maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N900 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ??? (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=41841)

nedjinski 2010-01-22 17:02

N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
would you buy a new N900 now or wait for the Dell Mini 5 ?

DarkPand0r 2010-01-22 17:10

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
I trust Dell as much as I trust a £5 hooker not to give me an STD......
Thats +1 for N900 if you were wondering.

torpedo48 2010-01-22 17:16

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
I've already bought an N900. If the Dell Mini 5 had already been out I'd have bought the N900 anyway.
I don't think you are going to find a Dell Mini 5 fun here...

switchfiend 2010-01-22 17:21

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nedjinski (Post 489006)
would you buy a new N900 now or wait for the Dell Mini 5 ?

Honestly, while I've been impressed with Android's quick development (going from being pretty consumer unfriendly with 1.5, to being much much better with 2.1) I don't see the appeal in Android as a non-phone.

As a phone, I think a case can be made for a platform that is well integrated but limiting. I don't need my toaster to run Mutt, so I'm content with it not being open and extensible. But...

Once I get past the utility of a phone, any computing device other than that (like a tablet, or a netbook), I find Android to be much less compelling.

This forum is predominantly made up of people who enjoy tinkering, who want their device to do whatever it is they think it should be able to do (not what the manufacturer thinks it should do, or the carrier). That is a powerful paradigm.

nedjinski 2010-01-22 17:27

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
part of my dilemma is that I am looking for the device to be primarily an internet device which would mean browsing, skype, gps, etc and a cell phone a distant second - and I want to be able to have these things with a basic phone plan, not a data plan.

does the N900 fall into these possibilities?

Den in USA 2010-01-22 17:38

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nedjinski (Post 489040)
part of my dilemma is that I am looking for the device to be primarily an internet device which would mean browsing, skype, gps, etc and a cell phone a distant second - and I want to be able to have these things with a basic phone plan, not a data plan.

does the N900 fall into these possibilities?

I think a device that has Skype with video and can be used as a basic Verizon provider phone would get my immidiate attention.

j.s 2010-01-22 17:38

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nedjinski (Post 489040)
part of my dilemma is that I am looking for the device to be primarily an internet device which would mean browsing, skype, gps, etc and a cell phone a distant second - and I want to be able to have these things with a basic phone plan, not a data plan.

does the N900 fall into these possibilities?

It is possible. But for GPS, be prepared to start the GPS with a good view of the sky for 5 to 20 minutes before you need it. Best to turn it on with a good view of the sky before you leave the range of your wifi.

Many people find the built in GPS application not very useful. Good third party GPS (both paid and free) should eventually be available.

torpedo48 2010-01-22 17:39

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nedjinski (Post 489040)
part of my dilemma is that I am looking for the device to be primarily an internet device which would mean browsing, skype, gps, etc and a cell phone a distant second - and I want to be able to have these things with a basic phone plan, not a data plan.

does the N900 fall into these possibilities?

If you are looking for an Internet device the N900 is what you're looking for, but I can't understand what you mean with "with a basic phone plan"... You are going to spend tons of gold without a data plan (or wifi).

nedjinski 2010-01-22 17:44

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
sorry should have clarified that -

no on the data plan -

yes on the wi-fi - that would be the primary connection to the internet - browsing, skype, etc.

livefreeordie 2010-01-22 17:48

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nedjinski (Post 489040)
does the N900 fall into these possibilities?

Yes, but without a data plan, you're obviously going to have to use wifi.

Edit: damnit, should refresh tabs before replying.

torpedo48 2010-01-22 17:48

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nedjinski (Post 489067)
sorry should have clarified that -

no on the data plan -

yes on the wi-fi - that would be the primary connection to the internet - browsing, skype, etc.

Actually I have no data plan for my N900, I use it only with wifi.

I have a personal wireless network in my house and I also use my University free wifi when I'm there. Works for me!

thinh 2010-01-22 17:54

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
wow that dell seem pretty cool, but i'll probably still take the n900 if i had a chance.

I love nokia because they always try to give as much features and freedom possible in a device.

Jeffgrado 2010-01-29 14:22

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
http://www.engadget.com/2010/01/29/m...-parka-offers/

Look at this, a real Dell Mini 5. I think this is what many of us wanted a NIT to be. It's easy to see maemo on this form.

teh 2010-01-29 14:37

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
i would choose the n900 over all the current devices for looks and features. and thats what im typing on now. android sounded good when i heard about it, now im not so sure since using this!

DaveP1 2010-01-29 16:19

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
For primarily Wi-Fi browsing, I'd look into an N810 and a low end phone combination. Its bigger screen will make the end result better even if the slower processor makes it slower.

nosa101 2010-04-19 20:00

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
if the mini 5 is on tmobile, i'll definitely look into getting one

bxbomber 2010-04-19 20:05

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
http://www.engadget.com/2010/04/19/d...-t-mobile-fla/

with tmo 3g.
def interested in this. nokia needs to come out with something as nice with meego or my money will go to dell.

wmarone 2010-04-21 01:05

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Runs Android. I think I'll stick with a real Linux stack :)

bunanson 2010-04-21 01:10

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
[QUOTE=CyberCat;620271..I got the N900 a few weeks ago after owning the N810 for several years....[/QUOTE]

Welcome on board, CyberCat. I have the tmobile 1$ a day plan and it works, kind of slow, but it does work. Dont deal with any tmobile CSR, just go walmart or anywhere buy a tmobile prepay card, then go online, tmobile.com to activate the card and choose data plan. I turn it on when I am out of town and turn it off when I am back in town. I have wifi at my work place as well as at home.

Welcome again,

bun

superg05 2010-04-21 19:09

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wmarone (Post 620275)
Runs Android. I think I'll stick with a real Linux stack :)

linus said Linux is just the kernel everything else is user space
http://www.androidcentral.com/linux-...oves-nexus-one
http://gizmodo.com/5466072/linus-tor...gle-nexus-oner

http://torvalds-family.blogspot.com/...py-camper.html
read the comments he responded to on his blog

wmarone 2010-04-21 19:24

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by superg05 (Post 621419)
linus said Linux is just the kernel everything else is user space
http://www.androidcentral.com/linux-...oves-nexus-one
http://gizmodo.com/5466072/linus-tor...gle-nexus-oner

http://torvalds-family.blogspot.com/...py-camper.html
read the comments he responded to on his blog

Sure, but that doesn't make me want to use Android more. I'd rather not have to operate up in a pseudo-Java layer and deal with the complete lack of a package management system and no access to various tried and true (and untrue) libraries.

I suppose what I should have said is:

Quote:

I think I'll stick with a real *nix user space stack
which Android devices try very hard not to provide.

bunanson 2010-04-22 03:55

Re: N900 vs Dell Mini 5 ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCat (Post 620293)
Hi bunanson, thanks for the tip! Do you have a link for more info on those cards? What prices are they available in? Do you get like $1 = 1GB? Can you have a data and voice prepaid? Also do those expire?

This is the way I did it, and more info here.

Go tmobile.com, home page>plan>all plans>prepaid plan or here

I went to get a $20 phone came with a prepaid sim card or you can order just the prepaid sim card for $10 (the card itself is about $7). I got a very good Nokia old phone with BT support, talks to my N800, but I never make any real use of it yet. I went to the tmobile.com web site, activated my phone, chose plan pay as you go (talk minutes are more expensive than the other plan, but there is no per day charge, so one can sit on it till being use on talk plan), never talk to any CSR. Some people posted that talking to the CSR and activated a smart phone like N900 will cost more. I did it all online without having talking to anybody.

I sit on it for several weeks, till I need to go out of town, I then switched from talk plan to data plan 1$ a day, unlimited data, it counts by the hour, midnight to midnight, you allow to make one change a day, more than one change, it will cost 1$ per change. And when I am back in town, I switch back to talk plan to avoid the 1$ charge.

It is not fast enough to use it for skype, but otherwise, it does everything like a 56kb modem suppose to do, slow, but will get you online.

The tmobile page is SO CONFUSING, even the CSR would NOT understand what to do. I once called up to ask for help, the CSR insisted sidekick plan ONLY works on sidekick phone and NOTHING ELSE and please DO NOT WASTE his breadth to keep explain it! what a jerk!

anyhow, I am using it quite happy about it, not necessary the best way to get online, but its a way that fits my current budget.

I can not get what other people have been able to get online, maybe I dont understand or I have not tried hard enough, it works with some hiccup or you can have the real plan, I guess, something like 30$ a mo for the phone and $10 a month for the data plan.

In the above thread, if you know how to setup your own proxy, you can get 3G going, much faster than 2G. I am still learning how to get a home proxy works :(.....

Hope this helps,

bun


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:14.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8