maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   MeeGo / Harmattan (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=45)
-   -   One 2 Touch NFC keyboard (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=81493)

Lomax 2012-01-10 16:19

One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Hi all,

Spotted this new foldable keyboard (from Norway!) which uses NFC instead of BT to connect to a handset:

http://www.12touch.no

Could this be the perfect keyboard for the N9?

Sniper_swe 2012-01-10 17:20

I've sent them an email to ask some questions:)

DarkSkies 2012-01-10 18:24

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Looks kinda bulky, doesn't it?

freemangordon 2012-01-10 18:39

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Well, most-probably it uses NFC to do a quick pair using Bluetooth(instead of entering code) , NFC range is 1.5-5 cm according to specifications (if memory serves me well)

m4r0v3r 2012-01-10 18:45

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
i can problably use that keyboard but my fingers go to the otherside of the keyboard a lot so hmmm

Lomax 2012-01-10 19:09

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by freemangordon (Post 1148503)
Well, most-probably it uses NFC to do a quick pair using Bluetooth(instead of entering code) , NFC range is 1.5-5 cm according to specifications (if memory serves me well)

I'm pretty sure it's NFC all the way - hence the non user replaceable battery with 3 year life...

jalyst 2012-01-10 20:10

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
^ Veeeery interesting, nice find, thanks.

Lomax 2012-01-18 03:16

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sniper_swe (Post 1148460)
I've sent them an email to ask some questions

Ditto! I really hope they'll work on a driver for the N9 - if not we'll just have to cobble one together ourselves... ;)

SamGan 2012-01-18 04:13

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Looks kind of big doesn't it? You would need a table top to use it. Not very convenient to carry around.

The best solution is a casing with slide out keyboard.

Lomax 2012-01-18 10:29

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SamGan (Post 1152164)
The best solution is a casing with slide out keyboard.

I don't agree at all: surely the best solution must be to have several options? I personally don't like the look of the slide out cases one bit, they look very cheap and plasticky to me - and would take up just as much place in my bag. The One2Touch keyboard is an innovative alternative that manages to look quite cool, and I for one support their efforts.

caranuial 2012-01-20 15:50

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
any news on availability, price or compatibility with our beloved N9?

'cos this one look really nice :)

Lomax 2012-01-20 18:47

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
I wrote to them to ask and was told it will be compatible with the N9, but that it was unlikely to be available (in the EU) until later this year. No pricing info, but I think they mention somewhere else that it will be around $50.

jalyst 2012-01-21 13:05

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lomax (Post 1153400)
I wrote to them to ask and was told it will be compatible with the N9, but that it was unlikely to be available (in the EU) until later this year. No pricing info, but I think they mention somewhere else that it will be around $50.

Wow nice, I think I'll be getting this if it works well.
I like the fact that uses much lower power via NFC.
And it looks like it's designed very well....

jalyst 2012-01-23 17:29

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lomax (Post 1153400)
I wrote to them to ask and was told it will be compatible with the N9, but that it was unlikely to be available (in the EU) until later this year. No pricing info, but I think they mention somewhere else that it will be around $50.

Did they say it'll be available earlier elsewhere or is the EU the 1st market?
Can they be more specific than "later this year"? e.g. Q2, Q3, Q4 etc.

Thank-you!

marxian 2012-01-23 17:41

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
The keyboard reminds me of the ZX Spectrum. Mushy. A folding keyboard with Cherry blues FTW.

Lomax 2012-01-23 18:14

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jalyst (Post 1154516)
Can they be more specific than "later this year"? e.g. Q2, Q3, Q4 etc.

I suppose there's no harm in me quoting their email:

Quote:

Yes, we will make it N9 compatible, but it will
not be available in the market in EU before end 2012.

wolke 2012-01-23 19:49

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lomax (Post 1148436)
Hi all,

Spotted this new foldable keyboard (from Norway!) which uses NFC instead of BT to connect to a handset:

http://www.12touch.no

Could this be the perfect keyboard for the N9?

link appears dead.

Lomax 2012-01-23 20:07

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wolke (Post 1154583)
link appears dead.

Indeed. My vapometer moves up a notch.

cddiede 2012-01-23 20:18

There's no such thing as a NFC keyboard. Even if you could stay in range with the device, there's no protocol for such a device to use. NFC is for burst transmission and not for persistent device connectivity.

This device clearly just uses NFC to pair a bluetooth connection, which a common useage much like Nokia's own bluetooth speakers.

And since the N9 doesn't support bluetooth keyboard connections yet, this device is not a smart buy for an N9 owner.

Lomax 2012-01-23 20:20

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cddiede (Post 1154602)
NFC is for burst transmission and not for persistent device connectivity.

I stand corrected.

godofwar424 2012-01-23 20:44

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cddiede (Post 1154602)
There's no such thing as a NFC keyboard. Even if you could stay in range with the device, there's no protocol for such a device to use. NFC is for burst transmission and not for persistent device connectivity.

This device clearly just uses NFC to pair a bluetooth connection, which a common useage much like Nokia's own bluetooth speakers.

And since the N9 doesn't support bluetooth keyboard connections yet, this device is not a smart buy for an N9 owner.

You must realise that if it was bluetooth, then it would require charging after 10 or so hours of use?

Also you said yourself NFC provides burst transmission, meaning that each keystroke can be a burst of data, meaning hardly any battery usage, and phone is CONSTANTLY in contact with the keyboard seeing as the design has the phone resting on the flat surface in the middle

Lomax 2012-01-23 20:50

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by godofwar424 (Post 1154614)
You must realise that if it was bluetooth, then it would require charging after 10 or so hours of use?

What I said. But I confess I don't know nearly enough about NFC to say whether a keyboard would be possible. I have noticed that there is quite a delay when reading cards with the N9 - even a fraction of that delay would be a show stopper for a keyboard...

jalyst 2012-01-23 21:37

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lomax (Post 1154535)
I suppose there's no harm in me quoting their email:

Meh too vague, but thanks...
I may try asking them again later, if the site ever comes back up!

Quote:

Originally Posted by cddiede (Post 1154602)
There's no such thing as a NFC keyboard. Even if you could stay in range with the device, there's no protocol for such a device to use. NFC is for burst transmission and not for persistent device connectivity<SNIP>

See the 1st several posts. Also godofwar raises some further good points.
Admittedly I know little about NFC, so this may well be pure vapor.

cddiede 2012-01-23 21:42

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by godofwar424 (Post 1154614)
You must realise that if it was bluetooth, then it would require charging after 10 or so hours of use?

You stand corrected:
wired.com/gadgetlab/2011/12/broadcom-offers-10-year-battery-life-for-bluetooth-keyboards/

jalyst 2012-01-23 21:47

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Ugh.......
So this depends on if we ever get the BT4 we were promised earlier on & all the signs were pointing to.*
I spoke to someone about that recently, & he couldn't tell me much except:

Quote:

BT4 is almost done, but not production level. You should raise a ticket about it to bugzilla. That it was promised.
The part missing from BT4 stack (the uncomplete part) is BT LE (Low Energy)...
It's really interesting for lot of accessory cases, but those are still so new that ordinary user would not be benefitting from those much within a year or so.
May be the reason why it hasn't been perfectly completed yet....
I guess the only way to know for sure, is to ask One2Touch to explain how it works.
We should be able to pick up ******** pretty quickly.... :)

*was in doco/specs all over the place, & some personnel in Australia felt it was coming w/1.1

invent 2012-01-23 22:38

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
It is purely NFC. Just check out the patent
http://www.google.com/patents?id=B3C...ed=0CDcQ6AEwAQ
(Search word "External Keyboard" & Aasen).

godofwar424 2012-01-24 00:01

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lomax (Post 1154615)
What I said. But I confess I don't know nearly enough about NFC to say whether a keyboard would be possible. I have noticed that there is quite a delay when reading cards with the N9 - even a fraction of that delay would be a show stopper for a keyboard...

But that delay seems to be for the initial communication, I reckon once the initial connection is made, the N9 will stay active for a second or two to see for any further connections.

Lomax 2012-01-24 00:44

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cddiede (Post 1154602)
There's no such thing as a NFC keyboard

Quote:

Originally Posted by cddiede (Post 1154635)
You stand corrected

And there you are. Standing. Corrected. :p

jalyst 2012-01-24 00:48

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Well it could still remain vaporware :)

cddiede 2012-01-24 01:01

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by invent (Post 1154662)
It is purely NFC. Just check out the patent
http://www.google.com/patents?id=B3C...ed=0CDcQ6AEwAQ
(Search word "External Keyboard" & Aasen).

As facinating as this NFC keyboard sounds.....

Antigravity craft slips past patent officers :
http://www.nature.com/nature/journal...l/438139a.html

Basically, release a product or it doesn't exist.

mscion 2012-01-24 01:18

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cddiede (Post 1154602)
.
.
.

And since the N9 doesn't support bluetooth keyboard connections yet, this device is not a smart buy for an N9 owner.

Hi cddiede.

Actually, I've had limited success getting btkb working with N9. The instructions are given in the FMC thread

"How to connect bluetooth keyboard to N9"

Unfortunately it only works as long a the VKB remains in view. That is, if you swipe the VKB off the screen, while leaving the terminal in view, you can no longer enter any keystrokes from the bluetooth keyboard! This kind of defeats the purpose as I generally would like to have a full screen in view while typing. There is a possible fix given in the thread and while I do lots of scientific programing I think it is a problem more appropriate for a skilled developer on these forums (unless you don't mind waiting 6 months for me to do it!). Also, the other thing I noticed is that I could start up some apps from the touch pad on my btkb, but, here the problem is that I could not easily control which app I started because I could not see where the cursor was! At least I think there is one! Anyways, I hope someone can tackle this soon as many would benefit...

damaltor 2012-01-24 02:01

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
New Link:
http://o2t.nxtech.no/

jalyst 2012-01-24 03:42

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mscion (Post 1154733)
Hi cddiede.

Actually, I've had limited success getting btkb working with N9. The instructions are given in the FMC thread

<SNIP>

I coulda told him all that, but assumed he already knew :)
Thanks for the summary of it all again...

cddiede 2012-01-24 11:55

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jalyst (Post 1154755)
I coulda told him all that, but assumed he already knew :)
Thanks for the summary of it all again...

Yep, I'm aware of and very appreciative of the current efforts to get bluetooth keyboards working on the N9.

However, my initial statement was more to the effect of:

"If bluetooth keyboards aren't officially supported by, nor work out of the box on the N9, then purchasing an "NFC" keyboard that likely uses bluetooth connections is an unwise purchase."

damaltor 2012-01-24 11:58

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Why do you still think that it uses bluetooth? Of course nfc could be used to transmit keypresses, if an appropriate driver modules is loaded.

godofwar424 2012-01-24 12:07

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cddiede (Post 1154877)
Yep, I'm aware of and very appreciative of the current efforts to get bluetooth keyboards working on the N9.

However, my initial statement was more to the effect of:

"If bluetooth keyboards aren't officially supported by, nor work out of the box on the N9, then purchasing an "NFC" keyboard that likely uses bluetooth connections is an unwise purchase."

The patent does suggest that only NFC is used, meaning there's no bluetooth chip in this keyboard, and the company mentioned the N9 as something that are working on for compatibility meaning they must be creating some sort of driver that will enable it to work effectively with the N9 :)

godofwar424 2012-01-24 12:09

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
In their video the android device they are using has no bluetooth icon on the notification bar at the top!

NFC One2Touch Video

PortaDiFerro 2012-01-24 13:01

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
This thing is extremely interesting, although I'd be more interested in something that you don't need a table to use with, ie in bus/bus stop, lunch queue, walking. Might have to get this anyway just to check it out and support the company.

Also they are clearly saying on their page that they are using NFC to substitute BT.

freemangordon 2012-01-24 13:08

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by damaltor (Post 1154878)
Why do you still think that it uses bluetooth? Of course nfc could be used to transmit keypresses, if an appropriate driver modules is loaded.

Because AFAIK NFC does not have protocol to be used for such purpose.

By using NFC you could:
read/write tags.
emulate ISO (put number here) and mifare cards (EMV, QVSDC ,etc.)
do easy paring (for BlueTooth)

Anyway, by looking at the video it seems it really does not use BT. Just wondering how portable will be such proprietary extension to NFC. And how usefull it will be to hold your device on the top of your keyboard. NFC range is 1-5 cm, no options there.

damaltor 2012-01-24 14:02

Re: One 2 Touch NFC keyboard
 
NFC can transmit arbitrary data, too (which is done on bt pairing, as the two devices exchage a bluetooth passkey).

As the data rate is (relatively) slow, there is no sense in transmittig big amounts of data (like directly sharing an image via nfc).

but as a keyboard has to send a minimal amount of data, nfc is fast enough. there is no standard for this though, there will be a special driver needed, which is polling nfc and emulates the keypresses for the os.


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:29.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8