maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Community (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=89926)

joerg_rw 2013-04-27 02:56

[ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
This is a moderated thread just to plublish concise info for you. It's not meant to start any discussion here
Facts and News about The April/May 2013 Elections

(Direct links to voting pages will be behind the banners at time! Just CLICK!)


As you already might have noticed, it's time for another Maemo Community Council (MCC) election, which has to happen every 6 months the latest.
This time we also try to finalize pending issues around the Hildon Foundation (HiFo) which needs a council (Hildon Foundation Council (HFC)) as supervisory board entity and to coordinate and manage election of the HiFo Board of Directors (BoD).

According to common notion in maemo community there seems to be a desire to have MCC take that role of HFC.

So MCC and current BoD - after long arguing about the right way to go forward - came up with a process that allows the community to decide on whether you actually want that unified single council entity and also this process hopefully is compliant with all the rules and regulations all involved entities have to adhere to. It looks like this:

Code:

1. step: MCC asks community in a referendum to allow small adjustments to the MCC election rules so they won't conflict with any HiFo bylaws rules
This referendum is already running and all of you who, according to usual karma and account age rules, are eligible to vote should have received your mail from maemo with your token so you can vote.  PLEASE USE YOUR RIGHT TO VOTE!  It's the only support we - the council - NEED from you - the community - to make all this happen for you and secure maemo's future.
MCC suggests that you vote "YES" on this referendum.

Important info: This time basically everybody is entitled to participate in voting and we very much like to ask you to actually do. If you haven't received a token mail yet, this might be either due to problems with sending the mail to you, or you're not in the bunch that automatically got a mail due to karma or account age issues. please see http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php...13#post1338413 how to proceed, there's probably no reason why you shouldn't be allowed to vote.

Referendum voting closed. 82 votes, 77 YES, 1 NO, 4 void: http://maemo.org/vote/results.php?election_id=30
Referendum got votes YES, changes to MCC rules are in effect.




Now next one, which is...

2. step: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/sh...13_COUNCIL.png synchronous elections of (new) MCC and (first) HFC. The nomination period for that ended and voting will start on 2013-04-30. We have seven candidates that are nominated for both MCC and HFC, of which the community will vote 5 for each of both entities, in compliance with the then-to-be identical election rules thanks to step 1. It's current council's and (at least partially) BoD's recommendation that you all vote identical on both votes, so we will have an identical body for both MCC and HFC after voting closed.
Both the MCC and the HFC election been announced and voting on both will start one day after referendum voting closes:

Council Election Voting Closed

results:
http://maemo.org/vote/results.php?election_id=31
http://maemo.org/vote/results.php?election_id=33


tip: to vote identical on both votes I found the advice to write down what you vote in one vote is really needed since unless you thought very thoroughly to make your decision, you will run into difficulties recalling exact selection and sequence of your previous vote in sister election. Please don't spoil council merging just because you ignored the importance to vote identical on both votes, or you were just too lazy, or full of confidence that you could recall a sequence of a few items for just 5 minutes
However there's a convenient workaround for the digital natives who know pencil and paper only from old movies: open TWO windows (or tabs) with http://maemo.org/vote/, select
Maemo Community Council Election Q2 2013 in one of them, and
Hildon Foundation Council Election Q2 2013 in the other. (you also can simply click <- the links here)
Fill in your email addr and token into both windows/tabs in sync (very convenient for copy&double-paste), to log in.
Then proceed in one window/tab until you made your complete selection, then go to the other window/tab and exactly duplicate.
Only then click "OK" in both windows/tabs. So you're sure you voted identical in both votes, with minimum overhead and virtually zero headache. Worked for me.



3. step: On own discretion the new Hildon Foundation Council may decide to unify or rather merge into the existing Maemo Community Council, and will create according rules for future (Hildon Foundation) council elections so this will become a sustainable status.
The MCC on own discretion may decide to permanently accept the duty to serve as HFC for HiFo. Since in step 1 and step 2 we resp you alligned both entities' rules and bodies, there wil be no clash of interests on either side in doing so. So this will result in de-facto only one council entity will exist from then on, which you can call HFC, MCC, MCC/HFC, or any other name the council will come up with, in the end who cares about names? For that council the same rules will apply as do for MCC now or rather after referendum.



So much for now. In a few days this post will get augmented to also explain the 4th election that you might have heard about: HiFo BoD election.

Please support the guys that try to keep maemo running and alive for you: VOTE!
Keep your token mail! You'll need it for all 4 votings.


Best Regards
jOERG
(councilor)

see wiki "how elections work" for a in-depth explanation on how votes ensure anonymity, how to vote (technically), and how you can resume an aborted voting process. Here is a TEST election for you to practice and play. Also see #13 in this thread.
PS: many thanks to win7mac for the icons!

qwazix 2013-04-27 15:38

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Dear Community

The nomination period for candidates for the upcoming Maemo Community Council and Hildon Foundation Council has ended on the 23rd of the current month of April. The voting begins on Tuesday the 30th of April. We are happy to see more than enough candidates to hold an election this time. The candidates are as follows:

Ruediger Schiller (chemist)
Joerg Reisenweber (joerg_rw/DocScrutinizer)
Edoardo Spadolini (kerio)
Christian Ratzenhofer (Merlin1991)
Aakash Sadh (thedead1440)
Michael Demetriou (qwazix)
Paul Healy (sixwheeledbeast)

You can see all candidates and their declarations at the following wiki page:

http://wiki.maemo.org/Community_Coun...e_declarations
One day earlier, on the 29th, the voting for the currently running referendum will end, as planned, in order to have the results of the vote before the voting period for the Council starts.
The nomination period for the elections of the Hildon Foundation Board is extended for 4 weeks due to insufficient candidates.

On behalf of the Maemo Community Council chair,

Michael Demetriou

jalyst 2013-04-28 14:29

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Apologies for the OT, feel free to move this post to a more appropriate thread....

I've read previously that MCC would be merged with HFC & there'd be only one entity called HFC.
Now I'm seeing it's been "decided" to merge them both & call that single entity MCC instead...
When did this "common notion" supposedly coalesce into the most broadly/commonly accepted one?

*edit* nvm I see this:
Quote:

Since in step 1 and step 2 we resp you alligned both entities' rules and bodies, there wil be no clash of interests on either side in doing so.
So this will result in de-facto only one council entity will exist from then on, which you can call HFC, MMC, or any other name the council will come up with, in the end who cares about names?

setter 2013-05-01 15:32

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
How to verify that my vote is correct? I have checked the token and the vote but see no possibility to verify. If it wasn't correct should I then mail someone and inform that it was wrong or???

thedead1440 2013-05-01 15:46

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by setter (Post 1340463)
How to verify that my vote is correct? I have checked the token and the vote but see no possibility to verify. If it wasn't correct should I then mail someone and inform that it was wrong or???

Go to http://maemo.org/vote/votes.php?election_id=30 and verify the code you received after voting with those on that list for the referendum voting...

setter 2013-05-01 17:20

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by thedead1440 (Post 1340467)
Go to http://maemo.org/vote/votes.php?election_id=30 and verify the code you received after voting with those on that list for the referendum voting...

I've been there before I made my posts. I can verify my token and vote but only for my self. I see no way to click at some button or any other thing to give you an acknowledgement thyat it is okey.

thedead1440 2013-05-01 17:26

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by setter (Post 1340485)
I've been there before I made my posts. I can verify my token and vote but only for my self. I see no way to click at some button or any other thing to give you an acknowledgement thyat it is okey.

That is indeed the acknowledgement so what else do you require?

setter 2013-05-01 17:34

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by thedead1440 (Post 1340486)
That is indeed the acknowledgement so what else do you require?

Thats why I wrote a question "If it wasn't correct should I then mail someone and inform that it was wrong???"

I believe I have got the answer :)

juiceme 2013-05-02 04:59

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
I can see from the voting results page (http://maemo.org/vote/votes.php?election_id=30) that my vote was counted correctly, but what I don't understand is why some tokens have 2 votes marked, like "1.YES 2.NO" ?

thedead1440 2013-05-02 06:16

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
juiceme,

Most likely since its a preference given some people were not alert enough to the question and chose both yes then no instead of just one of the options...

This is useful when electing candidates as you can prioritise your preferences but in a direct yes/no it was assumed maybe that people would at least bother to read before voting...

qwazix 2013-05-02 08:46

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Single transferrable vote, the system we use allows every voter to cast one vote. If the candidate they chose gets eliminated the vote is transferred to their next preference. This makes no sense in case of two candidates, but the system is still like that.

joerg_rw 2013-05-03 10:32

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by qwazix (Post 1340597)
Single transferrable vote, the system we use allows every voter to cast one vote. If the candidate they chose gets eliminated the vote is transferred to their next preference. This makes no sense in case of two candidates, but the system is still like that.

It actually makes no sense for only one "winner". alas the interface doesn't change depending on number of winners defined for the vote. No matter if you vote one out of two, one out of 8, or 5 out of 7, the web interface always works the same. For one winner votes only the top (#1) of your selection counts.

/j

joerg_rw 2013-05-05 08:09

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
I added a TEST election for you to test and practice.
It's moot, you're free to ignore it, it has no consequences whatsoever.
Works with same token as the other 2013-Q1/2 elections (actually I cloned the still untouched token table for BoD election).

Some remarks:
in "Step 2/4 - Choose your vote" you can remove candidates from "Preferences" by clicking on them, just like you selected them by clicking in "Candidates" field.
in "Step 3/4 - Confirm your vote" you can still click "Back" button of your browser which will bring you back to 2/4 with all previous "Preferences" deleted resp moved up to "Candidates" again
Only after you click "Continue to next step" button at bottom of screen 3/4, your vote gets committed and you get your confirmation token in screen 4/4

Despite this being an election set up to have two "winners" in the end, you're still free to select an arbitrary number of candidates from "none" to "COUNT(candidates)" (4 in this TEST election)

A HUGE THANKYOU to Woody who made it possible to conveniently and swiftly create elections like this one, by implementing the fine vote-admin web interface. Setting up the TEST election been a matter of ~5 min. :-)

have fun ;-)
/jOERG

joerg_rw 2013-05-08 02:33

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
council elections finished.
results:
http://maemo.org/vote/results.php?election_id=31
http://maemo.org/vote/results.php?election_id=33

more tomorrow
/j

misterc 2013-05-11 18:25

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
not even the same candidates made it in both councils ¦-)))))))
so the merged council will have threewheels720zombie or what?

joerg_rw 2013-06-26 07:03

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Sorry for my blatant failure to update this thread. :(
In short: councils finally got unified, BoD elections got announced and
currently the voting booth for BoD elections is open till June 28th 23:59UTC

As already announced during previous referendum and elections, for this vote you use the same authentication token you received for last votes. Same rules apply.

/j

joerg_rw 2013-06-29 13:07

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
votes finished, quite nice results
http://maemo.org/vote/results.php?election_id=32
Thanks to everybody who voted
I hope we're now done with this elections cycle, and you may forget about your token :-)

/j

nokiabot 2013-06-29 16:38

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
I cannot view that link it gives error why?? :( i want to know what happend . Could someone post here results :)

juiceme 2013-06-29 16:44

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Better than previously, that's a good thing attendance goes up!

jalyst 2013-06-29 17:20

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Excellent news that we now have 5 in the HFB!!!
And most seem to be very competent, 1 or 2 I'm not so sure about, but they deserve a chance to prove themselves.
And we can't be too critical, because at least they put their hand up to serve!

nokiabot 2013-06-29 17:38

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
I could have voted in the previous elections but now i know i was the mess not the system . Its easy and quick no hassels:)

Win7Mac 2013-06-29 19:41

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jalyst (Post 1355637)
And most seem to be very competent, 1 or 2 I'm not so sure about, but they deserve a chance to prove themselves.

I might be one of those I guess... :)
jalyst, I see you are making your points about N9/harmattan.
I very much appreciate that and am proud to say that I'll do my best to support your attempts. Please don't hesitate to bother me with your realistic ideas about improvements on the N9/harmattan infra here on maemo.org.

OFC, everybody else is invited to do the same as well.

Ilew 2013-06-29 21:50

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Oh no, Win7Mac made it in... I sense more banners in the not to distant future. :p

Congrats to everyone that made it in and thank you to those who participated.

Now back to lurking the irc logs...

jalyst 2013-06-30 04:12

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Win7Mac (Post 1355655)
I might be one of those I guess... :)
jalyst, I see you are making your points about N9/harmattan.
I very much appreciate that and am proud to say that I'll do my best to support your attempts. Please don't hesitate to bother me with your realistic ideas about improvements on the N9/harmattan infra here on maemo.org.
OFC, everybody else is invited to do the same as well.

I won't be so presumptuous as to tell you how to proceed, I'm just grateful that you've raised your hand, & will try to help. :)
But certainly if I have any concerns, or if I notice things that could be improved or attempted, then I'll try to remember to share them with the BoD or the CC.

Best of luck!

panjgoori 2013-07-19 20:46

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
one question. sorry if its off topic here. Why 16th July community meeting is not announced here ? i just saw it on Hildon Foundation website. isn't earlier every meeting was announced here in TMO ?

GeneralAntilles 2013-07-19 21:22

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by panjgoori (Post 1360260)
one question. sorry if its off topic here. Why 16th July community meeting is not announced here ? i just saw it on Hildon Foundation website. isn't earlier every meeting was announced here in TMO ?

My fault, I dropped the ball on the announcement. I drafted one, but never got around to posting it. I'll make sure it goes up in plenty of time for the next meeting.

panjgoori 2013-07-19 22:36

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles (Post 1360265)
My fault, I dropped the ball on the announcement. I drafted one, but never got around to posting it. I'll make sure it goes up in plenty of time for the next meeting.

thanks for the reply. can you post 16th July meeting minutes link here.

GeneralAntilles 2013-07-20 16:32

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by panjgoori (Post 1360273)
thanks for the reply. can you post 16th July meeting minutes link here.

Minutes will always be posted to the Hildon Foundation blog. I plan on mirroring them to a thread here, but haven't had time to format it in BBCode yet this week.

July 16th, 2013 meeting minutes

Jaffa 2013-07-22 03:23

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
We should be able to get the HiFo blog posts syndicated to the Community forum, in the same way we did for the Community Council.

Reggie did some magic which made TMO automagically post HTML in an RSS feed as a new thread, under a given user account (he also created a CommunityCouncil user for it).

qwazix 2013-07-22 06:15

Re: [ELECTIONS] [COUNCIL] news aggregator
 
Unfortunately this does not work every time though (migration issues?) and it creates more confusion than it helps, as we have to check back after a while to see if it worked, or post duplicates.


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:42.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8