maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Applications (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=41)
-   -   Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008 (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=13986)

SethCohn 2007-12-28 18:20

Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Quote:

It is very important to note that this is not Mobile Firefox. Its pretty stable for ‘normal’ use but I was able to crash it by opening a bunch of google maps tabs. (failed alloc not handled properly). Also, text input is broken; I’m sure it won’t be a problem with the hardware keyboard on the N810, but right now focusing on the address bar or a text box doesn’t bring up the soft keyboard.

[Seth's note - but bringing up fingerkeyboard on n800 does work ok ]

What this is, in my opinion, is a very nice starting point. This binary has all the capabilities of desktop Firefox, including support for XUL and SVG, so it can be an excellent platform to experiment with different UI concepts for mobile (both the browser UI and web pages targeting mobile users). We are also working on tools to develop and test mobile UI’s on your desktop, but more on that later.

We have a lot of work to do on stability, usability, performance and getting the “right” mix of features.

http://blog.mozilla.com/blassey/2007...d-on-the-n800/
http://blog.mozilla.com/blassey/2007...mo-repository/

Repo: http://people.mozilla.com/~blassey/ chinook extras

hordeman 2007-12-28 20:02

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Wow! That's cool! I need to try it. The current MicroB browser (to me) is pretty frustrating... it just hangs all the time. I know Minefield is still a WIP, but I think it will be a cool app to try! It sounds promising!

sevo 2007-12-28 20:22

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Don't be too excited - MicroB already uses Gecko 1.9, the rendering engine of Minefield.

hordeman 2007-12-28 21:32

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Hmmm... well, at least I can be excited about the UI... I'm not a huge fan of bare minimum UI of MicroB. ;)

GeneralAntilles 2007-12-28 21:39

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Interesting, slow as hell, but interesting.

mplawner 2007-12-28 21:42

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Wow! Wow! Wow! That IS fantastic! Real Firefox interface right on my n800! Not VNC, not X forwarded... amazing! Keeping my eye on this one. Text input clearly needs to be resolved... and speed optimizing... but again... wow! Thanks!

linuxrebel 2007-12-29 20:29

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
wah!.... I can't get it to accept text input from the n800 keyboard. But this is one project I'll follow closely for sure. Right now if the dev's need testing done let me know. Thanks!

scruffy 2007-12-30 02:14

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by linuxrebel (Post 117438)
wah!.... I can't get it to accept text input from the n800 keyboard.

Yes, that was in the announcement - known bug.
If you have mapped the finger keyboard to the main button (on the 4 way nav), you can enter text though...

linuxrebel 2007-12-30 03:15

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
-scruffy-
The *wah* was intended to be a worthless whine. The overall view is expressed in the thanks. I'm curious if the problem with keyboard entry isn't OS2008-final.

Crussader 2007-12-31 09:23

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
it's slow... but impressive... it can even handle youtube from the start... great start!

please don't drop this project... we really need a tabbed browser around here hehe

Traecer 2007-12-31 09:46

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
OK, I'm sorry--I don't understand. Is this just for hacking on, or is this intended (ultimately, when bugs are worked out) to be a MicroB replacement? I know the blog post says, "this is not Mobile Firefox," but later paragraphs in the post lead me to believe that's where this project is headed...

SethCohn 2007-12-31 13:02

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Traecer (Post 118272)
OK, I'm sorry--I don't understand. Is this just for hacking on, or is this intended (ultimately, when bugs are worked out) to be a MicroB replacement? I know the blog post says, "this is not Mobile Firefox," but later paragraphs in the post lead me to believe that's where this project is headed...

Minefield Firefox:
Firefox minefield = Firefox 3.0

Mobile Firefox:
http://weblogs.mozillazine.org/schre...nd_mobile.html

In other words, this is a full firefox, not a 'mobile' version, ala MicroB.

TabletKev 2007-12-31 13:15

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Downloading now-can't wait to try it out. Anyone know how the stylus keyboard problem could be potentially solved?

dblank 2007-12-31 18:46

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TabletKev (Post 118326)
Downloading now-can't wait to try it out. Anyone know how the stylus keyboard problem could be potentially solved?

As a workaround, tap anywhere on the D-Pad in a text field.

I'm sure a proper patch will come along soon enough.

hordeman 2008-01-05 18:09

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Crussader (Post 118260)
please don't drop this project... we really need a tabbed browser around here hehe

You raise an interesting point. MicroB had tabbed browsing in OS2007 --- I wonder what happened to it in OS2008?

Talon88 2008-01-05 21:43

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Looking Forward

bazanime 2008-01-05 22:13

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
oh how i wish for kinetic scrolling, tabs or easier window switching while in fullscreen, far far better handling of long lists of bookmarks and many more. all as standard.

for an internet tablet, browsing is abit of a chore and it can all be fixed in a simple update.

i'll give minefield a try.

kenny 2008-01-06 20:23

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
[QU
Quote:

Originally Posted by hordeman (Post 121432)
You raise an
interesting point. MicroB had tabbed browsing
in OS2007 --- I wonder what happened to it in
OS2008?

MicroB /OS 2007 had tabbed browsing?.... are you referring to "open in new window"? I found that feature did not work much of the time in MicroB/OS2007. And that's why I'm still using Opera!

rcadden 2008-01-07 14:58

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
I'm most interested in extensions, specifically Google's browser sync (or Weave, I suppose)

ghoonk 2008-01-10 11:15

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Out of curiousity, how many of you would be willing to give up application performance for application functionality? As it were, there are already a number of forum posts here complaining about how slow microB is (personally, I have no issues with it), and some people complain about it being unstable (never had that problem myself)

Assuming that Minefield runs the same Gecko engine (v1.9) as Minefield, and assuming that interesting features such as kinetic scrolling, extensions tabbed browsing etc were introduced, I'm quite sure there would be some compromise to the performance of the browser.

The way I see it, when the system is trying to render a web page, it does not matter if it is doing it over 4 open windows or 4 tabs, the amount of computing power needed to execute the rendering should not be all that different.

At some point in time, we are going to have lots of features and UI improvements and live with performance issues (I'm hoping to stand corrected on this one)

As it were the case today, while microB is not perfect, it gets the job done. The N800 by far, in today's world of fat, bloated devices (the Nokia N95 would be such an example) is a breathe of fresh air. It does almost everything I need it to do, with a good balance between UI and performance, enough to satisfy my internet and media needs, while impressing the heck out of users of iPhones, iPod Touch, and other 'consumer' devices.

While I for one, am not adverse to better UIs and functionality, I would be very careful to tread the thin line between bloatware and an effective+efficient application. Perhaps one way to do so would be to focus on developing Minefield in a very modular fashion that allows users to install the functionality and UI enhancements that they need, thereby allowing users to manage the balance between performance and bling :)

spirytsick 2008-01-10 12:04

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ghoonk (Post 124669)
...
While I for one, am not adverse to better UIs and functionality, I would be very careful to tread the thin line between bloatware and an effective+efficient application. Perhaps one way to do so would be to focus on developing Minefield in a very modular fashion that allows users to install the functionality and UI enhancements that they need, thereby allowing users to manage the balance between performance and bling :)

I completely agree. I believe that on the limited cpu power devices emphasis should be on the responsiveness and simplicity.

ARJWright 2008-01-11 16:52

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Just getting onboard with this thread. There's a good bit of excitement with this on my end. I'll be keeping an eye on this that's for sure.

jmancine 2008-02-25 03:52

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
But...responsiveness and simplicity do not guarantee function. Why not support the development of firefox for maemo? Simplicity is being able to run the SAME open source browser on any platform instead of clinging to a mobile browser (microb) with no long term benefits to the mobile community.

I say lets get on board and get mobile firefox for maemo on the fast track.

The extension compatibility alone would redefine the possibilities for the n8x0 platform.

GeneralAntilles 2008-02-25 04:07

Re: Minefield (new firefox) on OS2008
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jmancine (Post 147317)
But...responsiveness and simplicity do not guarantee function. Why not support the development of firefox for maemo? Simplicity is being able to run the SAME open source browser on any platform instead of clinging to a mobile browser (microb) with no long term benefits to the mobile community.

You do realize MicroB is Gecko based, right?


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:30.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8