maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Competitors (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4 (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=63004)

etuoyo 2010-09-27 16:37

5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
http://mynokiablog.com/2010/09/26/ra...-the-iphone-4/

The link is actually Nokia Blog's response to an article listing 5 (rather daft reasons) the N8 will not beat the iphone 4 but the 5 reasons are quoted in Nokia Blog's response.

I am not a computer techie so do not know much about these benchmark testings but the N8 numbers seem rather high compared to the ipad. Does that mean the N8's CPU performance is much higher than those of the ipad?

Parody 2010-09-27 16:45

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
Wait I thought the N8 wasn't even in the same price range?

Edit: Okay it mentions that the iPhone 4 is circa 200 subsidized while the N8 is 549 unsubsidized. I don't get how that is a valid point.

Deaconclgi 2010-09-27 17:03

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etuoyo (Post 827566)
http://mynokiablog.com/2010/09/26/ra...-the-iphone-4/

The link is actually Nokia Blog's response to an article listing 5 (rather daft reasons) the N8 will not beat the iphone 4 but the 5 reasons are quoted in Nokia Blog's response.

I am not a computer techie so do not know much about these benchmark testings but the N8 numbers seem rather high compared to the ipad. Does that mean the N8's CPU performance is much higher than those of the ipad?

The benchmarks represent the GPU, which the original MSNBC article fails to mention. The N8's GPU is very powerful and Symbian^3 is GPU accelerated so the load is on the GPU. Also, the Symbian OS is a lightweight (code base optimized over many years) OS that does not require a high freqency CPU in the firstplace.

In short, the MSNBC writer does NOT know much about anything and this is just another stupid article that causes similarly misinformed consumers to continue to pass negative and totally false judgment on Nokia and their products. It is almost as if there is a conspiracy in the US and someone has put a "hit" out on Nokia. If I was MSNBC, I would never allow that author to post on my site again. The sad part is that most American consumers will take this article and others like it for truth and will not even consider the N8 or Nokia products.

I am amazed at how many americans (I am american) tell me that the Iphone (any Iphone, not just v4) is better than everything, even the N900. There is a fine line between great Marketing, brainwashing and lying.....

People need to realize that internet journalism is NOT held to the same standard that printed journalism used to be held to. Anyone with a way to enter text and permission to post can spew whatever comes to mind....

mr_xzibit 2010-09-27 17:06

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
a fixed battery huh???

wonder why thy have done that? any advantages?
if my n900 had a fixed battery id be fooked!

as for it being an iphone killer?
nothing will be.
well the iphone5 maybe?
nokia make phones.
apple have a phone. so the support for that phone will be endless
wheres nokia phones last as long untill the next one comes out.

Berserk 2010-09-27 17:07

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
For some people, a simple call-only phone beats any smartphone on the planet :D

mr_xzibit 2010-09-27 17:13

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
lol wheres the n900 is a "call-maybe" recieve call-unlikely" kind of smartphone.

gerbick 2010-09-27 17:17

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
I don't get why they compared the iPhone 3GS when the title stated iPhone 4 in their benchmarks/screenshot at the top of the screen.

Capt'n Corrupt 2010-09-27 17:19

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
What I don't get is why people insist on believing that specs are directly proportional to a device's success.

mmurfin87 2010-09-27 17:19

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
I'll give you one reason: Symbian.

Berserk 2010-09-27 17:31

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Capt'n Corrupt (Post 827621)
What I don't get is why people insist on believing that specs are directly proportional to a device's success.

You're right.
If you say that a certain videocard has a 2 GB memory and a lot of Mhz/Ghz, then that's a great fact.
If you say it runs the newest games with all video settings at maximum, without any problems, you sell a lot more :D

kureyon 2010-09-27 17:56

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mr_xzibit (Post 827605)
a fixed battery huh???

Well it's not fixed fixed, apparently. When it dies you can open the case and replace it yourself - unlike on the iphone where you have to return to apple.

pycage 2010-09-27 18:10

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
The main reason why the N8 won't beat the iPhone is because it's no iPhone (TM).
This reason makes it very hard for any phone to beat the iPhone.
iPhone people expect the same user interface and exactly the same apps and syncing with iTunes.

patlak 2010-09-27 19:24

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Deaconclgi (Post 827601)
The benchmarks represent the GPU, which the original MSNBC article fails to mention. The N8's GPU is very powerful and Symbian^3 is GPU accelerated so the load is on the GPU. Also, the Symbian OS is a lightweight (code base optimized over many years) OS that does not require a high freqency CPU in the firstplace.

In short, the MSNBC writer does NOT know much about anything and this is just another stupid article that causes similarly misinformed consumers to continue to pass negative and totally false judgment on Nokia and their products. It is almost as if there is a conspiracy in the US and someone has put a "hit" out on Nokia. If I was MSNBC, I would never allow that author to post on my site again. The sad part is that most American consumers will take this article and others like it for truth and will not even consider the N8 or Nokia products.

I am amazed at how many americans (I am american) tell me that the Iphone (any Iphone, not just v4) is better than everything, even the N900. There is a fine line between great Marketing, brainwashing and lying.....

People need to realize that internet journalism is NOT held to the same standard that printed journalism used to be held to. Anyone with a way to enter text and permission to post can spew whatever comes to mind....

The reason for this article mostly is to promote and popularize their own domestic products. Getting average Joe to believe that Nokia N8 is worse due to the lower clock speed is positive for them, but in reality bull****. Everybody is about 1GHz CPU, just so that they can say they have such a phone even though they have no idea what the use is. I can't believe that in this age one would buy a 1GHz phone with no features rather than a fully featured Nokia N82.

patlak 2010-09-27 19:27

Re: 5 Reasons N8 Won't Beat Iphone 4
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mmurfin87 (Post 827624)
I'll give you one reason: Symbian.

Coming from an American....I bet you loved the article.


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:08.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8