maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Off Topic (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   A new user in the Linux ranks! (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=51998)

Siggen 2010-05-06 05:32

A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Today I am proud of my self. I converted a Windows user to Linux! If this is a wall of text for you, jump to the last two paragraphs. :) He is a self proclaimed computer newbie or computer illiterate and had a medium league dell laptop that took 12 minutes to boot Windows Vista.

I asked him if he had anything Important on his laptop, he said, not really maybe a few files. I asked him if he could back them up and he said "You mean copy them to my external drive?" I answered positively and he did.

Now I asked if I could remove Windows from his anyway OLD AND SLOW machine completely and install an alternative to Windows that was free, I said if he didn't like it Id download Vista again and use his Windows licens thats under his laptop anyway. And he said okay.

I took his machine home with me, installed Ubuntu 10.04 and it took every device driver his computer needed, wifi, media buttons, graphics and everything worked out of the box, I installed VLC, Wine, Flash, Java runtime, Chrome, and Spotify for him (also a bunch of games he will just play once, and a few he might play on the buss and so on). Then I took it back to him, showed him where to log in to MSN and other connectivity things, showed him how to install new programs, explained that windows programs might not work and his conclusions is as follows in the next paragraph;

He absolutely loved it, it ran in full graphic mode with wobbly windows, 100% smoothly compared to his problems browsing for files in windows. It started from cold boot in 35 seconds compared to between 5 and 12 minute boot time for windows. He got all his favorite programs running natively, wine or good alternatives. And he will find out that his iPod will work out of the box! (forgot to tell him)

Anyways I also explained that Linux IS NOT WINDOWS WITH A NEW SKIN, and things are different, but asked him to just think logically and click where he thinks, and he has my number anyway if something stucks him up in a corner :D I encourage you to share similar stories, so people here that does not user or know about Linux might get interested in the JUST WORKS and NO VIRUSES that Linux has!

ZogG 2010-05-06 05:54

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
on one hand linux population is great - as more companies pay attention and port/develop/support things under linux as well.
on other hand more linux popular - more dumbs using it. so for more "user friendly" interface developers trying to make less configuration systems. and than all the point of linux is lost. i think ubuntu is nice distro. but though i don't agree with it's politics. they decide instead of user a lot of things and you do can change things back, but it would be more comfortable to set the configuration from the begging. or for example as ubuntu decided to refuse HAL and it's not you the one to decide if you want to use it or not.
P.S. I'm gentoo user and just set ubuntu on my laptop(as i don't use it that much so i decided to experiment) and sometimes i find some configurations are much easier on gentoo. now looking forward to try arch on laptop. or even to go more experementing and try Haiku(http://www.haiku-os.org/) Plan9 (http://plan9.bell-labs.com/plan9/) and Opensolaris (http://hub.opensolaris.org/bin/view/Main/)

Siggen 2010-05-06 06:05

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
@ZorG its people like you that keep other distros alive. Installing HAL in ubuntu 10.04 would be a mess i guess, but most user settings are easily changable via the terminal for power users.

Me personally im on a Mac running Snow Leopard, my home server runs linux, and i try to stay away from Windows or Xbox.

But back to your point, Yes Ubuntu is a great OS for newbies and a lot of things are automatically set up during the install. I hope Ubuntu becomes faster, more feature rich, more sleek, and easier to use. For me personally, if Ubuntu did not do it for me, i would just go for linux from scratch.

devu 2010-05-06 06:10

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Hi.

You seems to me like a guy I am looking for :)
I'm Windows user stick to this platform because of tools I have to use.

Look at this subject and please would you like to convert me as well?
This is what I want today more than n900 2 months ago :)

Tuukka 2010-05-06 06:35

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
In addition to my gaming rig I have a crappy 2-3 years old laptop running vista. The laptop is slow, unstable and runs hot as hell. Would the change of OS remarkably speed things up and make the use more enjoyable?
Thanks! ~Tuukka

Siggen 2010-05-06 06:52

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by devu (Post 645813)
Hi.

You seems to me like a guy I am looking for :)
I'm Windows user stick to this platform because of tools I have to use.

Look at this subject and please would you like to convert me as well?
This is what I want today more than n900 2 months ago :)

Hey devu, as far as I can tell, you are just a Windows user that is curious about linux, half ways because you would like to develop for it. (TBH ive been awake for two days now, and I was getting ready to sleep 8 hours ago, but to much to do :P ) Also you need more general Linux knowledge.

A fine place to start for any Windows or Mac User is Ubuntu Linux! Okay you have some alternatives, but I suggest that you get a hold of Ubuntu and try it a while and not remove windows before you(if you ever) find that you dont need to use Windows at all.

These are the 3 ways of getting Ubuntu I am suggesting to you:

1. Easiest way is to use Wubi to install Ubuntu on a virtual filesystem on your windows disk and it configurs your boot manager to be able to select between ubuntu or windows when you start. Installing Ubuntu with Wubi is just as simple task as installing any program in windows.

2. Take an old laptop, not too old because you would like to run the newest ubuntu smoothly. This is of course just like a rule of thumb, but I think most about 3 to 4 year old laptops or newer should run ubuntu like a charm, and make it to a fully fledged ubuntu only machine. Ubuntu is great with laptops, and great with power management (almost as great as OS X, and much greater than Windows). You would need to burn an Ubuntu ISO file and boot in on your laptop to install it like this. (Its a very straight forward install) Or make a USB pen a bootable Ubuntu Installer!(program for windows) (also you need to download the ubuntu ISO file and select it in this tool)

3. Download the Ubuntu ISO file and brun it, partition and install ubuntu on its own partition. This would have practically the same result as solution one, but is a "cleaner" harder way to do it, but you get a bit more performance out of your ubuntu. This should be a piece of cake if your a power user! Just boot from ISO or USB and follow the intuitive installer, pay extra attention to the partitioning section :)

Siggen 2010-05-06 07:00

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuukka (Post 645838)
In addition to my gaming rig I have a crappy 2-3 years old laptop running vista. The laptop is slow, unstable and runs hot as hell. Would the change of OS remarkably speed things up and make the use more enjoyable?
Thanks! ~Tuukka

Yes, Change of OS would remarkably speed things up and make the use more enjoyable!

I suggest (since you have a gaming rig) just downloading ubuntu from ubuntu.com, boot from the burned disc (ask if you have problems with that) and install it on your vista laptop and completely uninstall Vista. When Ubuntu asks how you would like to partition your harddrive, select erase the entire drive and install ubuntu or something like that.

The negative thing is that you might not have your Vista DVD to go back if you choose to do so. But in my country it is legal to obtain the Vista install disc from pirate site sources and use your own payed for licens key (sticker under your laptop). Just choose to get the right language, and right processor version 64bit or 32bit, and right version (home premium or other) and you can use your own burned DVD.

In fact, when i worked at a PC repair shop, we were allowed to make appropriate burned windows disc's to OEM customers. (bought a computer with us and had no other way to recover, but they still had their license)

paulkoan 2010-05-06 07:13

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZogG (Post 645801)
on other hand more linux popular - more dumbs using it. so for more "user friendly" interface developers trying to make less configuration systems. and than all the point of linux is lost.

The "point" of linux is not to be complex and command line driven - it just happens to be. And this is as much a problem for take-up as it is a benefit for power users.

Learning how linux works should not be the primary reason for using it - the primary reason should be to escape the tyranny of Windows and closed-source and endless re-inventing the wheel.

If you learn about about how things work in the process - fine if that interests you. But for the vast majority of the population, a computer just needs to be a tool that makes life simpler, not for it to be a project in of itself.

That ubuntu and other distros are doing their level best to make linux usable for the non-technical has to be applauded and encouraged.

ZogG 2010-05-06 07:15

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Siggen (Post 645811)
@ZorG its people like you that keep other distros alive. Installing HAL in ubuntu 10.04 would be a mess i guess, but most user settings are easily changable via the terminal for power users.

Me personally im on a Mac running Snow Leopard, my home server runs linux, and i try to stay away from Windows or Xbox.

But back to your point, Yes Ubuntu is a great OS for newbies and a lot of things are automatically set up during the install. I hope Ubuntu becomes faster, more feature rich, more sleek, and easier to use. For me personally, if Ubuntu did not do it for me, i would just go for linux from scratch.

first of all it's ZogG, second of all. i liked hal very much (moving to udev, as i moved to new xorg). but the point is not about mess or not. the point is that distro giving you configuration he decides what is the best for you. and if you are noobie - you are getting used for it as it given and it becomes the standart (yes everything is the matter of what you are used too, as only moved too linux i tried to find programs that look like ones i used in windows(winamp, bsplayer), but now i think that xmms2/mpd, mplayer(without gui) are much easier to use. most of people that are searching for usefriednly OS like ubuntu would probably stick to default programs. even the firefox has it's default homepage with search. and so this politic are very simuliar with apple ( i don't like their politics too) . and yes sometimes it's messy to change for example from gnome to kde (as most of ubuntu software are gtk and some of them are deeply builtin OS) and yes you can say that there is kubuntu - but why would you use different os if only the difference is DE/WM. I'm just saying the point of the linux was not only opensource and free software but also modulation ( that things work together but not depend on each other and if something goes wrong it wouldn't stuck all the system) also the choice - you don't like something - change it to something else or even make your own way. you actually understand what's going on your computer and it works how you want it to. and if not - i don't see any difference with windows - except it's free and opensource.

Siggen 2010-05-06 07:30

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
@ZogG Get of your High horse and think about what your saying. I'm sorry for misspelling your name, but for nothing more. Most people CHOSE as you chose to use mplayer without gui, they CHOSE something they are able to use without reading 3 books on the subject. Ubuntu is made as a CHOICE like you are taking, and ubuntu is a choice to windows. You want even more choices, thats fine because ubuntu's philosophy and politics is not to MAKE YOU use Ubuntu, but to be a CHOICE to OS X and Windows, Canonical does not care if you use their Ubuntu or not, but their happy if they make the people happy, (they have a lot of money, and their not getting it from the end user and the users who sits and votes in the brainstorming section.

Ubuntu is for everyone, from the power user to the complete Newbie! but if its not for you, then we all hope you find a suitable alternative for your self, and that you stop being negative about ubuntu

ZogG 2010-05-06 07:58

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Siggen (Post 645934)
@ZogG Get of your High horse and think about what your saying. I'm sorry for misspelling your name, but for nothing more. Most people CHOSE as you chose to use mplayer without gui, they CHOSE something they are able to use without reading 3 books on the subject. Ubuntu is made as a CHOICE like you are taking, and ubuntu is a choice to windows. You want even more choices, thats fine because ubuntu's philosophy and politics is not to MAKE YOU use Ubuntu, but to be a CHOICE to OS X and Windows, Canonical does not care if you use their Ubuntu or not, but their happy if they make the people happy, (they have a lot of money, and their not getting it from the end user and the users who sits and votes in the brainstorming section.

Ubuntu is for everyone, from the power user to the complete Newbie! but if its not for you, then we all hope you find a suitable alternative for your self, and that you stop being negative about ubuntu

I didn't say it's bad. i'm advising ubuntu to all people who wants linux and don't want to configurate it and learn it in more deep way. i'm saying the population of linux users can influence in a bad way as well. when people come and expect everything to work and they ask questions instead of 1 minute google use. i'm just saying populating something is not always the best thing

xomm 2010-05-06 21:26

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Ubuntu 10.04's pretty nice with the social integration (Empathy, Evolution, Gwibber).

All your alter egos in a couple square inches (or a few square centimeters).

I just can't seem to convert any of my friends because they're all gaming addicts... (And most of their games don't work well in wine.)

I've been a part-Linux, part-Windows user for the past year or so, and the last nail in the coffin for Windows came when one of the essential .dlls got corrupted. Tried to re-install Windows and everything, but then the sound drivers wouldn't work.

Funny how I learned more about computers in a year than the library technicians (oh the irony...) at my school have all their career.

My friend (http://lincomlinux.org/homepage) and I were writing the .spec files for the base system one day, and one of the technicians accused us of hacking the school computers. (Even though there are quite advanced C++ and Java courses here, too.).

Basically, people need to know about Linux. Just knowledge of what Linux is (even if all they know is that it's an alternate OS to Windows and Mac) would brighten the technology world greatly, in my opinion.

Hope Chrome OS can facilitate this effect.

Siggen 2010-05-06 23:26

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
@xoom

I disagree with the Chrome OS, its the worse OS ive evere tried. I would rather have DOS on my computer than Chrome OS, its JUST a bootable internet browser, NOTHING more. It can be useful to have it installed for googling if your computer OS dies. Thats about it. Anyway, Lynx web browser can run in dos too :P

Well if some people think its cool and hip, then I wont refuse them running such an OS :P

xomm 2010-05-07 00:44

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Siggen (Post 647288)
@xoom

I disagree with the Chrome OS, its the worse OS ive evere tried. I would rather have DOS on my computer than Chrome OS, its JUST a bootable internet browser, NOTHING more. It can be useful to have it installed for googling if your computer OS dies. Thats about it. Anyway, Lynx web browser can run in dos too :P

Well if some people think its cool and hip, then I wont refuse them running such an OS :P

What I meant by "facilitate," is to spread the word about Linux (Google being one company that everyone knows of). Honestly, I don't think Chrome OS is revolutionary either. Just an idea that many have thought of, but never tried, because it's simply too vague.

geneven 2010-05-07 00:50

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
That user running Windows Vista with a slow old computer might also want to try Win7.

devu 2010-05-07 01:24

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Siggen (Post 645861)
Hey devu, as far as I can tell, you are just a Windows user that is curious about linux

Hi Siggen. Thanks for replay, but your assumption is wrong :)
I'm building my PC's always myself. I know how computers works from electric circuits point of view. All those 3 steps I know but good you put this here someone can might find it useful.

Also I know from theory and architecture what the Linux is and differences between Windows. I have knowledge about file systems and I always agree that Unix based Linux is the winner from programmer point of view.

However, because of tools I had to use from many years I hade to use Windows. I was giving chance my self many times to install some Linux distribution. Windows made me disabled no because lack of knowledge but because I get use to. Each time when I had Linux set up and running... ( I remember my first was RedHat with KDE i think). i was struggling and messing around with commands to install even simple things. It made mi impatient and finally I gave up. Even if something was working it was easy to stuck on very simple task like fix your missing driver or something.

Basically Linux for person like me with a bit more knowledge wasn't OS that could teach me. You had to know everything is needed to learn Linux.That's why Windows won.

Maemo Linux based - cool. Do I have to think here to do something? No!
It's very straight forward. Do I know how to use x Terminal? No! I don't now the commands and how it works under the hood.

Now I am playing with easy debian on N900. I love it. I can behave like normal user on it. But my enthusiasm ends when I need to dig deeper.

The bigger problem with linux is, has been developed by hi-end programmers for themselves. They made it beauty for guys with knowledge on their level. Completely useless for normal people. Things are getting better and better but very often different way as customers getting use to new versions of Windows and OSX. Sorry for this opinion I don't want hurt anybody and I have full respect to this guys. Especially when during my life I evolved from designer to developer.

But in your genius programming minds you miss human-interaction aspect and usability. Stuff usually looks ugly and not user friendly. Since doing system for yourself you can love it and die for it doesn't mean someone else can. Why there is so many different distributions of Linux?. Because you even can't agree between each other.
Don't be surprise that only you.

And I'm sorry to see that even here programmers are divided. Some do like Qt MeeGo some doesn't because it's against the beauty of clear programming. I am not taking side here still this is above my range.
But if you want to keep Maemo for yourself will die with you same way as you Killed Linux popularity some time ago when was big opportunity to compete with Windows on the market.

You have great opportunity to make Linux happen on the mobile computing now. This is new decade and new chance. I really love this OS mostly because is close to ideology I've being always big supporter, what Open Source suppose be. Don't f** it up. Learn from the past. Join your forces rather doing OS for yourself again.

At the moment from my short period of observation is not good. So much ego games taking place here. You want to prove one to each other who is better programmer and have more experience. If someone new will show up, first of all kill him by attacking his skills and destroy his respect. Is that how you programmers created Linux some time ago? Wow...

xomm 2010-05-07 01:45

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by devu (Post 647367)
The bigger problem with linux is. Has been developed by hi-end programmers for them self's. They made it beauty for guys with knowledge. Completely useless for normal people.

I'll keep that in mind. Will be co-developing a new distribution sometime next year alongside a fellow Linux enthusiast friend. (Right now it's very geeky: lincomlinux.org)

zaksloan 2010-05-07 01:57

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
I have been a Windows user since Windows 3.1.

I had previously dabbled with Ubuntu, but only using the live CD on my main PC and tested on spare PCs.

My main PC running Win 7 died recently, but was bought back to life with a new PSU. At the same time I found a P4 PC a neighbour had discarded and put a 1TB HD in with the intention of running it as my torrent box and media server, while using my Win 7 PC as my main rig.

I installed Ubuntu on the torrent box and since then have had no reason to start up the Windows machine.

Using the N900 was another incentive for me to start embracing Linux and I am happy I made the switch. There have been no tasks I have been unable to perform with Ubuntu and love the idea and concept of 'open source' operating systems (and software).

It does take a bit of learning a new way of doing things, but it's very satisfying to do.

Win 7 still runs on my laptop, and I still love the OS, but now I know I don't have to rely on it anymore.

roundyz 2010-05-07 08:35

Re: A new user in the Linux ranks!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Siggen (Post 647288)
@xoom

I disagree with the Chrome OS, its the worse OS ive evere tried. I would rather have DOS on my computer than Chrome OS, its JUST a bootable internet browser, NOTHING more. It can be useful to have it installed for googling if your computer OS dies. Thats about it. Anyway, Lynx web browser can run in dos too :P

Well if some people think its cool and hip, then I wont refuse them running such an OS :P

Chrome OS Is not good. I think that the worry of what data is going to Google (and what they are doing with it) scares me a bit. However (never used it), it would be a good idea to see just how well it operates (and what applications it facitiates) OFFLINE. Without data able to get through to Google.


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:49.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8