maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N800 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=25)
-   -   3G on N800 (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=16293)

OppositeOfIgnorance 2008-02-07 20:41

3G on N800
 
in the future is there a chance that instead of Wi-fi hotspots, there'll be 3G hotspots?

and in more current news, Will 802.11N replace the dominance of G? i've seen a lotta new lappys with N support - or WiMAX perhaps?

i think there should be a mass movement within this forum, for someone SOMEBODY to develop a USB-in connector - either via external device, or something - that will allow us to do somethings like adding 3G Wireless adapters (if that becomes standard) ,and adding Wireless-N or wimax support (also, if that becomes standard)

seriously though, USB in would open SO many new doors. USB host, and video out may actually become a reality if someone perfects this theoretical USB in device.

GeneralAntilles 2008-02-07 20:59

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OppositeOfIgnorance (Post 139522)
in the future is there a chance that instead of Wi-fi hotspots, there'll be 3G hotspots?

What? 3G is for cellular data, and "hotspots" don't apply. :confused:

OppositeOfIgnorance 2008-02-07 21:04

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles (Post 139533)
What? 3G is for cellular data, and "hotspots" don't apply. :confused:

okay sorry thanks for not answering my question

mansonshake 2008-02-07 21:42

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OppositeOfIgnorance (Post 139522)
seriously though, USB in would open SO many new doors. USB host, and video out may actually become a reality if someone perfects this theoretical USB in device.

I'm not clear totally what you mean usb in but is this
what you are looking for? It shows usb in for keyboards hdd's n such:)

I don't know much about g3 or the other stuff but I hope this will help.

everythingsablur 2008-02-07 21:43

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OppositeOfIgnorance (Post 139537)
okay sorry thanks for not answering my question

But in a way he did answer your question. 3G is a label for cellular packet data. There is no simply need at all for a "3G hotspot"; anywhere you have cellular data you would have 3G coverage (provided your carrier offered such a service). In effect, the whole country is a hotspot.

802.11n is the next revision up from 802.11g, so yes, N will replace G in time just as G replaced 802.11b. The key is interoperability (i.e. why 802.11a failed to gain much traction at all as it was not interoperable with other standards as it operated at 5.8 Ghz instead of 2.4 Ghz). It's hardly a new thing. Old modem technologies always eventually superseded previous standards, and it took years for 802.11g to supplant 802.11b (I was running a B network back in ... 1999?).

WiMAX will see only limited support at the integrated hardware level as it is reliant on a carrier/provider/ISP of some sort to give you WiMAX service. I would never buy a laptop that required me to sign up with Company XYZ's WiMAX service to utilize hardware someone felt like shoving in my laptop. It has it's uses in devices like the OQO, but you don't see those flying off store shelves. Demand isn't there for such an expensive, locked in product. I don't even know if I'd want WiMAX as my at home internet service.

The need for a USB interface to connect to an adapter to connect to another service is a bit redundant. If you already carry a 3G cell phone, both devices are already fully equipped and capable of connecting over Bluetooth. Yes, eventually Bluetooth will become the bottleneck (if it isn't already) and we'll crave something faster, but by then these devices will have evolved well past their current iteration and likely have all of those things you want.

mansonshake 2008-02-07 21:53

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by everythingsablur (Post 139546)
The need for a USB interface to connect to an adapter to connect to another service is a bit redundant. If you already carry a 3G cell phone, both devices are already fully equipped and capable of connecting over Bluetooth. Yes, eventually Bluetooth will become the bottleneck (if it isn't already) and we'll crave something faster, but by then these devices will have evolved well past their current iteration and likely have all of those things you want.

I know alot of people including me (now-a-days) that dont have bluetooth on their phone but are able to connect from phone to pc with a data cord.
Would be nice for me when I'm on the go and not to purchase another phone as mine is just fine without bluetooth.
I'm sure in the future all phones will be equipped with bluetooth or something faster but for now id like to see if this would work with the n800 i'm purchasing soon!

Benson 2008-02-08 00:37

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mansonshake (Post 139551)
I know alot of people including me (now-a-days) that dont have bluetooth on their phone but are able to connect from phone to pc with a data cord.
Would be nice for me when I'm on the go and not to purchase another phone as mine is just fine without bluetooth.
I'm sure in the future all phones will be equipped with bluetooth or something faster but for now id like to see if this would work with the n800 i'm purchasing soon!

Should work, if your phone can be tethered in Linux with an open-source driver; I don't know of any cases where anyone's tried this, but it should work on the N8x0 (possibly with new kernel modules).

Benson 2008-02-08 00:40

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OppositeOfIgnorance (Post 139522)
in the future is there a chance that instead of Wi-fi hotspots, there'll be 3G hotspots?

and in more current news, Will 802.11N replace the dominance of G? i've seen a lotta new lappys with N support - or WiMAX perhaps?

i think there should be a mass movement within this forum, for someone SOMEBODY to develop a USB-in connector - either via external device, or something - that will allow us to do somethings like adding 3G Wireless adapters (if that becomes standard) ,and adding Wireless-N or wimax support (also, if that becomes standard)

seriously though, USB in would open SO many new doors. USB host, and video out may actually become a reality if someone perfects this theoretical USB in device.

What is "a USB-in connector"? I understand it's a theoretical device. But no-one I know uses that term, so we don't know what in the world you mean by it...

jackc111 2008-02-08 21:27

Re: 3G on N800
 
I recently tethered my HTC Mogul (Sprint) to my N800 through WiFi. There is a way to hack the Mogul so that it acts as a router and accepts incoming connections from multiple sources, bridges them to the EVDO-Rev A radio and out to the internet. It's just an ad hoc Wifi connection just like Bluetooth, but obviously it's not Bluetooth.

Google "WMWifirouter" or "Windows Mobile Wifi Router" which works on a few different types of WM phones.

I was actually able to put the Mogul in my work bag, connection the N800 to it with Wifi, and stream Internet radio while driving at 60 MPH on a bus. Not one single hiccup.

mansonshake 2008-02-08 23:26

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jackc111 (Post 139968)
I recently tethered my HTC Mogul (Sprint) to my N800 through WiFi. There is a way to hack the Mogul so that it acts as a router and accepts incoming connections from multiple sources, bridges them to the EVDO-Rev A radio and out to the internet. It's just an ad hoc Wifi connection just like Bluetooth, but obviously it's not Bluetooth.

Google "WMWifirouter" or "Windows Mobile Wifi Router" which works on a few different types of WM phones.

I was actually able to put the Mogul in my work bag, connection the N800 to it with Wifi, and stream Internet radio while driving at 60 MPH on a bus. Not one single hiccup.

Thats cool. Was it infact adhoc mode? Hope to see more ppl connecting without bluetooth just to see the results.:)

jackc111 2008-02-09 00:18

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mansonshake (Post 140012)
Thats cool. Was it infact adhoc mode? Hope to see more ppl connecting without bluetooth just to see the results.:)

It was definitely ad hoc mode. I had to go into the Mogul's settings and create an ad hoc connection before doing the registry hacks. Then I had to turn wifi radio on in the Mogul, then search for the AP in the N800 and connect as normal.

I would have used Bluetooth, but the DUN profiles are stripped out of the Mogul by Sprint, so Wifi was the easiest choice.

With the Sprint SERO plan, I basically have a portable 500-800 kbps (constant bit rate per DSLReports.com speed test) router with me at all times for only $30/month (comes with unlimited text and 500 mins as well). Once the EVDO Rev A upgrades are complete it should be over 1 mbps. Can't beat that unless you stay home all day.

ghoonk 2008-02-09 04:03

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles (Post 139533)
What? 3G is for cellular data, and "hotspots" don't apply. :confused:

I was thinking exactly the same thing. Not sure why the OP had a go at you on that though. Clearly, someone has no idea what 3G is or how it works.

To the OP: In theory, using USB OTG mode on the iT, you could hook up an external radio device such as a WiMax receiver or an EVDO modem (if one exists) via USB, but you'd still need drivers to make it work

OppositeOfIgnorance 2008-02-09 04:18

Re: 3G on N800
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ghoonk (Post 140109)
I was thinking exactly the same thing. Not sure why the OP had a go at you on that though. Clearly, someone has no idea what 3G is or how it works.

To the OP: In theory, using USB OTG mode on the iT, you could hook up an external radio device such as a WiMax receiver or an EVDO modem (if one exists) via USB, but you'd still need drivers to make it work

lols i know

rcadden 2008-02-09 04:27

Re: 3G on N800
 
Can someone please inform me as to what 3G-capable handset on the market doesn't have Bluetooth? I'm not trying to be daft, but I seriously can't think of a 3G handset that doesn't have Bluetooth.

ghoonk 2008-02-09 05:30

Re: 3G on N800
 
Fact is, MOST of them have. I cannot recall any 3G-enabled handset that doesn't have BT, and seeing that I'm not totally familiar with handset models in the USA, I didn't want to come to any conclusions about whether the phones you guys have there even come with BT.

In EMEA and Asia, most 3G phones come equipped with BT as well.

brecklundin 2008-02-09 11:42

Re: 3G on N800
 
or if you cannot get your USB 3G (either HSDPA or EVDO) modem to work with your N8x0 then consider a Cradlepoint PHS300 ( http://www.cradlepoint.com/ ) with a USB EVDO modem.

There is another thread in the Newbies section about this or at least it was steered that way...

http://www.internettablettalk.com/fo...ad.php?t=10770

Actually I no longer need a cell at all. Well, I keep a throw-away with an unactivated prepaid card around just in case everything else takes a dump. Otherwise I use Skype everywhere thanks to the Mobile Broadband data plan (in my case EVDO) I have with Millenicom (http://www.millenicom.com). One of my desires of from the N8x0, if I decide that is the device, is to use that service and the CDU680 EVDO USB modem I have. If I cannot get it to work with the tablet directly then I might consider using that Cradlepoint router. Google a bit and it will make sense. The router supports EVDO USB modems and acts as a Wifi Hotspot. So you can connect to the router using the tablet's wifi and viola instant 3G MBB connection to the web no overpriced and redundant cell phone needed. Plus with the router option I can be using one device and my better half can be using another and we can share the connection while we sit and have coffee somewhere or even are sitting under a tree in the park. See that router also has a Li-ION battery. Kinda cool...

I am not sure there are pocket/travel routers for HSDPA but I would imagine there must be some by now. And for the near future forget WiMax unless you live in a beta test area. And how useful is that for a "mobile" service? 3-years and we'll see something faster like WiMax...

Samatva 2008-02-10 17:18

Re: 3G on N800
 
The whole country (almost) is my hotspot via my Treo 700p:

http://www.mobile-stream.com/usbmodem.html


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:55.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8