maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N900 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=35391)

etuoyo 2010-05-13 16:07

N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Okay having had my brain continually exploded by the endless "you should have done your research" comments and "I don't have that problem so the problem does not exist" I have decided to put together a list of known issues with the device.

This is so potential buyers can see in one place all the main (negative) issues with the device and can weigh it against its plus points.

Note that some of the issues listed have fixes/work arounds such as using free third party apps. The linked thread here contains the fixes or work arounds to these issues. Some other issues are expected to be fixed in the next firmware update.

http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?p=657204

Please do not attack me pointlessly as so many of you love to do. This is meant to be constructive. Let me know what issues you think I have missed out so the list can be as comprehensive as possible.

Please do not say I don't have that issue so it does not exist. Everything I will list other than from what others have contributed will be from my own experience and I am not making anything up.

Maybe eventually this can be changed to a wiki or something. Hopefully this will prevent others buying a device which is not suitable for them.

There will of course be some comparisons with iphone despite the fact many will hate that. However, that is the phone most potential buyers of the N900 would also be considering.

On schettj's suggestion I have broken this down into Issues and Annoyances. Issues will cover more significant issues and possible annoyances will try to cover things that some may consider to be nothing but are important for others. An example would be the lack of custom ringtone which many don't care about but is a big deal for me. Both categories though will still try to list all the things people would take into account when buying a phone but will not necessarily be able to find out from reviews. For example I have read three lenghty HTC Desire reviews and don't know the answer to many of the things I consider important. All I can tell is it is smooth and can be customized alot but I can't tell how much.

Something like the media player widget not working may not be a big deal at all but I have put it in issues because well it shows a general lack of care and attention to detail from Nokia towards their product. You may or may not agree with me but can't think of any other big phone company creating a widget that does not work.

(A) ISSUES


Hardware


(1)The screen scratches more easily than capacitive screens. I have two very large scratches on my screen despite making sure I put absolutely nothing in the same pocket as the N900. Be sure you use a screen protector because no matter how careful you are the screen may get scratched.

(2) There is a serious manufacturing defect with the micro-usb socket of some of the N900s. For some it has fallen out completely. For me the device no longer charges from a charger. It has to be charged from PC via USB cable. Nokia have been made aware of the problem and it is believed they have fixed it in the latest builds but there is no guarantee you will not end up with an older batch so be aware of this risk.

Battery

(3) If you do not have IM accounts turned on then the battery should easily last you through the day. However, with some IM accounts (not sure which are the culprits but yahoo and msn seem to be amongst) you should generally expect around 6 hours use on average. With facebook and gtalk chats only being on you can expect to get up to 10 hours. This is not really an issue specific to the N900 though - Engagdet's review of the HTC Desire says they had 6 hours with similar use. Just seems to be a case of modern smart phones having become as smart as laptops and I can barely get an hour out of either of my laptops. Note that some have quite solid battery life even with IM accounts on they can get through the day without needing a recharge.

Interface/Operating System

(4) Some devices randomly restart. This was fixed in a previous firmware but still occurs for a few.

(5) If you have a lot of media going to a folder with many sub-folders or files will cause the device to slow down to the point of the file manager being unusable.

(6) The device can sometimes be slow and unresponsive. If you are a Linux expert or are lucky you will never have any slow down or apps freezing up. However, it is generally not as snappy as an iphone for the general user where you tap an icon and it opens up immediately.

(7) It takes relatively long to switch from portrait mode to landscape and vice versa.

(8) There is no full portrait mode on the device so makes one handed operation rather difficult or virtually impossible. There is only portrait mode on phone app, web browser and some third party apps.

(9) No SIM toolkit support which makes it difficult to use internet banking on the device in certain territories such as Finland.

Maps/Navigation

(10) The Ovi Maps version on the N900 is outdated and misses voice turn by turn navigation. Note that most symbian devices have a full navigation software with turn by turn and voice whether walking or by car and this is free on these devices. On the N900 you have a choice of third party programmes to get this (one free one paid).


Media Player


(11) Videos stutter a lot for the first few seconds of play back.

(12) The N900 has a serious problem with displaying proper tags for music files. For some it works fine for some it doesn't. For me it shows album artist and never song artist and album artist is almost pointless for me as many of my songs are from compilations and so just shows Various Artist rather than e.g. R. Kelly. Free third party apps such as Media Box do not have this problem but may have their own issues.

(13) Some album art do not show even though embedded.

(14) Tracker which updates media file info is very often defective. You can add media files and they not show up in the media player for a week. You can reset tracker or kill it, etc using terminal but be warned it is very often not like what you are used to where you transfer files via usb and your files show up immediately.

(15) No proper functioning software to sync with your PC the way itunes syncs perfectly with iphone. You can use drag and drop but that is only helpful for the first sync of all your music and when you add new songs to your PC and are sure exactly what the news songs are and can just drag and drop them. There is Ovi Music but it does not work with the N900. Third party PC software programmes can sync but many of them just sync to the main documents folder or the main music folder rather than in an organised manner (via artist, album artist, etc) and so create a huge mess and will kill your use of file manager. You may get something to work properly but will be quite an effort compared to using itunes and iphone.

(16) The play button on the media player widget does not work for some. It seems this may have something to do with the other widgets you have installed.

(17) No way to stretch to full screen in the default media player (though mplayer a free third party app will do so).

Email

(18) There is no easy way to search your emails.

(19) Nokia Messaging sometimes has delay in pushing emails to the device. Delay can be 15 minutes, can be a couple of hours. If you have a job where you need to be contacted immediately by email better to use a blackberry.

Phone

(20) For some it randomly goes to speaker mode whilst you are on the phone. It does not appear to be a widely known issue so may be talking of small fractions of a percentage here in terms of affected devices. However, it has recently started happening to me on around 25% of calls.

(21) For some the call volume drops on and off.

(22) No way to set the phone to divert all calls to voicemail. You need to download a free third party app to achieve this.

(23) Cannot dial numbers starting with * or # without the use of a free third party widget so without the third party widget you are unable to top up your credit or check your balance in certain countries. This is expected to be fixed in the next firmware update.

(24) No MMS unless you get a free third party app.

Connectivity with External Devices

(25) Connectivity with external devices via can sometimes be a bit hit and miss. Some bluetooth headphones which are listed as compatible may fail to connect with the device.

(B) POSSIBLE ANNOYANCES

Hardware

(1) Only three row keyboard layout so you need to use alternate for the numbers keys.

Interface/Operating System

(2) The transition between the four desktops is not very smooth for some users. This may depend on what you have on your desktop or what you have running. It may also simply be a case of some can notice it and some can't.

(3) You cannot jump to the particular desktop you want like you can with HTC's Sense interface. You can scroll forward or backwards so can go from 1 to 2 or 1 to 4. But you cannot go straight from 1 to 3. You must scroll through 2 to get to 3.

(4) Scrolling through a long list can be quite jerky. For example if you are scrolling through the thumbnails of your photos.

(5) The screen does not refresh automatically. If the screen goes off (battery saver) when you wake it up it will very briefly show exactly what it was showing before it went to sleep. So if the time was 14.50 then and is now 16.30 it will initially show 14.50. Or if you are listening to music it will show the song details of the song that was playing before the screen went off.

Ovi Store

(6) This does not work properly with the N900. I may be wrong but at present it is not even working at all. Also if you are using your PC you cannot easily load apps from Ovi Store to your N900 the way you can with itunes and iphone. If you choose to install an app on your PC all that happens is you get a link sent to your phone by sms and then you have to follow the link which takes you to the Ovi Store. You can of course browse directly to the store from the device but would be nice to have the option to also search for apps on a bigger screen and have them download automatically to the device like you can with iphone.

Media Player

(7) Creating playlists is not as intuitive as it should be. You need to add songs to now playing list then create playlist from the now playing list.

(8) Currently no equaliser. However, a free third party app is in the works to deal with this.

Phone


(9) The phone cannot say the name of the caller out of the box. There is a free third party app to get round this.

(10) You cannot have custom ringtones for each caller.

(11) You cannot have caller groups.

(12) The call log is pretty poor compared to symbian. It just lists all types of calls (incoming, outgoing, missed) in one long list with no option to filter by missed calls, received calls, etc.

(13) Only general and silent profiles (although there is an app that seeks to get around that).

(14) No call timers.

Address Book

(15) On symbian devices prior to the N97 you could edit the name of an address book contact. Very useful if you have someone with more than one number. For example call one number T-Mobile and another Orange. That way you easily know which of their phones you are calling. Or you could call one blackberry so you know it is their blackberry you are calling or texting. This feature is no longer available not just on the N900 but as I mentioned the N97 and probably all Nokia devices since. I believe this was a deliberate decision by Nokia rather than any oversight and the reason for this is that this edited info cannot be transferred/backed up from one device to another.

Special Issues

This section contains issues which may not be very wide spread but I have put them down because they are present on my device. Some can suggest other issues they have which no one else seems to have.

(i) If playing video I cannot receive calls.

(ii) Sometimes the phone rings with a blank screen for a few seconds so no way to answer the phone. I know a few others have had this issue but not sure how wide spread it is.

tigerswood 2010-05-13 16:18

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
You could also add the ridiculous Ovi Maps application and even more ridiculous Ovi Store, both of which make me wanna cry. One could also come up with a long list of issues/omissions in the Calendar app.

andraeseus1 2010-05-13 16:19

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
i cant disagree with you. those all seem to be legit hiccups and most of which i have experienced my self. hope no one buys this phone who cant afford to deal with these inconveniences

ysss 2010-05-13 16:21

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Good thread;

Let's keep it clean, courteous and on topic guys. No need to use charged words and sentences here.

sajman 2010-05-13 16:24

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
no MMS out of the box

acvetkov 2010-05-13 16:29

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Never seen or heard of the two specific issue. I have recieved many calls while watching a divx movie. Regarding the other points you are more or less right. I want to note that the "The N900 has a serious problem with displaying proper tags for music files." its not correct statement. The correct one is that N900 reads the Tags as they should be i.e. if the tag is not properly set its not N900 fault.

When I copy mp3 or video from pc in USB storage and i "safely remove n900" the video/mp3 shows insta. Its more personal issue I believe.

Venemo 2010-05-13 16:31

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Hey etuoyo,

Are you getting paid for this?

I mean, I understand that you don't like the N900 and stuff. You probably work for a competing company and your job is to disband the Maemo community. (Or you're just a plain fanboy?)

I experience NONE of the issues you listed, so I don't believe you.
You lie!

Seriously, why couldn't you post your rant to an already existing thread?

roger_27 2010-05-13 16:34

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
I love my phone to death, but I really wish I had customizable ringtones for separate contacts. so there's something you can add to this list.

No customizable ringtones for contacts

Texrat 2010-05-13 16:34

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
While I'm glad to see this sort of approach, parts of the starter post looks more like personal experience/opinion than an objective description. One example is the claim of screen scratching. I'm not debating this from a "never happened to me so can't happen" standpoint (that's a logical fallacy) but on the other hand it hasn't happened to me despite the fact that (and I admit this with some embarrassment) I have not taken proper care of my screen and yet still not a single scratch. In fact my device has been dropped to concrete a couple of times.

However, I did get some scratches on an N800 and here's what I discovered: dirt and dust can contain traces of extremely hard minerals, including diamond. One tiny speck getting stuck to a stylus point can do significant damage.

So I would certainly caution people as you have, and screen protectors can be a very good idea. Same for wiping the screen and stylus tip before using them. I just think including additional context in a complaint is helpful too. In this case, the issue is not one of hardware but contamination and poor handling. The N900 screen is actually very resilient.

That said, you're providing a great service here etuoyo, thanks.

optimistprime 2010-05-13 16:38

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Very well presented list. I can agree with alot of the points, but some users may experience some bugs while othes dont. Even with all of the annoyances, there is no other phone for me but the N900.

wmarone 2010-05-13 16:40

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
I do have scratches on my screen but it's no worse than any other resistive device that I've used. The worst ones (about 2) were suffered back in December after I first got the thing. But a screen protector is a good idea, regardless.

And I highly recommend converting this into a Wiki page and re-categorizing some of these, as (like Texrat noted) some of these are more opinion, like the 3-row keyboard and means by which you transition desktops, than actual issues like the USB port and mp3 tag issue.

marcsony 2010-05-13 16:41

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Get Call forwarding applet to divert calls to voicemail. Ive got it never used it lol. Still it may do what you require.

rcarlos 2010-05-13 16:45

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
just to add on the issues i have with N900(some of them are abt to get fixed in 1.2)
Phone
1.no call timers
2.disconnect button some times not visible when a call is received
3.unable to use SIP account to call a contact telephone
4.no USSD dial feature OOB
5.cant copy a number from call history(might not b needed but i found a requirement)
6. disconnect call and send message doesnt work always
7.no option to add contacts to SIM

rcarlos 2010-05-13 16:58

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
to list the positives i have experienced,
browser
1. the best browser around. can beat any phone in the market.
2. replaces the need for many online apps such as twitter
ya some times it crashes on me but not a problem as long as the xperience is good

messaging or rather conversations

1.conversations is unique and certainly better than what i have experienced on the other phones

nicolai 2010-05-13 17:00

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(i) Many devices randomly restart.

How much are "many", 2 percent, 10, 30?

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(ii) The transition between the four desktops is far from smooth.

Ok, but this highly depends on the installed applications,
mainly desktop widgets.

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(ix) There is no full portrait mode on the device so makes one handed operation rather difficult or virtually impossible. There is only portrait mode on web browser and some third party apps.

You forget one important portrait mode support. The phone.

etuoyo 2010-05-13 17:00

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by acvetkov (Post 657063)
Never seen or heard of the two specific issue. I have recieved many calls while watching a divx movie. Regarding the other points you are more or less right. I want to note that the "The N900 has a serious problem with displaying proper tags for music files." its not correct statement. The correct one is that N900 reads the Tags as they should be i.e. if the tag is not properly set its not N900 fault.

When I copy mp3 or video from pc in USB storage and i "safely remove n900" the video/mp3 shows insta. Its more personal issue I believe.

Sorry I disagree with that first part. My tags show properly on everything besides the N900 media player. They even show properly on Media Box on the N900. e.g. a song by R Kelly ft Celine Dion will show as exactly that. In the tags R Kelly is the album artist, R Kelly ft Celine Dion is the track artist. The Media Player on N900 shows R Kelly rather than R kelly ft Celine Dion. Media Box on N900, Windows Media Player, Media Monkey, Winamp, Itunes and my Creative Mp3 player all show R Kelly ft Celine Dion. Surely you are not suggesting they are all wrong and the N900 media player is right?

On the second point on media not showing immediately you are lucky yours works but it is a widespread problem and even as I am typing this reply there is a thread on the Active Topics list about this.

omeriko9 2010-05-13 17:01

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Please do not say I don't have that issue so it does not exist.
No problem, but you can't ask that and then say:

Quote:

I have decided to put together a list of known issues with the device
And:
Quote:

...so potential buyers can see in one place all the main issues with the device
I don't experience most of the problems you described. I don't claim they don't exists, but this is definitely not an objective post for potential consumers to look for at the first results page they get from google, and as Texrat mentioned, that need to be said, and probably enough times to give the right balance to those potential buyers.

Also, many of the missing features you mentioned has a 3rd party (usually free & open source) application to fill the gap.

Some examples: USSD, Portrait mode (many apps implement it, now SMS as well), say name of caller (dedicated app), minimal call log (dedicated app), lack of profiles, divert calls to voice mail (turn GSM off) and so on (all in here at talk.maemo.org and the wiki).

giecsar 2010-05-13 17:04

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
I think someone already said this, but some of the "issues" you mention aren't really issues, it's just stuff you don't like or doesn't suit your needs.

The lack of the portrait mode for instance is not an issue at all, it is by design. Take a closer look at the "Nokia" logo and the "N900" text, what's the orientation? When you slide out the keyboard, what's its orientation? When you pull out the kickstand to watch a movie, what's the orientation of the screen?
The N900 has phone capabilities as an added bonus, but it's actually an internet tablet (or mobile computer if you like). This is what everyone forgets and then gets frustrated about the interface not working in portrait mode like any other phone.

geneven 2010-05-13 17:05

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
It is interesting that Texrat has never experienced screen scratching, but screen scratching was reported by quite a few users before the vast majority of N900 users (including me) bought screen protectors.

Venemo's statement that he has experienced none of the issues listed can't be true and therefore the objectivity of his saying so must be questioned. One of the issues listed is that the phone cannot say the name of the caller. I don't think that Venemo is claiming that his phone can say the name of the caller, but by saying he does not experience any of the issues listed he does imply that HIS phone DOES say the name of the caller.

imperiallight 2010-05-13 17:05

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
http://www.gizmodo.com/assets/resour...oy-anatomy.jpg

etuoyo 2010-05-13 17:07

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nicolai (Post 657114)
How much are "many", 2 percent, 10, 30?


Ok, but this highly depends on the installed applications,
mainly desktop widgets.



You forget one important portrait mode support. The phone.

I will change many to some then.

Yeah knew there was a portrait mode I was forgetting but couldn't remember what it was.

giecsar 2010-05-13 17:11

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
etuoyo, you really need to remove the parts where it's about your personal preferences only if you want this to be a reference for those wishing to buy the N900 (and possibly you will also stop receiving negative replies).

etuoyo 2010-05-13 17:18

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by giecsar (Post 657123)
I think someone already said this, but some of the "issues" you mention aren't really issues, it's just stuff you don't like or doesn't suit your needs.

The lack of the portrait mode for instance is not an issue at all, it is by design. Take a closer look at the "Nokia" logo and the "N900" text, what's the orientation? When you slide out the keyboard, what's its orientation? When you pull out the kickstand to watch a movie, what's the orientation of the screen?
The N900 has phone capabilities as an added bonus, but it's actually an internet tablet (or mobile computer if you like). This is what everyone forgets and then gets frustrated about the interface not working in portrait mode like any other phone.

Please be more specific. Which ones are the things I have listed that are not real issues and I will edit. For example someone said their is a third party app to get call divert. I did not know about that. I edited my first post to reflect there is such an app. It is still an issue because some willl not know there is a third party app and some will expect them to be in there without the need for a third party app. But they certainly do exist and apart from the last section they are things I know for certain others besides me have experienced.

The point of the list is that everyone says you should have done your research. It is in no way intended as a review. It is a list of things that you may not get from reviews and may only get by using the device for a certain period. It is a warning for potential buyers. I have no duty to Nokia to not deprive them of any potential customers. If anything on the list is an issue for them they consider, weigh it against all the pluses and make their decision.

Texrat 2010-05-13 17:19

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by geneven (Post 657125)
It is interesting that Texrat has never experienced screen scratching, but screen scratching was reported by quite a few users before the vast majority of N900 users (including me) bought screen protectors.

Note that I acknowledged experiencing it on the N800. And as a former Nokia QA engineer who analyzed numerous product defects and their causes, I'm very well aware of how huge the issue of contamination is for these devices... external and internal.

Dust is a big one mainly due to static. If assemblers do not wear the proper grounding straps, they tend to introduce dust into the mechanics of a device. But beyond that, in general use, dust likes to go to objects that cause and/or attract static. The motion of a stylus against a screen, especially under certain environmental conditions, can increase that probability.

So odds are I've just been fortunate in my use that no damaging particles have insinuated themselves between stylus and screen. While I have been way too casual with regards to screen protection, I *am* careful when it comes to static. VERY careful. In fact, no carpet in my house. That static avoidance may well be the difference here. Nothing that should be so surprising, geneven, just physics.

rcarlos 2010-05-13 17:19

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
etuoyo, its a very good initiative.dont bother abt the references nor being in wiki. let potential buyers know what to expect.

wld have loved such a thread providing all this consolidated information b4 i spent my 600$

Texrat 2010-05-13 17:25

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rcarlos (Post 657146)
wld have loved such a thread providing all this consolidated information b4 i spent my 600$

Some of these complaints have been around since the launch (some even before, from early testers). Nothing prevented anyone from putting together a reasonably objective list long ago. In fact I encouraged complainants to do so months ago but this is the first time I've seen anyone take that up this comprehensively.

geneven 2010-05-13 17:32

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
It is great to have a fairly objective list that can be challenged and added to. In fact, I'm going back and adding a Thanks to the original posting.

zanzibar2 2010-05-13 17:36

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Venemo (Post 657064)
Hey etuoyo,

Are you getting paid for this?

I mean, I understand that you don't like the N900 and stuff. You probably work for a competing company and your job is to disband the Maemo community. (Or you're just a plain fanboy?)

I experience NONE of the issues you listed, so I don't believe you.
You lie!

Seriously, why couldn't you post your rant to an already existing thread?

...and why cant etuoyo let some steam off? He / she is merely collating all know existing problems / bugs and bringing them to light and asking for anyone else to add other issues. How else for Nokia to create a fix? :rolleyes:

I like the fact this has not been tagged onto another thread - it has a good header and its fresh.

This list is invaluable for both potential N900 users and existing users alike. From a mobile phone point of view Its an expensive piece of kit. As a community who know the product we should be obliged to provide information about what we know about the N900 so we can end up being a happy community. Not everyone has had the same success as you so instead of lambasting etuoyo why not embrace the fact he / she is only trying to help? :)

I also happen to think you were quite rude to etuoyo. No need for explanations marks either. :p

Zan ;)

nosa101 2010-05-13 17:37

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
can this thread be sticky'd and all the other complaint thread get merged into this one?

Texrat 2010-05-13 17:46

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nosa101 (Post 657169)
can this thread be sticky'd and all the other complaint thread get merged into this one?

I won't argue with a sticky, but etuoyo has taken a more professional approach than many of the complaint threads so I prefer this one not be corrupted by them.

NokiaRocks 2010-05-13 17:48

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Most things are correct. But it's still the best phone out there imho.

schettj 2010-05-13 17:51

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
While I agree that several of the OP issues are either "by design" or "personal experience" it isn't a bad list. Once 1.2 is out, we should strike out the resolved items. Here are my comments

- general - number the list from the top, not i, ii per each subheading, for easy comments :D Also, since this is for NEW purchases we should be assuming FW 1.1 at least, old issues resolved since then need not be rehashed here.

Hardware
i) the screen is resistive, all resistive screens scratch, so this is not an issue of the 900. The takeaway here is "use a screen protector on any device with a resistive screen." In MY experience, from a long history of HTC/WinMo Resistive screen devices, if anything the n900 is LESS susceptible to scratching. Still, I have a protector on mine.

ii) yep this was true and was supposed to be fixed in future runs. I have an early run device, and *with care* still have a fully functional usb port.

iii) preference, not an Issue. Suggest striking.

Battery

battery lasts as expected. Non issue.

Interface/OS

i) addressed LONG ago, strike
ii) user dependent, strike
iii) by design, not an issue, strike
iv) hard to quantify - it's not an "issue" as in something that prevents you from accomplishing a task or function. Maybe we could have "annoyance" for this kind of thing?
v) same as iv
vi) same as v
vii) same as vi
viii) same as vii (ie, "performance" annoyances are subjective, and possible on any device from iPhone to Palm WebOS to Android to Maemo)

ix) by design, not an issue. File under "annoyance" or "things we wish it did, but doesn't do"?

Maps/Nav

Annoyance not issue. There are plenty of platforms where you have to buy turn by turn nav. This is one.

Ovi Store

Yep. Check back after 1.2

Media Player
i) dependent on encoding used on media, annoyance not issue
ii) apparently this depends on the id3 tag format used on your media.
iii) yep
iv) yep
v) annoyance
vi) annoyance (sorry, its not an iPhone, and Apple does NOT allow 3rd parties to play with iTunes. Sucks. Buy an iPhone)
vii) annoyance
viii) you have a few of these in here, and I'm not sure they belong. Maybe a third section "things some people sometime may have had happen"?
ix) yep

Email
i) yep
ii) hemmm... not sure about this. MfE (which is what you would use if you have exchange) has no delay. The FREE, BETA Nokia Messaging doesn't have a SLA. If you use iMAP or POP, you can decide to burn as much battery as you like to get messages every 1, 5, 10, etc minutes. Annoyance at best.

Phone
i) sure, but its an annoyance or feature you want not one that is promised but not working
ii) this is True, and one hopes Will Be Added but again, like (i) is NOT a promised feature that isn't working...
iii) see ii
iv) "pretty poor" - annoyance
v) goes under "stuff that may have happened to someone somewhere"
vi) see v
vii) annoyance since it is working as designed
viii) annoyance
ix) YES actual issue
x) annoyance since MMS is not a feature that is supposed to be supplied

Special Issues
i) not sure why, I get calls just fine. Can you elaborate?
ii) goes under "stuff that may have happened to someone somewhere"

Feel free to do what you wish with the feedback, but do try and understand what I am saying.

I find you have a handful of actual issues, a lot of annoyances (things that don't work like you want, or features you wish were there that are not) a couple of OLD issues from release 1.0 firmware that are long gone, and a few very isolated issues a small number of people report.

Still, good effort.

Andre Klapper 2010-05-13 17:57

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Just some comments to a few points here, or linking to corresponding bug reports for the records and other interested folks...
In general: Thanks for the list. An interesting summary, and something worth to forward to some Nokia "deciders".

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(i) Some devices randomly restart.

http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6334 was fixed already in a public release, but there are still reasons left, e.g. see https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8787 .

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(vii) The screen does not refresh automatically for some reason. If the screen goes off (battery saver) when you wake it up it will show for a couple of seconds exactly what it was showing before it went to sleep. So if the time was 14.50 then and is now 16.30 it will initially show 14.50. Or if you are listening to music it will show the song details of the song that was playing before the screen went off.

For me it's never been a couple of seconds, but less than a second. Current behaviour is because of performance (not updating the screen when it is not shown anyway).

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(iii) Some album art do not show even though embedded.

If this refers to "officially supported" audio formats this sounds like a bug. Feel free to file a ticket in bugs.maemo.org and attach an example music file (or send it via email to me in case of copyright issues as bugs.maemo.org is totally public).

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(iv) Tracker which updates media file info is very often defective. You can add media files and they not show up in the media player for a week.

Again, sounds like a bug. If you see any pattern a ticket is welcome.

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(vii) Currently no equaliser though I don't see much point in an equaliser but just be aware there is none in the media player.

Planned for Harmattan it seems, plus 3rd party software is being worked on - see https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1890

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(viii) The play button on the media player widget does not work for some.

In most cases it seems to be related to other desktop widgets installed. See the status/progress in https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5894 and https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=9192 .

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(ix) No way to stretch to full screen in the default media player (though mplayer a third party app will do so).

I asked in https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=10065 to report it in maemo.org Brainstorm but cannot find the ticket.

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(i) There is no easy way to search your emails.

https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5502 .
Feel free to vote for it by clicking "Vote for this bug".

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(v) For some it randomly goes to speaker mode whilst you are on the phone.

Uh? Any quotes/URLs, or a bug number for this one?
I think I haven't heard of it before (or I cannot remember)...

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(i) If playing video I cannot receive calls.

If that's true it sounds like a huge problem to me. Haven't heard that before. Again, care to file a ticket in bugs.maemo.org?

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(ii) Sometimes the phone rings with a blank screen for a few seconds so no way to answer the phone. I know a few others have had this issue but not sure how wide spread it is.

See https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=7772 .
Patch is being tested internally...

Parody 2010-05-13 18:00

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 657067)
While I'm glad to see this sort of approach, parts of the starter post looks more like personal experience/opinion than an objective description. One example is the claim of screen scratching. I'm not debating this from a "never happened to me so can't happen" standpoint (that's a logical fallacy) but on the other hand it hasn't happened to me despite the fact that (and I admit this with some embarrassment) I have not taken proper care of my screen and yet still not a single scratch. In fact my device has been dropped to concrete a couple of times.

However, I did get some scratches on an N800 and here's what I discovered: dirt and dust can contain traces of extremely hard minerals, including diamond. One tiny speck getting stuck to a stylus point can do significant damage.

So I would certainly caution people as you have, and screen protectors can be a very good idea. Same for wiping the screen and stylus tip before using them. I just think including additional context in a complaint is helpful too. In this case, the issue is not one of hardware but contamination and poor handling. The N900 screen is actually very resilient.

That said, you're providing a great service here etuoyo, thanks.

The device screen has gotten scratched for me, in my work and normal clothes. I got a Nokia carrying pouch for it and I strongly recomend it to anyone who doesn't want a screen protector
http://i39.tinypic.com/15buhs.jpg

Texrat 2010-05-13 18:07

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Parody (Post 657199)
The device screen has gotten scratched for me, in my work and normal clothes. I got a Nokia carrying pouch for it and I strongly recomend it to anyone who doesn't want a screen protector

Good advice in general but be advised: IF static is the issue (and it's my first guess here based on experience), this solution could actually be part of the problem if no screen protector is used. If dust is on the screen or the inside pouch surface, inserting/removing the device can cause scratching.

geneven 2010-05-13 18:13

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
The consensus among early users of the N900 (before screen protection became nearly universal IMHO) was that the N900 screen was lots easier to scratch than the earlier tablets.

And an irrelevant aside. My N800 has scratches and my N810 doesn't. Neither had screen protectors. They both got the shoddy treatment I generally give my tablets.

Texrat 2010-05-13 18:16

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by geneven (Post 657222)
The consensus among early users of the N900 (before screen protection became nearly universal IMHO) was that the N900 screen was lots easier to scratch than the earlier tablets.

Interesting. I had not seen such a consensus. And I'm puzzled at how my experience has been exactly the opposite (unless, again, static is the culprit).

imperiallight 2010-05-13 18:18

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
Would be good if we could create ROMS with programs installed and aspects tweaked like in Windows Mobile.

Laughingstok 2010-05-13 18:20

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
I've beat the crap out of N900 before I finally got an Otterbox. It held up fairly well with only a couple little knicks on the right hand side of the screen and a couple of VERY light scratches in the middle area.

I've dropped it numerous times and even left it in my pocket for about 20 minutes playing some football in the park.. fell on it and remembered it. :D It took a pretty solid beating then too.

It's tough indirectly. But now with the Otterbox I think it's damn near indestructible.

ossipena 2010-05-13 18:24

Re: N900 Issues: For Potential Buyers
 
I wish these points could be edited to match reality:

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(i)The screen scratches more easily than capacitive screens. I have two very large scratches on my screen despite making sure I put absolutely nothing in the same pocket as the N900. Be sure you use a screen protector because no matter how careful you are the screen may get scratched.

There must be something to scratch the screen, right? yes the screen is scratch prone but the scratches doesn't appear nowhere like baby jesus was born...


Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(ii) There is a serious manufacturing defect with the micro-usb socket of many of the N900s.

many is the worst word one could possibly have put there...


Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(iii) Only three row keyboard layout so you need to use alternate for the numbers keys.

isn't this obivous if you have looked more than one picture from the device?

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
Battery

If you do not have IM accounts turned on then the battery should easily last you through the day. However, with some IM accounts (not sure which are the culprits but yahoo and msn seem to be amongst) you should generally expect around 6 hours use on average. Not really an issue specific to the N900 though - Engagdet's review of the HTC Desire says they had 6 hours with similar use.

I get 10+ hours with facebook + gtalk. so imo that should be mentioned: better protocol - double the battery duration


Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(i) Some devices randomly restart.

these are called defect units. these should be replaced asap. (you can get a brand new if you return the device within xx days at least in Finland)

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(ii) The transition between the four desktops is far from smooth.

depends fully what you are running and what not. and what do you concider smooth anyway?

Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(vi) No proper functioning software to sync with your PC the way itunes syncs perfectly with iphone. You can use drag and drop but that is only helpful for the first sync of all your music and when you add new songs to your PC and are sure exactly what the news songs are and can just drag and drop them. There is Ovi Music but it does not work with the N900. Third party PC software programmes can sync but many of them just sync to the main documents folder or the main music folder rather than in an organised manner (via artist, album artist, etc) and so create a huge mess and will kill your use of file manager. You may get something to work properly but will be quite an effort compared to using itunes and iphone.

then why in the heavens name you don't use iTunes?!?! it can be used with any device cabable mounting to your PC as an usb stick....
Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 657036)
(ix) Cannot dial numbers starting with * or # without the use of a third party widget so without the third party widget you are unable to top up your credit or check your balance in certain countries.

will be fixed when PR1.2 is released.


thank you!


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:41.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8