maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N810 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=28)
-   -   N810 and Iphone Bluetooth (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=22396)

bearwitme 2008-07-29 17:36

N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
Has anyone been able to connect to internet via iPhone 's Blue tooth???
I just got my N810 and was able to pair the 2 devices but them when I go to connect it never does. Maybe I am missing a step??

Thanks
Connie

Laughing Man 2008-07-29 17:47

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
You won't be able to (easily). Apple limited the iPhone's bluetooth capabilities. (You can't use it as a modem without using some hacks). Which means jailbreaking it and such.

http://lifehacker.com/software/featu...top-327066.php

azemute 2008-07-29 17:48

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
AFAIK the iPhone does not support a number of somewhat important protocols in the bluetooth stack.

DUN/SPP is among them [Dial Up Networking] which is, generally, the most used network protocol. I gather this is what you are attempting to do with bluetooth via the iPhone, no? This is likely the trouble you are encountering.

Alas, the iPhone also doesn't support A2DP and OBEX which I suspect is likely a bit of a disappointment for some users as well.

fatalsaint 2008-07-29 17:53

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by azemute (Post 208330)
AFAIK the iPhone does not support a number of somewhat important protocols in the bluetooth stack.

DUN/SPP is among them [Dial Up Networking] which is, generally, the most used network protocol. I gather this is what you are attempting to do with bluetooth via the iPhone, no? This is likely the trouble you are encountering.

Alas, the iPhone also doesn't support A2DP and OBEX which I suspect is likely a bit of a disappointment for some users as well.

WTH?

Why in heaven's name would you even bother putting bluetooth into that device then????

Grrr.. Apple impressed me when they made their new OS based on a Unix base.. but they've since just been completely annoying me to death with their closed and microsoft-esque "use only our crap" mentality.

Seriously.. bluetooth without OBEX or DUN.. Why bother?

krisse 2008-07-29 19:28

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
The lack of A2DP is a surprise too, considering the iPhone's music player heritage. A lot of people would be buying it to play music, and A2DP is AFAIK the most common standard for wireless stereo headphones.

Benson 2008-07-29 19:41

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by fatalsaint (Post 208335)
WTH?

Why in heaven's name would you even bother putting bluetooth into that device then????

Grrr.. Apple impressed me when they made their new OS based on a Unix base.. but they've since just been completely annoying me to death with their closed and microsoft-esque "use only our crap" mentality.

Seriously.. bluetooth without OBEX or DUN.. Why bother?

A very good question. The only answer that even begins to make sense (to me) is with the intent to implement some stuff (A2DP, maybe OBEX) later, in newer firmware. DUN is gone; presumably a concession to AT&T, in which case it's probably never coming. A2DP should be there, of course; it's the phone that's an iPod, right?! so if they couldn't get it ready in time for firmware 2, it does make the state of NIT support much more understandable If they simply are refusing to implement it... <headshake /> I totally don't get it.

Laughing Man 2008-07-29 19:42

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
That's what really surprised me about the iPhone (and one of my greatest annoyances about it besides the app store being the only "correct" way of getting applications). Of course if I ever got an iPhone I'd have to jailbreak it.

Though I suppose they put bluetooth in the phone for the same reason most cell phone manufacturers do. HSP (hands free calling thru headset). My cell phone only has that and Obex, while if I look at my mom's (similar model, just higher on the price chain with a better camera and an mini sd slot) has full bluetooth support (ftp and everything).

But I think you can get networking working if you jailbreak it though. At least, that's what I've read.

bearwitme 2008-07-29 20:21

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Laughing Man (Post 208328)
You won't be able to (easily). Apple limited the iPhone's bluetooth capabilities. (You can't use it as a modem without using some hacks). Which means jailbreaking it and such.

http://lifehacker.com/software/featu...top-327066.php


Well that sucks the big weenie!!! Looks like I might be lucky to find some hotspots to be able to get to the net..I am very disapointed..
OK how about this..I have a broardband card on my laptop that I use to access the net. Is there anyway to tap into that to get to the web?? Unfortunately I moved about a year ago and they still do not have DSL or cable moden in my area. I had Satelitte internet but it was just to expensive and slow.

fatalsaint 2008-07-29 20:39

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
whatever your OS.. you should have the capability of sharing the internet connection from the broadband card across a wireless network (ad-hoc) and connect your N810 to that...

Or you might get experimental and see if you can get a USB 2 PCMCIA adapter to put the card into and get linux to work with it.

tso 2008-07-29 21:38

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
my guess:

at2p, no clue. but it could very well that jobs dont like the sound of music via that system. people keep claiming that ipod has the best sound, and to get the best sound one need a good wired headset so...

obex, not gonna happen. at best your looking at a special protocol over the serial bus profile that only itunes can talk. if you want to put something on or take something of the iphone, you have to go thru itunes.

dun/pan, again forget it. that is unless it becomes very popular with crackberry addicts that also need a tether for their laptops while on the road. but at that point, at&t and friends can just as well sell the user a expresscard "modem" and accompanying plan.

but thats me being norwegian, and seeing people from usa write about having to have the operator activate a special tethering plan makes me shake my head in disbelief.

and now a phone thats basically custom made for the us market have started to show up here, and people are hailing it as gods gift to mobile phone users. give me a freaking break...

the only interesting thing about it is the choice of touch sensor...

bearwitme 2008-07-30 11:37

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
Thanks all for the responses..I guess I will have to depend on Wifi. Don't want to Jaqil break my iPhone..

azemute 2008-07-30 19:12

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
I do have to agree that their choice of bluetooth protocol implementations is a bit... odd.

A2DP should be there; and likely is in some form, to be honest, but I am willing to bet that they were having performance issues. Apple does have a strong tendency to remove un-finished features to maintain a high degree of gloss / usability. It would not surprise me in the least if the audio quality and battery hit were too grave for Jobs, as it hurt the image of the device.

Someone else in here was spot on with OBEX and DUN/PAN I think... OBEX because they don't want you to be able to OBEX-push files to and from the device, probably because of the fundamentally locked-down nature of the system. DUN/PAN I can't really fathom entirely... to me it comes across as "curb features, simpler design" but I'm entirely unsure. It could easily have been as a toss to AT&T to allow the iPhone to fly on their network, but I still can't comprehend the decision... plenty of other phones support DUN/PAN and they seem to push the technology heavily.

Still, the iPhone only has token bluetooth support in my opinion, though it easily fullfills the primary goal: hands-free headset support. Basically required on any decent phone.

Also, I apologize if I'm amiss with any of this reasoning, I don't own an iPhone, my conclusions are simply from my readings and musings.

Pebby 2008-08-01 17:47

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
I wish I had enough faith in apple to think they didn't have A2DP because it 'wasn't ready,' but let us not forget - Apple wants you to use Apple stuff. They finally removed the proprietary headphone jack on the 3G iPhone - a MUSIC player, and it has a non-standard headphone jack. Nice one! I will happily bet money they didn't include A2DP because they'll be coming up with iWirelessHeadphones soon enough, and they will be the only ones that work with your iPhone. Apple would have loved to do that sooner, but it's hard to market a music device (iPod with a nonstandard jack). Once you add a phone, it gets a little easier. ;)

As others have said, OBEX falls under the category of 'able to put information on the device without using iTunes' which is just not what they want you to do. DUN, yeah right - AT&T even says using the DUN feature in your phone is against their Terms of Service.

Anyway, it's a total shame, and one of the reasons I got the n810 in the first place. It's sad they don't play nice together.

Laughing Man 2008-08-03 17:32

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
Ok, there has been a new application in the iPhone app store called NetShare. I think it's 10 dollars but it allows you to use your iPhone as a modem. Though the app was taken down and put back up a few days ago (developers had to talk with Apple to argue its use as something other then tethering.. [I think usage as a proxy or something].

andreww 2008-08-03 17:56

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
I heard about NetShare yesterday too. It's better than that, Laughing Man... Apple took it down, put it back up, and then took it down again, all without contacting the software developers. See: http://www.nullriver.com/

tso 2008-08-03 18:52

Re: N810 and Iphone Bluetooth
 
By the look of it, it will be made available in nations whos operators dont care if you have a tether plan or not...

But its yet an example of apple thinking that the world ends at the borders of usa...


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:02.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8