maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Accessories (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=17)
-   -   I Hate Screen Protectors (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=3112)

cagilaba 2006-09-19 22:26

I Hate Screen Protectors
 
I apologize in advance but I just have to vent. I noticed a couple of small scratches on my screen and decided it was time to invest in screen protectors. Well, I bought these stupid things: EXIM SPUC for lots of money, and had a hell of a time applying them. Difficult to get aligned. Impossible to align without dust getting stuck on the underside. Impossible to remove the dust. Bubbles. Makes me hate life. :mad: :mad: I don't know how people use these things without wasting lots of time and money???

I've given up and I'm just going to use my 770 without a screen protector :(

Odin 2006-09-20 01:54

Too soft, won't work...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cagilaba
I apologize in advance but I just have to vent. I noticed a couple of small scratches on my screen and decided it was time to invest in screen protectors. Well, I bought these stupid things: EXIM SPUC for lots of money, and had a hell of a time applying them. Difficult to get aligned. Impossible to align without dust getting stuck on the underside. Impossible to remove the dust. Bubbles. Makes me hate life. :mad: :mad: I don't know how people use these things without wasting lots of time and money???

I've given up and I'm just going to use my 770 without a screen protector :(

I guess you have discovered this (see title). My son has a PSP and I applied his SP for him--wasn't rocket science and now you would be hard-pressed to tell it was on there. Of course, the PSP has a hard, polycarbonate covered screen. I was able to press and "squeegee" quite hard to get a bubbleless surface. I can't see that happening with a 770--as your experience validates. I would say that by the time you actually start to gt a ragged display from all the use it will be time to upgrade anyway.

Don't get mad, get even--invent something better. BTW, good luck.

Vinh 2006-09-20 02:17

I got the BoxWave brand screen protector for my 770. It's fairly rigid and fairly easy to apply. If you mess up, like getting dust under the protector, you can just rinse it off and try again. It cost $13 for one sheet. In comparison, I bought a screen protector pack for my digital camera. I had to trim it to fit. It was foggy and impossible to get the bubbles out. Price was $10 for 6 sheets. The BoxWave, while more expensive, is a much better product.

phi 2006-09-20 02:53

Brando shop.brando.com.hk makes the best screen protectors. The only pain was getting it aligned but rarely did I get bubbles or dust.

gigabites 2006-09-20 07:48

I got a 10 pack of fellows writeright at radio shack for $15. It's a cut to fit job but there is an easy to follow grid on the backing plastic. I killed 2 before I figured out how to do it right. Good thing I got 10 of them, can't imagine spending $13 per sheet and messin up...ugh.

Ok, first was find the most dust/hair free room in the house. And it had to have prettyy good lighting. Since I don't have a "clean room" or an operating theater, the master bathroom fit the bill Then I gathered my supplies, easy removable clear tape, fat tweezers and scissors (they just happen to be in the bathroom) and an old creditcard.. And of course the screen protectors.

Then I cut a piece of paper to fit in the screen so I could have a template. Cutting the sheet was easy and the grid helped you more or less stay on track. Took off the old crappy screen protector I got from germany, it was like a cheap window magnet. Used the tape to catch any stray particles on the screen. When I peeled the plastic, I went down 3/4 of an inch and folded the backing so I can position it right. then I used the credit card to squeegy the film. The key here is go sloooow. Back up if you need to, to ge the bigger bubbles. It gets tricky at the end but if you hold the squeegy right, no prob. The sheet is amazingly clear and light and I didn't get any moire patterns like the old crappy one.

I did discover if you cut the sheet too perfect (tucks under the bezel a hair) the harder it will be to remove the sheet later on, just keep that in mind when you cut.

hope that helps.

Karel Jansens 2006-09-20 11:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odin
I guess you have discovered this (see title). My son has a PSP and I applied his SP for him--wasn't rocket science and now you would be hard-pressed to tell it was on there. Of course, the PSP has a hard, polycarbonate covered screen. I was able to press and "squeegee" quite hard to get a bubbleless surface. I can't see that happening with a 770--as your experience validates. I would say that by the time you actually start to gt a ragged display from all the use it will be time to upgrade anyway.

Don't get mad, get even--invent something better. BTW, good luck.

On my Newton (yes, it's me again, the Newton-nut, but stick with me) I used NuShield screen protectors, which are non-adhesive; they're shaped in such a way that they can be slid under the edges of the screen and stay in place due to some weird physics thing.

I don't know if they have 770-sized ones, but you can always drop a mail.

bac522 2006-09-20 11:45

i don't use them...

schmolch 2006-09-20 15:05

i used a brando protector for a while but removed it a few days ago.
writing on it just wasn't as precise as before and you also had to use much more pressure.

fondoo 2007-04-20 14:33

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
i used EXIM SPUC on my treo 700p and i also hated when i got dust under between the screen and screen protector. i eventually just took the damn thing off. i was going to get some EXIM SPUC for my new n800, but decided later.. screw it. let it breath :P

olawale 2007-04-20 16:01

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
people fyi, if you get dust and such on the protector before applying just use a piece of scotch tape to sticky it off.

vash 2007-04-20 16:34

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
You might want to apply the SP in a humid room - try placing the SP while in the washroom after a hot shower. The steam will eliminate the dust particles flying about in the air. Normally I try to avoid steam + electronics, but since you'll only apply it one time its not a big deal I think.

aaronw_1986 2007-04-22 17:03

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
get a JAVO Edge screen protector. Easiest installation ever, and I've had many gadgets. The way their system works, I have no bubbles on my screen. It's a really easy application of the sp.

jaymzz 2007-05-04 23:39

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by vash (Post 45228)
You might want to apply the SP in a humid room - try placing the SP while in the washroom after a hot shower. The steam will eliminate the dust particles flying about in the air. Normally I try to avoid steam + electronics, but since you'll only apply it one time its not a big deal I think.

Actually a cold shower works - this is the method I use when doing digital SLR sensor cleanings.

Still took me three sheets to get one without dust onto my N800.

luusyphre 2007-12-23 10:04

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by olawale (Post 45218)
people fyi, if you get dust and such on the protector before applying just use a piece of scotch tape to sticky it off.

OMG I wish I would have read this post before applying my Boxwave protector. I gave it multiple aggravating tries before discovering the scotch tape trick on my own. The scotch tape trick works well but there's a still a chance of debris getting under while you're picking away the stuff you were looking at, and by the time you set the protector back down there might be more crap underneath than when you started!

One method I used was to do the job as quickly as possible while lifting the protector off the screen as little as possible, which meant going under the protector with the scotch tape with the stick side still facing down. And if you haven't heard this before, to lift the protector up, just take a piece of scotch tape and tape it to the corner of the protector and lift up.

As for the Boxwave protectors themselves, they seem to be working pretty well so far (I've only used it for about 10 minutes). The screen actually looks brighter and I have not lost any touch sensitivity. The only major problem I have with mine is one of the lateral edges is actually damaged (not sure if I did it with all my reapplications) but now there's a big air bubble, that won't go away, stretching across the top of my screen. I can only see if I look for it (but I KNOW it's there!) or if the screen is black or off. It doesn't really interfere with my clicking so hopefully I'll be able to live with it, but chances are it'll drive me crazy.

Karel Jansens 2007-12-23 10:31

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
Another trick often suggested is to go in the bathroom, let a very hot shower run for a few minutes until everything is nicely steamed up and clean your screen and apply the protector in there. It appears the hot steam creates a dust-free environment.

Never tried it myself tho...

iamthewalrus 2007-12-23 13:34

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
I used the steamy shower method, plus a compressed air dust can like this one:

http://www.fellowes.com/Fellowes/ima...arge/99791.jpg

I have maybe two or three tiny airbubbles left but I can live with that.

Karel Jansens 2007-12-23 14:11

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
In fact, next time I just lick my screen clean.

Hey, it works for the cat's bollocks! :p (Finally! a smiley that's 100% tuned in!)

barry99705 2007-12-23 21:47

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
Steamy room works a treat. I used that method for installing a window in a laptop hard drive. Drive still works too!

http://idisk.mac.com/barrywoods/Public/drive_window.jpg

munky261 2007-12-31 03:47

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
lol at the cats bollocks comment.....not ive got the mental image of a cat licking itself stuck in my head...THANKS!! lol lol

gemniii42 2007-12-31 04:06

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
y'all get to worked up.
just cut a piece of vu-graph transparency film to fit under the bezel

bartsimpson123844 2008-01-01 16:44

Re: I Hate Screen Protectors
 
Yeah, you really get what you pay for when buying screen protectors. I went the cheap route and got one from China....wow that was a huge waste of $4.98. Buy a name brand one or one that has a good reputation. I've learned my lesson. :)


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:10.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8