Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Hi all,
The results of the Maemo Community Council are available - and we have a new Council. The Council for the coming 6 months will be:

• Randall Arnold (Texrat)
• Matthew Lewis(penguinbait)
• Alan Bruce (qole)
• Valerio Valerio (VDVsx)
• Graham Cobb (gcobb)

You can see the details of the count at http://maemo.org/vote/results.php?election_id=7

Congratulations to all the successful candidates, and commiserations to all those who were not elected.

For anyone who wishes to double-check the election results, you can obtain a list of the votes at http://maemo.org/vote/votes.php?election_id=7 and you can download the ballots on OpenSTV format, and re-run the election count yourself, at http://maemo.org/vote/blt.php?election_id=7

Cheers,
Dave.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Total # of "first choice votes"

qole 66
Texrat 50
VDVsx 38
gcobb 37
penguinbait 37
lcuk 30
sjgadsby 15
AndrewFBlack 14
zerojay 11


Total # of votes received

qole 216
Texrat 199
lcuk 192
penguinbait 186
VDVsx 185
gcobb 183
sjgadsby 179
zerojay 158
AndrewFBlack 146

Its interesting to me, that the # of "first choice" votes match the winners. It bums me out that lcuk received the 3rd highest # of total votes yet did not get a seat on council. :(

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Congratulations and all that.... and now go to work! ;)

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

The joys of STV - if you're always the 2nd or 3rd preference, and you don't get enough 1st choices, you're not going to get elected.

If you do the same test with just the 1st to 5th preference votes, how does it work out? (I haven't tried, just wondering).

Dave.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

# of 1st choice votes

qole 66
Texrat 50
VDVsx 38
gcobb 37
penguinbait 37
lcuk 30
sjgadsby 15
AndrewFBlack 14
zerojay 11


# of 2nd Choice Votes

qole 53
Texrat 51
penguinbait 34
sjgadsby 31
gcobb 30
VDVsx 22
lcuk 21
AndrewFBlack 16
zerojay 14

# of 3rd Choice Votes

zerojay 33
qole 32
penguinbait 32
sjgadsby 30
lcuk 30
gcobb 28
Texrat 28
VDVsx 26
AndrewFBlack 11

# of 4th Choice Votes

qole 30
lcuk 28
sjgadsby 28
VDVsx 25
zerojay 25
penguinbait 21
Texrat 21
gcobb 18
AndrewFBlack 15


# of 5th Choice Votes

lcuk 31
VDVsx 24
zerojay 21
sjgadsby 19
penguinbait 17
qole 16
AndrewFBlack 15
Texrat 14
gcobb 13

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

So totals of 1 through 5 are:

qole: 66 + 53 + 32 + 30 + 16 = 197
Texrat: 50 + 51 + 28 + 21 + 14 = 164
penguinbait: 37 + 34 + 32 + 21 + 17 = 141
lcuk: 30 + 21 + 30 + 28 + 31 + 140
VDVsx: 38 + 22 + 26 + 25 + 24 = 135
gcobb: 37 + 30 + 28 + 18 + 13 = 126
sjgadsby: 15 + 31 + 30 + 28 + 19 = 123
zerojay: 11 + 14 + 33 + 25 + 21 = 104
AndrewFBlack: 14 + 16 + 11 + 15 + 15 = 71

Looking at the preferences distribution, it's clear that lcuk was 3rd, 4th or 5th preference for a lot of people, but penguinbait, VDVsx and gcobb are all ahead of him in 1st and 2nd preferences - and those weigh more on the result than 4th or 5th preference.

Cheers,
Dave.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

See, this is why we should have used the US electoral system that was in place from 2000-2008, where we held elections, but just made up the results.

Don't misunderestimate me, I'm not saying anything for or against those who won here... it's simply much funner that way.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Congratulations to everybody!

Dear lazyweb, how was the participation compared to previous votings? The merge with Talk can be seen now clearly in the results, but what about the universe of voters and the percentage of participation?

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

It was posted in another thread, that 303 ballots were cast, 298 of them were non-empty. Compared to I believe 162 voters last election.

I do not know how many eligible voters there was? (in either election)

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

1- Election-> 936 voters
2- Election -> 166 voters
3- Election -> 303 voters

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

So at least we did a lot better than Florida in the 2000 election :)

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

I, for one, welcome our new community overlords.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Is it me or do we have a unduly high amount of vermin on the council this time? A rat, racoon, and whatever a the qole thing is.....:D

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

The new council should be named the Furry council.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

I'm only serving one term... then I'm gonna work as Gadsby's campaign manager next. :D

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Haha, congrats to everybody who are now on the council. :)

Edit: Interesting breakdown of the votes. I've always thought the European system (or the preference of this is the first, this is the second, etc..) is more fair than the USA's current all or none.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Yeah, the difference between parliamentarian style and ours is pretty stark. I'd actually like to try living under the former to see what it's like...

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

The bushy board?

Hopefully not the bristly board.

As (Google says) the Finns say: Onnea!

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Congrats :)

Almost all voting methods currently in use suffer from problems such as tactical voting. [EDIT: I meant this in context of nations[/EDIT]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Table_o...tems_by_nation

You're considering to relocate? ;)

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

I wish I could. I would still be employed by Nokia if I could have relocated. Traveling is as close as I can get.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Remember what I said about not trusting people with a first name for their last name?

• Randall Arnold (Texrat)
• Matthew Lewis(penguinbait)
• Alan Bruce (qole)
• Valerio Valerio (VDVsx)
• Graham Cobb (gcobb)

Looks like Graham is the only trustworthy one in the bunch :D

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Valerio's name was so cool his parents had to use it twice.

Assuming his middle name is different.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Congrats and condolences... http://www.clicksmilies.com/auswahl/ernaehrung004.gif

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Bingo ;) . You just won 10 'virtual' N900 candy's :p

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

The boy's name Cobb \c(o)-bb\ is of Old English origin.

uh oh, look out 5 out of 5



I was looking around and I found this, it made me laugh

http://www.lewiscobb.com/images/hdr-logo.gif

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

Nobody told you that council members need to relocate to the maemo.org brand new offices at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interna...urt_of_Justice ? This is why you all got the one way flight ticket to Amsterdam for free in the first place...

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

holy cow QUIM MADE A JOKE!!!! :eek: :p

The result: http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php...837#post336837

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

maemo.org is source of inspiration for many jokes flying in my mind and surroundings of my desk. Having a public role has certain weight and anyway most of the fun gets lost in translation. In my mother language it's not easy to connect 3 sentences without inviting to a smile.

Back to the topic. Ok we have numbers of actual voters but we still don't have numbers of potential voters so we don't know whether there is any trend in the participation?

The number of voters in each of the 3 elections is very different and I was trying to find a pattern.

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

The size of the 'real' voting body will be hard to determine as karma is timeless, so there are quite a lot of folks not much over the 10 karma line who no longer have an interest in Maemo (for example when I did a stat check back in July, there were ~500 active users on t.m.o. which is a LOT less than the number of registered folks with enough karma to vote).

Re: Maemo Community Council election: results are in!
 

There's http://wiki.maemo.org/Task:Community...ligible_voters for the first election (12287 voters). I can't find the lists for the other two, but dneary should have them somewhere.