maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   General (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego? (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=82039)

Dave999 2012-02-01 19:30

What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
1 - Sink it to the bottom of the arctic sea where no one will find it. EVER!

X. - Use it for his staff to devloping his own OS, called PeeGo, which only he is allowed to use, since he realised windows is not good enough for him.

2. Give to the poor guys that have supported the OSes for several years. (Yes, that's right. The poor guys are you and me, pal)

jaripi 2012-02-01 19:44

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
He will launch N960 and N9+ after Windows launching is done ... :)

Dave999 2012-02-01 19:46

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
No, Incorrect answer!

sanchdaniel 2012-02-01 19:48

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
I believe it will be answer 1.

"1 - Sink it to the bottom of the arctic sea where no one will find it. EVER!"

But, with enough dedication, someone(poor guys) might eventually get to it. Or, Nokia might release these things once they are not as relevant.

SD69 2012-02-01 19:58

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sanchdaniel (Post 1159129)
But, with enough dedication, someone(poor guys) might eventually get to it. Or, Nokia might release these things once they are not as relevant.

So that we don't go down this road again, after the WebOS announcement, I suggested again to Nokia opening up some parts of maemo. The response was silence.

Dave999 2012-02-01 20:23

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sanchdaniel (Post 1159129)
I believe it will be answer 1.

"1 - Sink it to the bottom of the arctic sea where no one will find it. EVER!"

But, with enough dedication, someone(poor guys) might eventually get to it. Or, Nokia might release these things once they are not as relevant.

That is two or possibly three answers...:eek:

Stskeeps 2012-02-01 20:26

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Honestly?

1) Sink it to the bottom

Open sourcing everything takes resources and lawyer time and developer time, neither which our beloved Maemo Devices has anymore.

In addition to that, most of Harmattan apps is built around a dead framework (MTF) and Fremantle apps is built around also dead one (Hildon, though that is being rebased on GTK+3)

We got a significant amount of things open sourced through MeeGo, but I think that's about it we'll see for now.

Dave999 2012-02-01 21:01

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Me, myself, leaning towards option X. Elop has fired alot of people and he might building a secret staff at some remote location and later on, a secret OS for himself. Unfortunately, I have no proof at this time!

Dave999 2012-02-02 17:11

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Option 2! We will get it :D

Dave999 2014-01-03 18:54

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Would it possible for Maemo Council to send a mail directly to Elop?

Rauha 2014-01-03 19:09

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
a). Doesn't Elop work as MS EVP of mobile since 1.1.2014?

b). Could the council, or possibly whoever remains modding these forums, do something to reign in Dave's necrophilia? The fetish is getting out of hand.

Mric 2014-01-03 19:09

option Y: make a giant fundraising operation in exchange of the closed parts of MeeGo.

This option would be both mutually beneficial for Elop and the community. Like Stskeeps said: “open sourcing takes time and lawyer time” which could be founded by the community and the company could even make a profit on it which is better than nothing like now.

Estel 2014-01-03 19:13

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
And what shitty corporations do with their IP, if they're not FOSS-friendly? Dump it into the "locker" for eternity, as for their limited thinking abilities, opening any source code = some (even if small) cost and no profit, while keeping it dumped somewhere = no cost no profit. So, following their line of thinking, dumping into eternal freezer is more "profitable" than opening.

Nokia presented this stance many times even before elop, no reasons to believe it changed to better during nokia$oft transformation.

IMO, asking Council - whoever they are, and if that body even still exist at all (sorry, I'm out of loop about such things) - is just implying on those poor guys to waste their time. Really, I don't believe anyone ever think about receiving positive answer (or any answer, probably).

/Estel

// Edit

Not that harmattan parts are, in any way, anything worthwhile for the community. The only thing that "can" be done for those devices, is to make all "Trusted" computing bits miraculously disappear on hardware level (that is, no signed-*anything*), and dumping whole system for something better. FOSS'ified Fremantle (preferably) or Mer without current limitations. Ah, and if someone need more miracles - closed hardware (GPS) becoming fully documented and open, all of sudden ;)

No amount of OS or UI components opening is going to help a device, that is so full of treacherously closed hardware.

If someone got confused by the above - no, it's not gonna happen, it's just a, well, "thought experiment".

aironeous 2014-01-03 19:50

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
He will take it and his 25 million dollar bonus (for destroying Nokia handsets) to his master's base (Dr. Octupus) under the ocean to use on his masters computer system.

There they will teleconfrence with the Nokia board members to create a new reality TV show only viewable by the 1%ers of the world called "So you think you can fail."

The one that destroys the biggest company and/or the most people's/country's income and gets away with it for the longest time while making the most money wins.

*edit: Happy New Year!

tissot 2014-01-03 21:54

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rauha (Post 1403459)
a). Doesn't Elop work as MS EVP of mobile since 1.1.2014?

b). Could the council, or possibly whoever remains modding these forums, do something to reign in Dave's necrophilia? The fetish is getting out of hand.

I really shouldn't even post to this thread, but Elop moved to MS couple of days ago.
He has not been representing Nokia for months though. Timo Ihamuotila has been Nokia's temporary CEO since September, before new one is selected shortly.

Rauha 2014-01-03 22:23

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Nevermind Tissot.

I'm sure Dave is finding something to do with his time by bumping up yet another thread back from few years back.

m4r0v3r 2014-01-03 22:26

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
tbh who actually owns the rights? I understand MS bought the phone division, but I though that was largely the crappy windows phone making part. Also who exactly owns Nokia? Is it the finnish or MS, what did MS get?

salsatabasco 2014-01-03 23:24

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Have you guys seen the asha 501? Thats where harmattan ended up, and probably why they wont open source it.

sponka 2014-01-04 00:38

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Wiki doesn't agree:

Quote:

The cell phone is built on Nokia Asha software platform 1.0, a new software platform descended from Series 40, with a user interface similar to MeeGo on Nokia N9, and featuring technology from Smarterphone, a software company acquired by Nokia in 2012.
And Smarterphone ...

Daneel 2014-01-04 01:52

Re: What will Elop do with the closed parts Maemo/Meego?
 
Dave, you are a waste of oxygen, every step you take on this planet is one step too many, you are the sole reason for the decadence of humanity, oil wars, aids and dead kittens.
Dave, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OT7xc_XqYO8


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:14.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8