maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Competitors (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   What can I expect from a Motorola Droid? (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=56955)

mrojas 2010-06-23 18:39

What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
So, here in my job we are getting our enterprise phones renewed and our carrier have just refreshed its phone options, previously it was either Blackberries, the iPhone 3G or the Nokia E71. I had already bought the E71; so I went with a free dumbphone, but now the carrier is offering the Motorola Droid as well.

What can I expect from the Droid? Any feedback?

cfh11 2010-06-23 18:41

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
http://www.anandtech.com/show/3764/t...torola-droid/1

Here is a good comparison of the droid and n900 (spoiler alert: the n900 comes out on top!)

quipper8 2010-06-23 18:51

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
a few of my users have droids

what i have heard and seen:

very good hardware, metal and VERY slim for having a keyboard

battery life sucks

takes a third party filemanager app to do some of the stuff we want to do in house(the nokias make this so much easier

I had to add some stuff on mailserver because of this( http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=2630 )since we have some processes where users send data in via email which is processed by server side scripts, which kind of pissed me off

keyboard is pretty good, you can get used to it pretty quick. It doesn't suck.

default drooooiidd notification is as annoying as hell

app devel is fairly easy and sideloading helps tremendously for small shops like us

mrojas 2010-06-23 19:00

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
I don't think I should worry about the email integration, but I do worry about battery life. I am used to the 3-4 days of the E71, how come it the Droid battery sucks?

quipper8 2010-06-23 19:12

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrojas (Post 726711)
. I am used to the 3-4 days of the E71, how come it the Droid battery sucks?

oh man, if you are used to battery life on e71, you are in for a rude surprise :)

the droid has a WAY bigger screen and WAY more power hungry processor than an e71 AND droid has a SMALLER battery

not picking on the droid specifically, most of the fancy new bigscreen phones(3gs, n900, evo, etc etc) do not fare much better compared to the battery life of an e71 or e72

danramos 2010-06-23 19:27

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
I'm a little confused by some of the statements said in here.

First..which DROID are you talking about? The Motorola Droid? The HTC Droid Incredible? HTC Droid Eris? Motorola Droid 2? Motorola Droid X? The term "Droid" is a Verizon brand slapped onto certain models from, so far, HTC or Motorola.

I myself have a Motorola Droid and the keyboard is awful, despite the earlier person's comment. However, the battery life is VERY good for a smartphone--about 250 hours standby, 6 hours of continuous talktime. I get MUCH better in both respects because I use the built-in Power Widget in Android's Google experience desktop. The complaint about the "Drrrroid" notification sound is silly--it's a default alert tone--and no more annoying than a myriad of any default tones in any number of phones. Just select another--just like you select another ringtone.

What you'll get is, generally, a closed environment sitting on an open operating system (very hackable.. intentionally) but it'll be very smooth and comfortable. An EXCELLENT phone experience with lots of applications and usefulness as a tool. The N900 is a much better all-around computer but the Droids are all FAR better phones.

That's my impression so far, anyway.

mrojas 2010-06-23 19:38

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
I was refering to the original Motorola Droid, the Milestone, with the QWERTY keyboard.

Thanks for the input!

pantera1989 2010-06-23 19:40

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
Q: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
A: It's a DROID. When the machines rebel, the droid will kill you.

quipper8 2010-06-23 19:50

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
I doubt this thread is helping you much :)

danramos 2010-06-23 20:30

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by quipper8 (Post 726757)
I doubt this thread is helping you much :)

I doubt your reply is helping him much either.

mrojas 2010-06-23 21:17

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
Well, one of our account managers just got his Droid and I have trying it for 5 minutes or so.

It is bigger than I thought, the keyboard is weird but I think I can get used to it. Android is weird as well, but I see options and customizations everywhere, which I like.

It is not perfect, I think it is too thick, the D-Pad is meh, no frontal camera, etc. But I would get it cheap due to the carrier subsidizing my employer (I will only pay out of my pocket the initial $100, the monthly fee is absorbed by my company); and I get support as well, so I think I will hop onboard.

I guess Tomi Ahonen was right about devices being available through carriers influence decisions a lot. I was completely decided about waiting for year's end to see Nokia's offerings; then I would ask someone travelling abroad (or myself if I go to EU next year); and to absorb the cost of buying it unlocked.

But the Moto Droid is $100, it is modern enough and will get Froyo. :)

ivanzorkic 2010-06-24 16:01

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
Moto Droid has similar hardware to n900, camera is worse and has no storage. So, all in all, it comes down to android vs meego. Both have strong and weak points. But Droid for a 100e, it certainly is a no brainer. It's just too good to pass, so go for it. Otherwise I'd suggest to wait and see what the n9 will be like.

Sent from my HTC Desire using Tapatalk

daperl 2010-06-24 17:43

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
:(

I don't own a Droid, but the person I most frequently speak to on the phone does. We're both long time Verizon customers, we both don't have land-line phones, and we both have lived in our same locations for the last few years. I've been happily using a Motorola RAZR for the past 3+ years, and until he got his Droid a few months ago, my conversations with him have been as clear as you would expect from any phone.

I'm not sure what cheapo cell he was using before, but since he's been using the Droid, the quality of his audio on my end has been abysmal. I have to constantly ask him to repeat stuff, and I constantly mention to him that his audio sounds garbled. He laughs and makes some adjustment (I'm not sure what he does; I'll ask him when he gets back from vacation). Things sound just okay after that, but slowly it reverts back to poor. I've been in his presence when he's talking on this phone, and I've witnessed nothing unusual about his usage. Maybe it's the mic location? Who knows, but it's very uncool.

Anyway, he likes the device (so do I), but he continually says it's not a good phone. I believe him.

I too am looking at Verizon's next Droid offerings, but I'm not sure my RAZR can be replaced if this poor sound quality persists.

Taigatrommel 2010-06-24 18:06

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
From what I can tell, the hardware keyboard of the Milestone sucks, though it looks pretty nice on the first look: four rows and rather large keys. Yet typing of it felt kind of awkward everytime I tried this device out. Maybe it gets better once you are using it on a daily basis.

On another note: I don't know if I misread or not, but the Milestone 2 should be out in a couple of weeks. At least from the photos I've seen yet, the keyboard got a better shape and appears to be more user friendly.

nosa101 2010-06-24 18:59

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
actually preferred the Droid keyboard

nilchak 2010-06-24 19:11

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
Talking about the Droid - it is worth jumping for the new Droid X even though its got no keyboard - but the screen is great and nice and big (like the EVO) ?

gsever 2010-06-24 19:26

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
Why get a Motorola Droid, while you can dual boot N900 with Maemo 5 and Android together ? :D

http://www.nitdroid.com/index.php?title=N900

danramos 2010-06-24 21:55

Re: What can I expect from a Motorola Droid?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by daperl (Post 727870)
:(

I don't own a Droid, but the person I most frequently speak to on the phone does. We're both long time Verizon customers, we both don't have land-line phones, and we both have lived in our same locations for the last few years. I've been happily using a Motorola RAZR for the past 3+ years, and until he got his Droid a few months ago, my conversations with him have been as clear as you would expect from any phone.

I'm not sure what cheapo cell he was using before, but since he's been using the Droid, the quality of his audio on my end has been abysmal. I have to constantly ask him to repeat stuff, and I constantly mention to him that his audio sounds garbled. He laughs and makes some adjustment (I'm not sure what he does; I'll ask him when he gets back from vacation). Things sound just okay after that, but slowly it reverts back to poor. I've been in his presence when he's talking on this phone, and I've witnessed nothing unusual about his usage. Maybe it's the mic location? Who knows, but it's very uncool.

Anyway, he likes the device (so do I), but he continually says it's not a good phone. I believe him.

I too am looking at Verizon's next Droid offerings, but I'm not sure my RAZR can be replaced if this poor sound quality persists.

Ah yes! I forgot about that--the Motorola Droid ships with a crappy vocode (vocal codec). I HATED the call quality when I first got it.. but there's a quick and easy fix for that. They ship it with a mediocre quality protocol to give the device a longer battery life during calls.. but I don't stay on the phone for hours, so it's kinda dumb for me.

Let him know he can fix it by doing this (also works on other phones I tried this on, too--although the resulting menu options are different):

Go to the phone dialer, enter ##PROGRAM (##7764726), hit DIAL and it'll ask you to "Enter SPC password". Just enter six zeros (000000) and tap "Verify". VOILA! The cellular radio's set-up menu! This menu is where things might differ on different Android phones. Anyway, on the Motorola Droid, choose menu option "04 Vocode". You have the option of 13K, EVRC and EVRC-B. It'll default to EVRC (medium battery life, medium-quality). Just change it to EVRC-B (lower battery life, highest quality). Hit Apply and hit the arrow BACK key to close it out. Done! From then on out, the calls should sound far better. I don't think you need to reboot the phone.

To summarize:
##PROGRAM
000000
04 Vocode
EVRC-B

There's a lot of other options in the cellular menu--I highly recommend they're not touched, just in case, but the whole cellular phone portion of the device is laid bare for you there. :)

I hope that comes in handy for that person you talk to.. and for mrojas and his boss.


Quote:

Originally Posted by gsever (Post 727998)
Why get a Motorola Droid, while you can dual boot N900 with Maemo 5 and Android together ? :D

http://www.nitdroid.com/index.php?title=N900

Because Android isn't really supported on it? No Android Market,no Google apps, etc. (Good luck with getting Froyo or getting support for most apps to look/work right.) Last I checked, hardware wasn't all supported either.


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:06.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8