maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N9 / N950 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=51)
-   -   Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=87063)

johnb543 2012-09-27 04:34

Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
3 Attachment(s)
So I'm hanging out with my Family for my Father's birthday, when my 10 year old niece decides to play angry birds (something normal which I let her all the time). While the good times roll, out of the corner of my eye, my beautiful N9 falling to it's ?death? Everyone was having a good laugh, even me, while my niece was crying uncontrollably, poor girl. Everyone saw it and knew of course it was in a million pieces.

Now, this is from the 16th floor of a building, and on the other side of the is concrete. When we went downstairs to pick it up, after 10 minutes of deciding whether or not we should even bother, we found it laying there. To my amazement, the phone was indeed intact. With provided case attached to it, the phone seems like it is still functional ! ! ! I mean, I picked it up and tried to turn it on, and the notification light in the lower left hand corner blinked twice. Since then, it doesn't blink, even while charging.

Now my question is, seeing that it did blink, is there some sort of miracle to know for sure if it can still be a functional device? I will post pictures of it tomorrow and will try to disassemble the phone, but what should I be looking for to know if this phone can be salvaged or good to throw away at my local dump site. The screen is in a million pieces but still intact. This phone definitely survived 16 floors of gravity.

soryuuha 2012-09-27 04:58

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
picture of your n9!

Maserti 2012-09-27 05:00

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
really!?,title made it sound like bad news. Might have to do a flash?

szymeczek34 2012-09-27 05:03

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Wow! Sorry to hear that but it's actually amazing that it survived in one piece! Hope you will be able to recover your data. I'm just curious, did it fall on grass? And what case do you have?
Edit: i just did a little calculation. Your n9 hit the ground at aprox 100km/h!!! And about it's signs of life...it might be hard to revive it. You have to open it and see what's destroyed. Battery could devastate it quite a lot and many connections between chips and mb can be torn apart. As I think of it more I'm pretty sure it's dead for good but I wouldn't throw it away. I would leave it as a memorial to that sad moment and a true test for finish quality.

lorenzo 2012-09-27 05:12

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
if it doesn't look damaged you can try to bring it to the nokia centre

immi.shk 2012-09-27 05:26

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Seems loose contact to me

1 : put it screen down

2 : tap on the back with hand (not too hard), there might be a chance it will make contact, since circuit is top facing

3 : try turning it on

4 : GODbless :)

szymeczek34 2012-09-27 05:40

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
I wouldn't count on hitting it as the contacts must be soldered. You might try though push all chips a little to the pcb and heat them with a heater, just like you fix ps3. You just have to be careful not to burn them but we need someone to tell us whether these chips can bare high temps as ps3 operates normally at much higher temp as our omap.

tortoisedoc 2012-09-27 08:29

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by johnb543 (Post 1272768)
So I'm hanging out with my Family for my Father's birthday, when my 10 year old niece decides to play angry birds (something normal which I let her all the time). While the good times roll, out of the corner of my eye, my beautiful N9 falling to it's ?death? Everyone was having a good laugh, even me, while my niece was crying uncontrollably, poor girl. Everyone saw it and knew of course it was in a million pieces.

Now, this is from the 16th floor of a building, and on the other side of the is concrete. When we went downstairs to pick it up, after 10 minutes of deciding whether or not we should even bother, we found it laying there. To my amazement, the phone was indeed intact. With provided case attached to it, the phone seems like it is still functional ! ! ! I mean, I picked it up and tried to turn it on, and the notification light in the lower left hand corner blinked twice. Since then, it doesn't blink, even while charging.

Now my question is, seeing that it did blink, is there some sort of miracle to know for sure if it can still be a functional device? I will post pictures of it tomorrow and will try to disassemble the phone, but what should I be looking for to know if this phone can be salvaged or good to throw away at my local dump site. The screen is in a million pieces but still intact. This phone definitely survived 16 floors of gravity.

I call bullsh*t.
PICTURE!

Hurrian 2012-09-27 09:08

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Whoa, nasty. I'm surprised the plastic body didn't shatter.

The lights blinking very early in boot indicates hardware failure. Try to get it taken apart at Nokia Care, or try to do it yourself - it's quite easy to disassemble the N9.

AMD 2012-09-27 14:30

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Wow, this is epic.. Seriously, some phones get shattered to million pieces from a 2-floor fall!

HELLASISGREECE 2012-09-27 14:33

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
I bet Stephen Elop had a hiccough at that time.

v0id 2012-09-27 15:39

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
picture or it didnt happen ^^

Half-Life_4_Life 2012-09-27 15:43

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
That is amazing.Though I wouldn't been laughing as my phone was falling from 16th floor ಠ_ಠ

jflatt 2012-09-27 16:00

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Do it again and record the accelerometer

ibrakalifa 2012-09-27 16:15

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jflatt (Post 1272972)
Do it again and record the accelerometer

upload it to YouTube !!

flopjoke 2012-09-27 17:23

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
but will it blend now?

MINKIN2 2012-09-27 18:08

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
When you say "16 Floors", is this using the European method of counting floors or the American way? Because if it is the latter, it's not so impressive ;)

tommo 2012-09-27 18:14

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
If its dead, can u send me the box??... I lost mine! ;-)

johnb543 2012-09-27 18:45

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Ok, I uploaded some pictures from my webcam, sorry for the quality :/
I will post more as I open the phone and after I stick the mother board in the oven for 10 min. maybe that might help the circuit board and sensors ?

johnb543 2012-09-27 18:46

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tommo (Post 1273006)
If its dead, can u send me the box??... I lost mine! ;-)

the outer casing has no scratch what so ever... nothing.. looks new... it was protected by the soft gel case that came with the phone.

szymeczek34 2012-09-27 18:48

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Let's hope for it. Just remember that after 10minutes just open the oven, don't touch. Don't touch it, just let it cool for another 20minutes.

AMD 2012-09-27 18:48

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by johnb543 (Post 1273011)
Ok, I uploaded some pictures from my webcam, sorry for the quality :/
I will post more as I open the phone and after I stick the mother board in the oven for 10 min. maybe that might help the circuit board and sensors ?

Wow... Seriously, nothing happened from the back? That's awesome! If the screen's upper layer is the one that's cracked hopefully it can be fixed.. I hope it works.. Though it's not even near to possible :P

johnb543 2012-09-27 18:49

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by szymeczek34 (Post 1272779)
Wow! Sorry to hear that but it's actually amazing that it survived in one piece! Hope you will be able to recover your data. I'm just curious, did it fall on grass? And what case do you have?
Edit: i just did a little calculation. Your n9 hit the ground at aprox 100km/h!!! And about it's signs of life...it might be hard to revive it. You have to open it and see what's destroyed. Battery could devastate it quite a lot and many connections between chips and mb can be torn apart. As I think of it more I'm pretty sure it's dead for good but I wouldn't throw it away. I would leave it as a memorial to that sad moment and a true test for finish quality.

It hit right on the pavement.. no grass surrounds the area where it fell. Thanks for the info about your calculations of the speed !!! that is really awesome :D I love Nokia and their last phone Nokia N9. I will try to open it up and post pictures and then decide to stick it in the oven to maybe get some of the chips and sensors circuited again.

johnb543 2012-09-27 18:52

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lorenzo (Post 1272782)
if it doesn't look damaged you can try to bring it to the nokia centre

I wish but Nokia doesn't exist in America :( and I'm pretty sure the warranty doesn't work in europe if I go... its 11 months old anyways. Maybe Palco , but I've dealt with them a couple times for my N900 and last time they charged me for doing nothing to the phone, still came back not working. So i'm hesitant to give my N9 to Palco here in the U.S.

johnb543 2012-09-27 18:54

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AMD (Post 1273015)
Wow... Seriously, nothing happened from the back? That's awesome! If the screen's upper layer is the one that's cracked hopefully it can be fixed.. I hope it works.. Though it's not even near to possible :P

Yeah ! Even the camera lens is still intact. And the flash glass cover.

slaapliedje 2012-09-27 19:28

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
I definitely want to see the insides of it now, this will be epic if it is still alive somehow. For reference, I think we need to drop an iPhone 5 off of the same balcony :D

slaapliedje

minimos 2012-09-27 21:09

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slaapliedje (Post 1273029)
For reference, I think we need to drop an iPhone 5 off of the same balcony :D

I'm sure we can find some proud iPhone owner that will say their phone can do better :D

Diggler 2012-09-27 21:33

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
My girlfriends' iPhone 4 looked something like that when dropped from 0,5 meters :) It is still working though.

Regarding disamble of the N9; My two year old son managed to get hold of my phone when charging and of course he managed to break the flap covering the usb connector. I watched a youtube video how to disamble the N9 and this is the first thing he removes with a single snap when opened. I tried this but it was impossible to remove. I used tools to get a better grip but no luck. Anyone tried to remove this themselves?

deviantv1ral 2012-09-27 23:04

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by szymeczek34 (Post 1272779)
Wow! Sorry to hear that but it's actually amazing that it survived in one piece! Hope you will be able to recover your data. I'm just curious, did it fall on grass? And what case do you have?
Edit: i just did a little calculation. Your n9 hit the ground at aprox 100km/h!!! And about it's signs of life...it might be hard to revive it. You have to open it and see what's destroyed. Battery could devastate it quite a lot and many connections between chips and mb can be torn apart. As I think of it more I'm pretty sure it's dead for good but I wouldn't throw it away. I would leave it as a memorial to that sad moment and a true test for finish quality.

assuming see level the dimensions and mass on gsmarena and laminar flow . and a drag coefficient of 1.28, the terminal velocity is around 50 km/h or 30 mph :p

assuming 16 stories is enough to reach that velocity of course.

to OP hows the body, any dents? i have on the corner of mine and my gf's lumia 900 too.

i just bought a new case to replace it for 40 usd

johnb543 2012-09-27 23:27

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by deviantv1ral (Post 1273130)
assuming see level the dimensions and mass on gsmarena and laminar flow . and a drag coefficient of 1.28, the terminal velocity is around 50 km/h or 30 mph :p

assuming 16 stories is enough to reach that velocity of course.

to OP hows the body, any dents? i have on the corner of mine and my gf's lumia 900 too.

i just bought a new case to replace it for 40 usd

Hahahaaa no ... if you want to get scientific we can. 16th Floors is 160 feet about 50 meters and sea level is 3 feet above sea level since the condo was on the beach. So now how much velocity do you think ? ?

The outter casing (body/outside hardware) has no scratches or dents except from previous drops which all had happened without the soft gel case.

Lumiaman 2012-09-27 23:47

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by johnb543 (Post 1273139)
Hahahaaa no ... if you want to get scientific we can. 16th Floors is 160 feet about 50 meters and sea level is 3 feet above sea level since the condo was on the beach. So now how much velocity do you think ? ?

The outter casing (body/outside hardware) has no scratches or dents except from previous drops which all had happened without the soft gel case.

YOu think N9 would survive this:

http://www.idownloadblog.com/2011/03...e-still-works/

Lumiaman 2012-09-27 23:48

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
or this:

http://appleinsider.com/articles/11/...rs_pocket.html

deviantv1ral 2012-09-28 00:01

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
oh so you had the silicon case? i might have to rethink my decision "to case or not to case"

using newton's gravitational law to model a non constant acceleration? now thats diff eq i'd rather not lol

@lumiadude doesnt matter how high, it'll reach maximum speed in a few seconds

Scharel 2012-09-28 00:21

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Diggler (Post 1273087)
...
Regarding disamble of the N9; My two year old son managed to get hold of my phone when charging and of course he managed to break the flap covering the usb connector. I watched a youtube video how to disamble the N9 and this is the first thing he removes with a single snap when opened. I tried this but it was impossible to remove. I used tools to get a better grip but no luck. Anyone tried to remove this themselves?

I had no problem to put this off. just pull

Estel 2012-09-28 00:43

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by johnb543 (Post 1272768)
I mean, I picked it up and tried to turn it on, and the notification light in the lower left hand corner blinked twice. Since then, it doesn't blink, even while charging.

Now my question is, seeing that it did blink, is there some sort of miracle to know for sure if it can still be a functional device?I be looking for to know if this phone can be salvaged or good to throw away at my local dump site.

It was saying good bye. Poor little robot, waited 10 minutes (when You wondered if You should even bother going down to pick it up), keeping itself alive, to blink twice, saying goodbye.

And now, You're wondering, if You should put it into trash dump. Cruel bastard.

johnb543 2012-09-28 04:53

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Estel (Post 1273156)
It was saying good bye. Poor little robot, waited 10 minutes (when You wondered if You should even bother going down to pick it up), keeping itself alive, to blink twice, saying goodbye.

And now, You're wondering, if You should put it into trash dump. Cruel bastard.

Lmao, I honor your world, but sorry my good friend Estel, it's all just in the name of good humor. Would never give my N9 away after I bought it on 11/11/11 and Got it stolen and Got it recovered. And yes it was just like you said. A poor little poor wondering if my best friend is alive, seeing it blink twice, saying goodbye, waiting for its return to be alive again.
I have all the intention to bring my baby back to life... Long live the N9 and lumiaman go away with your shitnonsense !!

danested 2012-09-28 07:03

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
It must have fallen face down... on the glass first... And The I phone too... and the one thing that's common in both of em is the glass.

Hurrian 2012-09-28 11:09

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
Disconnect the battery, reconnect it, then put it back together, and from a PC, run "flasher -i" and connect the USB cable.

If it responds, the main board's alive.
If it doesn't, it's dead, or you may want to investigate whether all the connectors are still where they're supposed to be. The N9 does not make a rattling sound when you shake it up.

Storm_11 2012-09-28 11:23

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
try taking the screen off, and ensure the battery is connected properly. I once had the same thing when taking my n9's screen off, turns out the battery plug was slightly dislodged. Its somewhat secure, but after a fall from the 16th floor... probably became dislodged somewhat

slaapliedje 2012-09-28 11:32

Re: Nokia N9 fell from 16th floor balcony
 
I vote that if he resurrects it, he gives his phone the name of Jesus.

At least you'd have a great story of why. A friend of mine... his ex-girlfriend's insane parents were Jehova Witnesses and one day her mother had left her cell phone in my friend's car, and it said "Jehova" no the front.... I just shook my head.

slaapliedje


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:47.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8