simply. If you have other questions, how about formulating them into a list?

Quote:

If you guys feel my request is not needed I guess ignore me.
What request?

Quote:

I am just saying if you want to get people involved, I think a better job could be done. Perhaps I just have a misexpectations of the council?
Get people involved in what? Plenty of people are involved in developing Mer, editing wiki pages, dealing with bugs, benefiting from the work of Niels and Jeremiah, downloading software, uploading software, and discussing on these fora.

When Nokia ask "do you want us to sponsor another summit, and where?", the elected council (and this is a representative democracy - not asking for feedback on everything) will steer and advise based on their opinions - and the opinions of anyone else offered.

You don't need our permission to do anything, and the role of the council as facilitators means you might not notice when we do things (which is fine - this isn't about glory, it's about getting things done).

It should be pretty clear what the council does (see my explanations above). It may not be everything you want the council to do, or you may have questions about its value, but I think questions of what we actually do have been answered.

qgil 2009-04-02 13:01

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Also, when the maemo-community list was created there were no plans for a talk.maemo.org. Now a possibility would be to move here the discussions held there.

GeneralAntilles 2009-04-02 13:11

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qgil (Post 276767)
Also, when the maemo-community list was created there were no plans for a talk.maemo.org. Now a possibility would be to move here the discussions held there.

We'd have to see, but, generally speaking, more of the involved people (paid—maemo.org, Nokians, Nemein—and otherwise) are on -community than itT. Relevant issues tend to get pushed to itT eventually, anyway.

sjgadsby 2009-04-02 13:30

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles (Post 276772)
We'd have to see, but, generally speaking, more of the involved people (paid—maemo.org, Nokians, Nemein—and otherwise) are on -community than itT. Relevant issues tend to get pushed to itT eventually, anyway.

A quick Google search turned up a script that claims to "scrape the archives of a MailMan list and convert to an RSS feed." Could that script or a similar one be implemented/adapted for Pipermail (Mailman edition), and if so, could a listing of recent threads from maemo-community be displayed in a sidebar on the talk.maemo.org main page? It might help the t.m.o main page become a one stop location for a quick overview of community discussion.

qole 2009-04-02 17:32

Re: Maemo Community Council: Why didn't you vote?
 
Yes! What sjgadsby said! I have said before that the mailing lists and the forums need to be brought closer together somehow.

Ideally, I think users should be able to make forums that they select from t.m.o act like mailing lists. That is, any new posts to that forum are e-mailed to "mailing list subscribers" of that forum, and those users can reply to threads by e-mail.

Then we could simply merge t.m.o and the mailing lists completely.

We can do it! We have the technology!


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:26.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8