maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Competitors (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   HTC Desire HD (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=64608)

shaf 2010-10-28 22:00

HTC Desire HD
 
Hi guys I was just wanting your opinions on the HTC Desire HD, after having my n900 since Janaury I feel it's time for something abit faster and newer.

So whats your thoughts on the phone itself, and how its compares to the n900? Thanks

maxximuscool 2010-10-28 22:52

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
I'd wait for N9 to show up its spec and support first. I'm not keen to go Android yet. Though there are heaps of games and stuff but Android doesn't have internatinalised language support like Maemo and MeeGO.

Something you can't get it to work because of the limitation of Android, oh the task switch of Android is a joke :(

bobaseth 2010-10-28 23:02

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
I would have it in my hands now but no 3g in the USA! No 3G no buy...,period! So I'll wait on this one until a equivalent or better comes out with 3g/4g.Also..., that phone has small battery and is a power hungry beast! It's battery is smaller than the is father the "Nexus!" The battery life on my next phone cannot be the same or worse then the N900 because I plan to use my next phone....,well as a phone and the N900 as a backup. You know because the N900 is kinda a Hybrid Mobile Computer/Phone. As for the Android OS..., It "Honors" the word or term "Smart Phone" in my personal experience with it.

leetut 2010-10-28 23:49

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
i really like the look of it but theres no keyboard, the desire z has one but its got less processing power 850mhz compared to 1ghz on the HD, and the internal memory is not up to scratch on either, was waiting for the n9 doubt we will see that for a long time yet, apparently nokia are making sure it not half baked like the n97 and n900 were when released, and iphone4 white is probs just around the corner if anyone fancies a girly phone

RAZOR 2010-10-29 00:11

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by leetut (Post 855994)
iphone4 white is probs just around the corner if anyone fancies a girly phone

White iPhone 4 has been delayed till spring 2011.

superhero 2010-10-29 00:23

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
LOL.. i have to say that android is kinda in a battle with meego for me, i mean, meego is not perfect but if they do what they say, combined with the N9 specs (imaginary) then Motorola has a hard time coming back, im sorry but Ive had the iPhone 4 for a week and i got bored (thats just me)

HellFlyer 2010-10-29 00:29

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
does it matter? its nothing new compared to other Android devices, same OS different device, only thing that i like is the screen size

superhero 2010-10-29 01:19

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
I was so bored so I made a quick preview on Photoshop of how i would like the Nokia N9 should look like...

http://s1208.photobucket.com/albums/...cell%20phones/

Kangal 2010-10-29 08:50

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by maxximuscool (Post 856021)
oh the task switch of Android is a joke

Agreed with that. It pretty awful, but at least its somewhat useful. I think Maemo has real multitasking and iOS has a "joke" multitasking. Android's is bang-smack in the middle of those two.

Quote:

Originally Posted by HellFlyer (Post 856021)
does it matter? its nothing new compared to other Android devices, same OS different device, only thing that i like is the screen size

That's sort of true. There's many varieties of handsets available with Android but these are easily differentiated via 2 questions (killer or standard hardware? and physical keyboard?). It's not as diverse as the Symbian platform.

Quote:

Originally Posted by leetut (Post 855994)
i really like the look of it but theres no keyboard, the desire z has one but its got less processing power 850mhz compared to 1ghz on the HD, and the internal memory is not up to scratch on either, was waiting for the n9 doubt we will see that for a long time yet, apparently nokia are making sure it not half baked like the n97 and n900 were when released, and iphone4 white is probs just around the corner if anyone fancies a girly phone

Desire Z has less RAM and less clockspeed on the same SoC core. But I think it is equally fast (improved Snapdragon with Adreno205) due to new software optimizations. Plus desireZ drains the battery much less than the Desire HD. Desire Z is definently the better phone except for the hinge that doesn't lock = annoying.

I wouldn't advise people to wait for the N9 as the N900 successor. Its not going to be groundbreaking, but rather to help Nokia try to catch up. If you have N900 and are happy with it, stick with it. If you're not and you want to "upgrade", do it when you want to because if you hold your breath [for the n9] you will turn purple and die ... i meant you will be very disappointed.

!!Nokia N900!! 2010-10-29 09:06

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
I was planning to get 1, but after reviewing the Very terrible speaker it has, i changed my mind.

etuoyo 2010-10-29 09:16

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by superhero (Post 856052)
I was so bored so I made a quick preview on Photoshop of how i would like the Nokia N9 should look like...

http://s1208.photobucket.com/albums/...cell%20phones/

Very nice. Send it to Nokia :o . I suspect the N9 will be quite ugly. Nokia is not really known for pretty looking phones. More for functional, manly, bulky devices. Even N8 which they put a lot into the design is one of the ugliest smart phones I have ever seen. Not sure if what you designed is possible though, It doesn't have those black borders around the screen which all touch screens seem to have. Not sure why it is needed but they all seem to have it and cause wasted screen space.

Also your design lacks a hardware keyboard. The main stream prefers this as it makes devices thinner and more sexy looking. However, there are some (like me) who cannot do without a keyboard. Shouldn't Nokia be releasing two versions of the N9 to attract all potential customers. If it has a keyboard those who want the thinnest possible design will be uninterested. If it lacks a keyboard people like me would be uninterested. That should be the case but I doubt that is what Nokia is aiming for.

If Meego is going to be a success I think there need to be as many options available as possible. Manufacturers are not jumping aboard meego like they have with windows 7 so it should be up to Nokia to design as many different types of meego devices as possible and have them all ready at launch. After HTC managed to have four different windows 7 phones all with very different designs and an option for everyone.

ericsson 2010-10-29 09:17

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shaf (Post 855953)
Hi guys I was just wanting your opinions on the HTC Desire HD, after having my n900 since Janaury I feel it's time for something abit faster and newer.

So whats your thoughts on the phone itself, and how its compares to the n900? Thanks

It's dead boring like most Android phones. And if you are bored by the N900, then after two weeks of Desire HD and you will be bored to death. The Desire Z can at least be used, and is overall a better phone than the HD.

Kangal 2010-10-29 09:21

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by superhero (Post 856052)
I was so bored so I made a quick preview on Photoshop of how i would like the Nokia N9 should look like...

http://s1208.photobucket.com/albums/...cell%20phones/

That actually looks sweet for a render. Say, do you think you might be able to do one for my concept I posted here a while ago? Here's the link if you're interested:
http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php...585#post754585

shaf 2010-10-31 18:47

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ericsson (Post 856304)
It's dead boring like most Android phones. And if you are bored by the N900, then after two weeks of Desire HD and you will be bored to death. The Desire Z can at least be used, and is overall a better phone than the HD.

Any reasons for Android being boring? I've seen the videos, read the reviews, been told it will be getting the next update and have decided to buy it sim free. Will probably update to another phone again in 6-7 months by that time hopefully Meego will be out and doing well.

ericsson 2010-10-31 19:46

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shaf (Post 858766)
Any reasons for Android being boring?

Because it is made by Google perhaps? Let's face the fact: Any other phone will be a step down in the 'tech-department' compared with the N900, hence boring :) All you can do with them is to change homescreen and install apps, How cool is that? not very. You can't even take decent pictures with them.

Android was interesting a couple of years ago, but today any Android phone is simply yet another Android phone. The only interesting parts of Android today are Sony Ericsson and Huawei.

My list of interesting phones looks something like this, in no particular order:
Nokia N8
Nokia E7
Nokia C7
Nokia C6-01
Nokia N900
Nokia N9 (still too much vapor but supposed to be cool)

LOL

Actually I am starting to feel a stronger and stronger urge for a real phone, like the old N95 8GB or smaller. A phone that does everything and works good as a phone with real keypad and T9. These 4 inc-ish touch screen devices doesn't 'satisfy' in the long run. Too small to watch the web, and clumsy as a phone - all of them (the N900 included). A nice, small, but advanced phone and a 6-7 inch tablet, thin and with keyboard in perfect harmony over Bt would be my dream. Maybe someday a 6-7 inch MeeGo pad and a svelte non-touch Symbian smartphone could do the trick, but until that day the N9 may be a compromise I could live with. Android - not so much.

shaf 2010-10-31 20:40

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Hmm surely anything the N900/Maemo can do the Desire HD/Android can do better or faster. Which to be honest i'm sure is what most people are after hence the talk of people waiting for the N9.

Sounds like your abit backwards in wanting an old school phone but fair do's thats your dream :P

S0urcerr0r 2010-10-31 21:14

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Topic starter:

Desire HD sounds sweet - but make sure that u're ready to start using android...

Some things that u may take for granted with Maemo, may be features that u will need to "root" (jailbreak) your android, and void your warranty.

Go to your local store and try a Android phone. Test it to see if u like the interface, power features and such...

I've tried a couple of android phones the last years, and find them very confusing and less intuitive compared to N900 Maemo - so i think u should really try it before u make a decision.

Also be prepared to install apps, or doing heavy modding / customisation to get many of the "simple" features u take for granted on the N900.

First u may try NitDroid on your N900 and make sure that u will be satisfied with a Android-only phone.

Like i said before - try before u buy :)


Superhero:

Nice Design! :)
i would customize the design a bit though, as i want a battery stretching from "side to side" (...and your "sides" may be a bit too narrow for that).

also it would be nice with additional keyb buttons - since i think the N9 will have a 4 inch screen which should supply plenty of extra space :)

ericsson 2010-10-31 21:34

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shaf (Post 858899)
Hmm surely anything the N900/Maemo can do the Desire HD/Android can do better or faster.

Like what? multitasking ? :D Androids are more phones than the N900, but for anything else the N900 is equal or better. Still, they are lousy phones compared with 'old fashioned' keypad phones, and lousy tablets compared with real tablets, and extremely lousy mobile computers compared with the N900. The N9 will also be a mobile computer, and that is what we are waiting for (at least I am :) )

But, the more I think about it, the more I am certain that I would rather have the N9 a bit larger, and no phone, and instead had a 'old fashioned' Symbian smartphone in addition to the N9. Still, maybe the N9 will be the perfect compromise, so I'l wait and see.

Kangal 2010-11-01 04:17

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ericsson (Post 858965)
Like what? multitasking ? :D Androids are more phones than the N900, but for anything else the N900 is equal or better. Still, they are lousy phones compared with 'old fashioned' keypad phones, and lousy tablets compared with real tablets, and extremely lousy mobile computers compared with the N900. The N9 will also be a mobile computer, and that is what we are waiting for (at least I am :) )

But, the more I think about it, the more I am certain that I would rather have the N9 a bit larger, and no phone, and instead had a 'old fashioned' Symbian smartphone in addition to the N9. Still, maybe the N9 will be the perfect compromise, so I'l wait and see.

Hmmm, easy fix! Hey ericsson, I'll give you my address and you give me yours. I will post you a Nokia N95 in exchange for your N900. Deal?

jukzh 2010-11-01 05:31

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shaf (Post 858899)
Hmm surely anything the N900/Maemo can do the Desire HD/Android can do better or faster. Which to be honest i'm sure is what most people are after hence the talk of people waiting for the N9.

Sounds like your abit backwards in wanting an old school phone but fair do's thats your dream :P

That's it? You not gonna write about it on your blogger, take yet another stupid poll on it like here

!!Nokia N900!! 2010-11-01 05:39

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
E7 is better

ericsson 2010-11-02 00:13

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kangal (Post 859223)
Hmmm, easy fix! Hey ericsson, I'll give you my address and you give me yours. I will post you a Nokia N95 in exchange for your N900. Deal?

Sure, will do :D No, I'm gonna keep my N900 until it falls apart (meaning until the USB port falls off :) )

Daywalker 2010-11-10 14:55

Re: HTC Desire HD
 
I have recently got one of these on an upgrade and like it alot, I realise that it isn't as open source as my N900, but apart from this site didn't forsee how little support it would receive, if I hadn't come across this site soon after I had my N900, it would have gone long ago.

I wanted a handset which was primarily a phone not a mobile computer.

I tried out the Nokia N8, but that was a bigger backward step then I envisaged.....

The Desire is fast, smooth and is quite easy to use, plus Rovio have updated Angry Birds!! I now have 45 new levels to have a go at later after work


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:21.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8