maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   General (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   N900 still epic (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=65885)

Laughingstok 2010-11-19 15:19

N900 still epic
 
So after owning the N900 since launch day, I must say it is still epic. My co-workers both have Android OS phones like the HTC Evo and Samsung Captivate and they still envy many of the things the N900 does.

Of course we're all IT professionals so they "get it."

I must say the overclocked kernel + Swappolube makes the N900 fly.

I know most don't give a crap about this, but I was playing with the N900 last night and it suddenly hit me just how fast and responsive the N900 is after watching a coworker browse around on his brand new Captivate.

I

ossipena 2010-11-19 15:28

Re: N900 still epic
 
exactly. and it is really shame. is the speed of epic device evolution frozen?

and n900 is unfortunately last of its kind. hopefully meego will have enough headroom for modding the system but it probably is at least harder...

gerdich 2010-11-19 15:41

Re: N900 still epic
 
I'm loving my n900!

I work with it day and night!

Meego-Devices will not be the same.
They're not debian based.
It will be much more difficult to adapt them.
There will be an atempt to impose commercial software on the open meege system.

volt 2010-11-19 15:50

Re: N900 still epic
 
I have this worry too, but I don't think it'll be as locked down as it could have been. Android has an clear advantage in the market (perception) and MeeGo has to bring something that can compete with that. Qt is just a platform, not a reason to buy it. So, I think they will have to keep it highly modable. After all, if they don't, what would then be the difference between MeeGo and Symbian^3? Different GUI colours? MeeGo is supposed to be the top end alternative, over Symbian^3.

johnel 2010-11-19 15:54

Re: N900 still epic
 
One of my concerns about Meego is the DRM "security" layer built into the platform.

It really depends how far they are willing to lock-down the handset (at the request of mobile operators).

gabby131 2010-11-19 16:13

Re: N900 still epic
 
when i use qtirreco (not sure what app that uses n900 as remote for tv's) to kinda scare my co-workers at lunch time (you know, tuning channels without the tv's remote). what they said is "man! you are a very dangerous person holding a wicked device!"

i even showed them the VNC thing......trying to make a printer work on a laptop. (the only problem was the electric connections though) and yeah......lots of awesomeness!!!!

Viny 2010-11-19 16:28

Re: N900 still epic
 
yeh its pretty much been an year, i think i got mine on the 25th?(not too sure about the date) here in new york nokia store. on the second day of launch. wow its almost been an year and its been with me for 5 different countries, hours of net, hours of calling, countless photos and videos and lot of exciting things and fun things.. all for 620 bucks lol.

gabby131 2010-11-19 16:31

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Viny (Post 878051)
yeh its pretty much been an year, i think i got mine on the 25th?(not too sure about the date) here in new york nokia store. on the second day of launch. wow its almost been an year and its been with me for 5 different countries, hours of net, hours of calling, countless photos and videos and lot of exciting things and fun things.. all for 620 bucks lol.

i'd say its a big bang for a buck

etuoyo 2010-11-19 16:39

Re: N900 still epic
 
Got mine day after black Friday so been almost a year. Unfortunately we have been apart the last three months due to faulty usb port issue but looks like I may finally get an N900 back in my hands next week.

Is there a real benefit in overclocking and swappolube on PR 1.3? Many people say 1.3 has made the device very snappy without any mods. And is 1.3 stable enough (saw a lot of bugs being reported) or should I just stick to 1.2 and overclock plus swappolube. I don't think 1.3 introduced any new features and so if all it achieves (increased responsiveness) is surpassed in 1.2 with overclocking and swappolube then I think I would rather just stick to that. Unless it is even more responsive on 1.3 when you add those.

Dave999 2010-11-19 16:43

Re: N900 still epic
 
epic device, epic threads. Cant wait for the n9 pre-order thread. Just love long and useless threads as well as great phones. Pre-order n9 thread is a 2011 event according to Elop. Cant wait...hope the thread is as "open" as before :)

ch88xy 2010-11-19 17:08

Re: N900 still epic
 
No doubt N900 is a super capable computer, but it's mostly for geeks. I am pretty sure you wouldn't call it user-friendly, would you? That's why it was not a big success among ordinary consumers. Today I use N900 mainly for TV streaming, thanks to its faster CPU. For other programs such as RSS, FBReader, Web browsing, music streaming, etc. I prefer to use my N810. It's a major disappointment to not be able to do a straightforward copy-paste in N900 (easily done in N810). How is this a pleasant experience? And why does a Web page have to jerk around when you touch it?

famdango 2010-11-19 17:15

Re: N900 still epic
 
I love my N900, i sometimes realise ive just been like staring at it, thinking wow this really is amazing... much like i did when i got my 3650......"woa its got a camera, u can downloads apps and its got a round keypad! OMG etc"

pantera1989 2010-11-19 17:18

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ch88xy (Post 878110)
It's a major disappointment to not be able to do a straightforward copy-paste in N900 (easily done in N810). How is this a pleasant experience?

How are Ctrl + C and Ctrl + V complicated???

Radicalz38 2010-11-19 17:22

Re: N900 still epic
 
I'm seeing the future of meego as this...
Android = java wrapping linux
Meego = QT wrapping linux

Yeah competition... Knowing nokia? I won't be shocked if we see a super stripped down linux on meego just like the droid.
Why? To avoid these "Oh no!! I deleted my /var/ folder got to go to nokia center" from common end-users

wmarone 2010-11-19 17:26

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Radicalz38 (Post 878124)
Knowing nokia? I won't be shocked if we see a super stripped down linux on meego just like the droid.

And Nokia could no longer claim compatibility with MeeGo. MeeGo is defined as a standard Linux distribution based off the LSB, so all the stuff we expect to get in a Linux distro are required to be there.

Quote:

Why? To avoid these "Oh no!! I deleted my /var/ folder got to go to nokia center" from common end-users
Anyone messing around at that level will not receive support.

tzsm98 2010-11-19 17:34

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Radicalz38 (Post 878124)
I'm seeing the future of meego as this...
Android = java wrapping linux
Meego = QT wrapping linux

Yeah competition... Knowing nokia? I won't be shocked if we see a super stripped down linux on meego just like the droid.

I'd be shocked if T-Mobile offered a MeeGo device that wasn't well locked down. I'd be shocked if Nokia locks down MeeGo on its own. The openess of the Maemo5 device shows Nokia gets it to some extent.

Thinking that MeeGo will end up in a situation analogous to Android negates the presence of a full Linux core in MeeGo. It also quietly avoids the issue of Google being the sole and secret tinkerer with the core of Android. MeeGo has several fathers and an open environment. Nokia can see the problems being closed and single point controlled carrys for Android. I can not imagine Nokia wanting to replicate those issues.

If the first MeeGo handset is not at least as open and modifiable as the N900 then Nokia will have not learned the lessons to be learned in step 4 of 5.

ossipena 2010-11-19 17:35

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ch88xy (Post 878110)
I am pretty sure you wouldn't call it user-friendly, would you?

outside telephone functions : absolutely yes! About 3 trillion years advance from os2008
e:good example:
take a picture, tag and share it to flickr. How could it be any easier?

Radicalz38 2010-11-19 17:39

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wmarone (Post 878128)
And Nokia could no longer claim compatibility with MeeGo. MeeGo is defined as a standard Linux distribution based off the LSB, so all the stuff we expect to get in a Linux distro are required to be there.


Anyone messing around at that level will not receive support.

Well meego is meego... It's a QT based platform for mobile. No GTK, hildon etc.
You can't install debian/redhat arm softwares from their respective repos.

ossipena 2010-11-19 17:41

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Radicalz38 (Post 878144)
Well meego is meego... It's a QT based platform for mobile. No GTK, hildon etc.
You can't install debian/redhat arm softwares from their respective repos.

but it offers great compatibility with any meego device.

wmarone 2010-11-19 17:41

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Radicalz38 (Post 878144)
Well meego is meego... It's a QT based platform for mobile. No GTK, hildon etc.

Yes, point being? MeeGo will have community repos much like Maemo does, however. You'll probably need to hack or buy an unlocked unit to use them however.

Quote:

You can't install debian/redhat arm softwares from their respective repos.
No, you can't. Even if you could, you'd be on your own as there's no guarantee they'd work.

lorul2 2010-11-19 17:59

Re: N900 still epic
 
Just wanted to be part of the love!

jflatt 2010-11-19 18:10

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Radicalz38 (Post 878124)
I'm seeing the future of meego as this...
Android = java wrapping linux
Meego = QT wrapping linux

MeeGo is a full Linux stack

gazza_d 2010-11-19 18:34

Re: N900 still epic
 
damn right it's epic...

i have moreorless replaced my laptop with my n900. there is not much my laptop will do that the 900 can't. about the onle thing i use it for is torrents as i don't wantt to trash an sd card to death, or gobble all my data allowance when I drop onto 3G.

Radicalz38 2010-11-19 18:41

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wmarone (Post 878146)
Yes, point being? MeeGo will have community repos much like Maemo does, however. You'll probably need to hack or buy an unlocked unit to use them however.

well my point is... flexibility...for me the more the better :D
Like they say 2 heads are better than 1.

Quote:

Originally Posted by wmarone (Post 878146)
No, you can't. Even if you could, you'd be on your own as there's no guarantee they'd work.

Well on a developers point of view this would be fine with me. :)

Frappacino 2010-11-19 18:49

Re: N900 still epic
 
for the enthusiast its the holy grail

for anybody else who wants an appliance that just works, its very low on the totem pole. There is a reason why you do not see N900s on ppl walking in the streets.

wmarone 2010-11-19 18:53

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Frappacino (Post 878187)
There is a reason why you do not see N900s on ppl walking in the streets.

The fact that it's $600 and not available subsidized from carriers couldn't have anything to do with it, no? I can't say it would be a huge seller if it was, but the chips are stacked against it, especially in the US.

etuoyo 2010-11-19 18:58

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wmarone (Post 878190)
The fact that it's $600 and not available subsidized from carriers couldn't have anything to do with it, no? I can't say it would be a huge seller if it was, but the chips are stacked against it, especially in the US.

Don't think would have made much difference. Can be subsidized here in the UK but barely anyone would pick it over HTC Desire, Samsung Galaxy, iphone, etc. For those of us who want to tweak a lot and spend all day on an internet forum it is great and greatest thing since sliced bread. but for the mainstream not at all. Many far better options.

fahadj2003 2010-11-19 19:16

Re: N900 still epic
 
n900.. hardware.. epic.. yes
software.. maemo.. nokia's official update ****.. major components still closed.. epic.. no

ch88xy 2010-11-19 20:06

Re: N900 still epic
 
>>How are Ctrl + C and Ctrl + V complicated??? <<

I am talking about the actions you need to take before all these, namely highlighting. To retrieve the arrow icon and to mark it red for text selection, that's already two steps extra than in the case of N810. I know how to do it only because an advanced geek (think about that!!!) was asking the same question on this board, otherwise I don't think anybody could have figured it out in a million years. BTW I also know how to do it in RSS, where different steps are required, because I asked the question and someone (probably the developer?) was kind enough to show me how. But I still don't like it. I think it's too much work on my part as a user.

Laughingstok 2010-11-19 21:56

Re: N900 still epic
 
I fire up vpnc and connect to my companies Cisco VPN and work without issue from the shell on the N900.

My coworkers meanwhile root their OS and hunt for solutions (still) to accomplish the same task.

It's those kinds of things that make the ones "in the know" really understand it.

bobh 2010-11-19 22:17

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Frappacino (Post 878187)
for the enthusiast its the holy grail
for anybody else who wants an appliance that just works, its very low on the totem pole. There is a reason why you do not see N900s on ppl walking in the streets.

Being a geek, I only care what it can do for me, not how many are walking the street. The only reason to care about that at all is if more walk the street then Nokia or someone else is more likely to make another device with similar hackability but more powerful hardware sometime down the road.

You don't need to sell tens of millions to reach that goal. A niche market of a 500K or a million can be pretty profitable especially if development costs are relatively low because of the use of open source.

My understanding is that Nokia sold quite a few more than they expected and consider the N900 a success. So hopefully that means there will be some follow on in the future.

ch88xy 2010-11-19 22:29

Re: N900 still epic
 
>>It's those kinds of things that make the ones "in the know" really understand it.<<

That's fine, but not everybody is in the know or wants to be in the know about everything under the sun. Many of us have non-computer-related day jobs, and other interests beside computing. We just want something that works (I don't want closed stuff from Apple though) or requires minimal tweaking. Why can't Nokia offer a simple copy-paste solution? Do you think consumers would embrace this device that only computer geeks can love? (Judging from the fact that they had to dump the remaining N900, I guess not.)

ch88xy 2010-11-19 22:39

Re: N900 still epic
 
>>Being a geek, I only care what it can do for me, not how many are walking the street.<<

But I am sure you don't want to give yourself pain all the time, do you? You also want to see your devices being improved all the time, no? Without demand from users, there will be no real progress.

daperl 2010-11-20 02:20

Re: N900 still epic
 
@ch88xy

Your cluelessness doesn't really deserve a response, but I'm tired of reading your ignorant posts. So, I'll give one answer in the hope that you'll think before you type again in this thread.

Does microb on your n810 have double-tap or swirl zooming? No. Well, microb on the n900 does, thus, someone decided a special mode was needed for copying. And so they introduced the left side swipe.

It took Apple two years to bring copying to the iPhone browser; they chose to use tap-and-hold to invoke a popup menu. If you're not in fullscreen, copying text with microb is faster than it is on an iPhone. Suck it.

bobh 2010-11-20 02:22

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ch88xy (Post 878380)
>>Being a geek, I only care what it can do for me, not how many are walking the street.<<

But I am sure you don't want to give yourself pain all the time, do you? You also want to see your devices being improved all the time, no? Without demand from users, there will be no real progress.

I don't have pain all the time. I actually have very few complaints about the N900. If I did have a lot of complaints I'd get something else. I'm not locked into a contract or anything. But then, I had an N800 before and apparently unlike many I bought the 900 on the basis of improvements over that rather than on my imagining of what it "ought to do".

Yes, improvements are good. Without a certain level of sales there will be no improvement. Input from users can provide guidance as to what should be improved. None of that has anything to do with hype or whining about things never promised or dick-measuring relative to some other device.

porselinaheart 2010-11-20 03:27

Re: N900 still epic
 
i don't consider myself to be very tech savvy or it knowledgable, but that being said. I absolutely ADORE my n900, ;P I've only ever needed the basic telephony functions the n900 has ( extra functionality would be great, but not really necessary for me ) but the range of actual USEFUL apps suits my every need, and has gotten me interested in things i wouldn't have thought of doing on my phone before. Web/internet conenctivity ( like browsing,im, rss, blah blah blah etc ) functions are awesome. I agree that the phone needs a little self tweaking out of the box, but that just means i have a highly unique experience with my phone, and no other n900 out there looks exactly like it ( ui wise i mean )
Sure some research and reading is required to perform these tweaks/adjustments, but if someone like me can do it, then the only excuse a 'normal' user has for saying that it requires too much work/ is not user friendly i can think of is that they're lazy or they just don't care about extra functionality.

Cue 2010-11-20 04:08

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ch88xy (Post 878110)
And why does a Web page have to jerk around when you touch it?

in Soviet Russia web page gets off on you...or something.

porselinaheart 2010-11-20 04:31

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cue (Post 878507)
in Soviet Russia web page gets off on you...or something.

roffle, haven't seen that line in a while, :P

ch88xy 2010-11-20 05:35

Re: N900 still epic
 
@daperl
I do recall trying the swirl thing when I first got my N900, but decided that I didn't like the feature, so promptly forgot about it. I am sure many N810 users would expect a simple tap and hold, just like me. If you want to call that ignorant, so be it.

hellnick 2010-11-20 05:45

Re: N900 still epic
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ch88xy (Post 878534)
@daperl
I do recall trying the swirl thing when I first got my N900, but decided that I didn't like the feature, so promptly forgot about it. I am sure many N810 users would expect a simple tap and hold, just like me. If you want to call that ignorant, so be it.

I'm almost embarrassed to say this but the swirl zoom has never worked for me and I've never seen a setting to enable it...


All times are GMT. The time now is 18:15.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8