maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   SailfishOS (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=52)
-   -   sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=94692)

Dave999 2015-03-24 19:16

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by coderus (Post 1464839)
you didn't meant any users in your question.

Nope, you have to read between the lines ;)

juiceme 2015-03-24 20:15

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
Weelll @coderus is absolutely correct, since flasher is just about the only thing we cannot easily make by ourselves.
Everything else I need I can make or port to the device.

Dave999 2015-03-24 20:33

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by juiceme (Post 1464844)
Weelll @coderus is absolutely correct, since flasher is just about the only thing we cannot easily make by ourselves.
Everything else I need I can make or port to the device.

Maybe there is a reason for no flasher approuch?

Hariainm 2015-03-25 01:04

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
I guess Myriad restrictions regarding Alien Dalvik, or Google, or Oracle, I don't know. If you think carefully, all ports of SailfishOS to other devices miss the android compatibility feature. And since the users himself can use the hardware adaptation toolkit... Place your bets on why.

bluefoot 2015-03-25 05:09

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hariainm (Post 1464857)
I guess Myriad restrictions regarding Alien Dalvik, or Google, or Oracle, I don't know. If you think carefully, all ports of SailfishOS to other devices miss the android compatibility feature. And since the users himself can use the hardware adaptation toolkit... Place your bets on why.

Even if that were true, it doesn't really excuse Jolla's wall of silence on this or other issues. They could simply say what the situation is.

Morpog 2015-03-25 07:27

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
The CTO (Stefano Mosconi) of Jolla said they are working on it. So yes it will come.
Also Stskeeps said a while ago on IRC that it's not a licensing issue, but more a technical.

ZogG 2015-03-25 07:42

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ggabriel (Post 1464804)
LOL - you'd get eaten quickly if you were a fish :D


But there is a Netflix application for Android, isn't it? And Jolla has Alien Dalvik, right? So, there you go. Why waste resources on something that works already?

If you want android apps, why not get an android? There is even jolla launcher. Seriously I don't see the point of me to buy non-Android phone to run android apps. It can be helpful as an addition as some would not port there apps, but not as main source of apps. Maemo5/N9 by the age Jolla is one already got much more apps and it was without android support

ggabriel 2015-03-25 09:15

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZogG (Post 1464876)
If you want android apps, why not get an android? There is even jolla launcher. Seriously I don't see the point of me to buy non-Android phone to run android apps. It can be helpful as an addition as some would not port there apps, but not as main source of apps. Maemo5/N9 by the age Jolla is one already got much more apps and it was without android support

Well, 2 points:
1. Define "main source of apps" - to me it is way more important to have proper IMAP/XMPP support than netflix for example. What is your flavour of preference? Everybody is different and I did mention in a later post that you could arguably use TJC for Jolla to find out what's "important" and they can _potentially_ invest some time in making their own applications for those non standard services.
2. Maemo5/N9 was initiated by a company that [still] has a lot more resources than Jolla, so understandably they could make things happen a lot quicker.

Like you say, Alien Dalvik is good for addition of applications that won't be there quickly for Sailfish. Dave999 quoted Netflix and Chromecast as examples - to me they are irrelevant, hence my counter argument.

FWIW, Netflix could just use HTML5 and every browser compatible with that technology would be able to use it. Problem solved. I don't really know what use I could give a google dongle, so I'll refrain to comment.

strongm 2015-03-25 09:18

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZogG (Post 1464876)
If you want android apps, why not get an android?

That is indeed the question some of us are beginning to ask. When I bought my Jolla (as a First One) I had high hopes for it.

But here we are 16 months later and, whilst Jolla have busily been patching and updating Sailfish, it still doesn't meet the promise that Jolla originally held out. And I'm increasingly beginning to feel that many of those who defend the current Jolla phone are subject to the free-choice paradigm of cognitive dissonance.

For example, and in response to your question, the store still doesn't have the capability to charge for apps. So if I'm a developer what do I do? If I create free apps, and I've got one that works on Android (and thus Alien Dalvik) why, when I probably have limited resources, waste time creating a native Sailfish version? And if I create apps that need to be paid for, well I'm out of luck. So basically most apps, and certainly most mainstream apps (and a fair number of niche apps - I don't expect my bank to be writing a native Sailfish banking app anytime soon) are only going to be available on the Jolla as Android apps.

So it isn't a question of wanting Android apps; it is a question of only being offered Android apps.

thedead1440 2015-03-25 10:14

Re: sailfishOS Upgrade12 discussions
 
^^^ is exactly why I never could convince myself to part with my money for a Jolla. It simply never felt worth even a fraction of its price after the initial euphoria died down. I was one of those who were taken in for their fancy marketing terms like etrazz (spelling?) display etc but when I saw the specs and found them to be a downgrade compared to the i9305 I was using at that time it became a big No-no.

Nothing from then on has made me regret my decision regardless of how much I want them to make me regret it.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:10.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8