maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   General (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Marc Dillon left Jolla (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=95935)

Dave999 2015-09-07 10:10

Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Marc D leaving the ship. should I get worried?

Stskeeps 2015-09-07 10:28

Re: Jolla tablet countup to delivery[Now With Poll]
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chuck Norris (Post 1481382)
Marc D leaving the ship. should I get worried?

Chuck Norris shouldn't worry.

MartinK 2015-09-07 11:22

Re: Jolla tablet countup to delivery[Now With Poll]
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stskeeps (Post 1481386)
Chuck Norris shouldn't worry.

Yeah! Worry should get Chuck Norris!

bockersjv 2015-09-07 20:58

Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Or should I say left! Big surprise and looks to be confirmed now. If there was someone I thought would be there to the end it was Marc.

Met him at the launch event and he was a truly inspiring speaker. I didn't see him as the captain of the Jolla ship, more THE ship.

Wish him well in whatever he moves to.

Mod edit:
Corrected thread title

jolla-pirate 2015-09-07 21:04

Re: Marc Dillon leaving Jolla
 
That surprises me!

salyavin 2015-09-07 22:39

Re: Jolla tablet countup to delivery[Now With Poll]
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvl (Post 1481385)
i believe he is taking more of the role of commodore, governing multiple ships

Ha at first I thought you were comparing Jolla to Commodore. I still have a couple Amigas hanging around from the 80s. That was a company with potential that messed up. I hope Jolla does better.

HtheB 2015-09-07 23:20

Re: Marc Dillon leaving Jolla
 
What happened??!
:/

This is seriously a bad news to Jolla....
Reminds me of the N9 story....

aegis 2015-09-08 01:23

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Total surprise for me too. Founders often do move on fairly quickly once past the excitement of a startup and perhaps the direction of the company changes so perhaps it's just that.

It does however feel like Jobs left Apple rather than Woz.

HtheB 2015-09-08 01:31

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
I think that something bad is going at Jolla.
Normally, they would write a blog, a tweet, or whatever to announce it... But there is nothing to be found...

Pretty sure some nda sh*t is going on why they can't tell the reason of his leaving... but I would love to hear from Dillon itself about this...

I know that Dillon really gave his heart on Jolla... And leaving the company even before the tablet is released?........

Copernicus 2015-09-08 02:15

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by HtheB (Post 1481513)
And leaving the company even before the tablet is released?........

Actually, the most harrowing days for the tablet are in the rear-view mirror. The problems with the display must have had folks at Jolla pulling their hair out. :) But they've managed to get past that, put together a device, and finally get all the pieces in place to get it shipped out. Sure, there has been some last-minute wrangling with logistics, but for all intents and purposes, the tablet is now done.

So, Jolla now has two examples of devices running Sailfish, and they've even netted their first licensee for the OS. At this point, they've pretty much got what they need to sell their product; now, they just need to start making contracts with manufacturers.

I kind of wonder if maybe this is why Dillon is leaving at this point. Jolla is actually kind of well-positioned to start becoming a fairly large concern, and maybe he prefers the freedom of the tiny startup... Anyway, just my own musings here.

Copernicus 2015-09-08 02:44

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by aegis (Post 1481512)
It does however feel like Jobs left Apple rather than Woz.

Just to be clear, both Jobs and Woz left Apple. :) It's just that eventually Jobs came back...

beobachter 2015-09-08 03:59

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Way too surprising for my morning ... Are we to wittness kinda Nokiasque meltdown in Jolla?

bockersjv 2015-09-08 04:18

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Well something is up. The news was all over my twitter feed and now all evidence is gone. NDA? Marcs feed has been quiet for days as hs the official channel.

bockersjv 2015-09-08 04:24

Re: Jolla tablet countup to delivery[Now With Poll]
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dirkvl (Post 1481385)
i believe he is taking more of the role of commodore, governing multiple ships

Really? That's not how the now deleted tweets explained it.

gerbick 2015-09-08 04:34

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by beobachter (Post 1481520)
Way too surprising for my morning ... Are we to wittness kinda Nokiasque meltdown in Jolla?

There's no Elop, there's no Microsoft, their managers seem to be invested in the company and not only their titles and there's no Symbian hoarding all of the R&D investments despite being a potential dead end while resting on their laurels thinking that they've cornered a market and were too big to lose.

No. Not another Nokia.

Marc Dillon's future endeavors might/might not include Jolla, but he was one of the founders with a vision of a startup that could release a device, change the way people saw how devices could be made, even sold and above all that it should be different and open enough to encourage other tinkerers, hackers and other fringe groups that feel left out of the Android and iOS race that's either under "Big Brother Google" or "closed platform/garden Apple" that none of us felt like we wanted to be a part of...

Yet, here we are, talking about Jolla some years after the fact, with a phone released with still incoming updates and a tablet that's ready to be shipped sometime very soon with an updated version of their Sailfish OS. You cannot say that much about most other companies at this moment that want to do any combination of my last paragraph. Neo900? Not yet delivered some 2+ years since I've seen it's first mention. And that "freedom" comes on an seriously underpowered, resistive, lower quality screen will cost you 4-5 Jolla smartphones. And it's still not yet available.

InvestorEye seems to match what he (and others) did while at Jolla. Find money, understand a demographic, talk to the engineers and thinkers, get them involved, get them talking and perhaps get some people investing.

With all of the layoffs just in Finland due to Nokia/Microsoft, it's not like there's a dearth of talent, capability and ideas. No... why not seed enough "think different/do different" mentality while making sure those minds do not go to Google, Apple or worse. It's what the Americans and Russians did with the German scientists during WW2 - take the best minds, fund them, watch the world change.

Am I speculating? Yep. Do I think Jolla is on its deathbed? Nope. If I were to speculate based solely on this forum, Jolla would have been dead at least 8 times, sold/reinvented as Nokia Jr. and running a bastardized version of a terminal only phone to make the geeks happy. Yeah... I don't think it works like that at all.

And I'm a serious outsider looking in. I have no true connections to Jolla, never tried their phone, ordered their tablet and if anything, I can see what niche needs to be filled. Perhaps Marc Dillon is doing just what I said, doing what I think he's doing... because it's sensible.

Sorry for the long post. Just tired of seeing doom and gloom whereas I see opportunity and a way to expand the horizons for the possibly disenfranchised yet incredibly intelligent folks in Finland that might bring a change that a huge corporation like Nokia might have never allowed.

Exciting times we live in... if you decide to look at it like that.

nieldk 2015-09-08 05:11

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Thanks to Cybette, and Jolla, for confirming Mr. Dillon left.

Now. A clarification, from my side, to Cybettes words.

As a company, Jolla can not say much more, at least without the concent from Mr. dillon.

Jolla can tell Mr. Dillon left.

Jolka can not, without the concent from Mr. Dillon, tell why or where Mr. Dillon left. That, is soleky a decision of Mr. Dillon as of if and when he wants to announce that.

This, is called protection of the individual rights, and is something we should all respect.

zlatko 2015-09-08 05:50

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
It all feels not right here and I am to speculate that something not good is going on inside Jolla.
Marc Dillon was the most passionate and vocal Jolla representative, seemed full of energy and very supportive of the idea. To quit silently, stepping back from the venture he put his hearth into past several years, a venture so fragile and in such dire odds of survival - this is not the man he presented himself to be. So parts do not click for me.

And giving Jolla due credit for what they are trying to do is one thing, but honestly - they have just set foot out of the camp and they have mountains higher than Everest to climb ahead of them. They launched an OS with great potential and released 2 mediocre devices - this is far, far away from becoming an viable option in the mobile world.
Just my point of view.

ste-phan 2015-09-08 06:27

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Rumour has he is being sent to Samsung as a Jolla mole.

Samsung has a burning platform going (or meltdown if you prefer) with its piss pants to keep warm strategy of Android and failure to launch Tizen. Now their flagship phone is not selling good enough (not enough grooowwwth) and they are at their most vulnerable.

Marc will enter the ship with his Jolla boat and leave back to to Jolla when the Koreans have switched all mobile product line to Sailfish and moved their production plants to Finland :D

Later thousands of pages of airport bookshop business strategy lecture will be written about the small Jolla boat entering and capturing the juggernaut Samsung.

And the original Jolla fans will be looking for another independent small and privacy friendly OS..

ZogG 2015-09-08 06:50

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
The most interesting part is what about his sailfish tattoo =)

tommo 2015-09-08 07:05

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZogG (Post 1481535)
The most interesting part is what about his sailfish tattoo =)

Ohhh that's worse than having an ex girlfriends name :D

caprico 2015-09-08 07:16

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gerbick (Post 1481525)
There's no Elop, there's no Microsoft, their managers seem to be invested in the company and not only their titles and there's no Symbian hoarding all of the R&D investments despite being a potential dead end while resting on their laurels thinking that they've cornered a market and were too big to lose.

No. Not another Nokia.

[...]

Exciting times we live in... if you decide to look at it like that.

I wished I could give more than 1 thanks to you for this post. It's really crazy how some people try to see the end of Jolla because of that loss...are we Apple fans who define a company through a human leader? I hope not! Marc leaving is certainly a shocking suprise. He always appeared as an adventurer to me, someone who seeks challenge after challenge and maybe he needed a new one to make full use of his talents. Ubuntu phone design lead Ivanka Majic also left Canonical for the personal ambition to co-found some green tech company.

Jolla has many, many talented, competent people in every division of the company who fight for their ideas and for the "unlike" of Jolla. There are not only people leaving the company, but also joining it, like some fantastic UX-design people.

I hope to hear a statement from Marc and until then we can only speculate. But will this hurt Jolla as a company? No, I don't believe so at all...

bluefoot 2015-09-08 07:52

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
I fail to see how this is a surprise to anyone. Marc's in the prime earning potential part of his career (certainly regarding being involved in young companies that might make it big), and it's patently obvious that Jolla is going absolutely nowhere quick.

I was never hugely sold on him (or any of the executive team), but he can clearly find employment elsewhere in the tech sector that will bring him far more financial and tangible success than Jolla is likely to in the forseeable future, and be far better for his career. For someone like him, staying on too long at at a company like Jolla can be quite damaging to both reputation and career prospects.

Best of luck to him.

JoOppen 2015-09-08 08:45

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Maybe this is a better forum than TJC

IMHO, the most important fact is that Carsten Munk (stskeeps) and the developers are still around.

Announcing a product and creating some hype is one thing - an important thing which Marc Dillon did great. However, meeting the expectations thus created is another thing. We all know that we seek for a great OS and great devices running the OS. Meeting our expectations is a tough task that is managed quite well by Jolla.

Off course, I am as impatient as everybody here around. I want my up to date Jolla 2 that I can use one-handed even with my small hands, I want system-wide copy/paste I want ... I want it all and I want it now ...

I am still confident that I will get it one day - because I see the constant output coming from Jolla - thanks to all those who develop every day (and night?).

Fellfrosch 2015-09-08 09:52

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Well maybe it's just because Jolla is shipping in a direction he doesn't like. Remember the decision of Jolla not to produce hardware anymore. Maybe there was an internal argue about the future direction. I think if Marc thinks, that hard- and software belong together, that could be a reason for moving on.

But that doesn't mean, that Jolla is a sinking ship. It only means, that Jolla made a principal decision, which Marc isn't willing to accept.

...just speculation of course... :o

jpel 2015-09-08 10:00

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Marc speaking tomorrow on HardwareHEL presents: Dawn of The Devices

https://twitter.com/HardwareHEL/stat...31837679620096

ste-phan 2015-09-08 10:51

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jpel (Post 1481548)
Marc speaking tomorrow on HardwareHEL presents: Dawn of The Devices

https://twitter.com/HardwareHEL/stat...31837679620096

Topic sounds in line with what Marc said in 2014: Jolla is about the future of mobile. Alliances of companies instead of one or two large companies dominating the market.
If he still believes that it is normal that he decides to go where those alliances are best to be forged.

MartinK 2015-09-08 10:56

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Who knows, maybe all those personal changes in Jolla will finally result in a positive change in regards of more openness, open sourcing of more (ar even all!) closed parts, more community involvement, public bugzilla, etc. ?

Or the exact opposite might happen. :P

ste-phan 2015-09-08 11:05

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MartinK (Post 1481554)
Who knows, maybe all those personal changes in Jolla will finally result in a positive change in regards of more openness, open sourcing of more (ar even all!) closed parts, more community involvement, public bugzilla, etc. ?

Or the exact opposite might happen. :P


Before changes: this is the plan for the Jolla tablet, our next project. It is just a dream but we want to make it people powered by the Jolla community. Tell us what you want and we will do everything we can to make it happen...(as long as it involves that tablet)

After changes: you tell us what you want and we will do everything we can.

?

handaxe 2015-09-08 11:05

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MartinK (Post 1481554)
Who knows, maybe all those personal changes in Jolla will finally result in a positive change in regards of more openness, open sourcing of more (ar even all!) closed parts, more community involvement, public bugzilla, etc. ?

Or the exact opposite might happen. :P

Yeah, and maybe Marc will be the new project lead of Ubuntu Phone... :-)

bluefoot 2015-09-08 12:04

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by handaxe (Post 1481556)
Yeah, and maybe Marc will be the new project lead of Ubuntu Phone... :-)

I highly doubt that. Either that he'd go or they'd want him.

Copernicus 2015-09-08 12:20

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
TechCrunch has an article out on Marc Dillon leaving Jolla:

http://techcrunch.com/2015/09/08/mar...on-sails-away/

pichlo 2015-09-08 12:38

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ste-phan (Post 1481555)
Before changes: this is the plan for the Jolla tablet, our next project. It is just a dream but we want to make it people powered by the Jolla community. Tell us what you want and we will do everything we can to make it happen...(as long as it involves that tablet)

After changes: you tell us what you want and we will do everything we can.

?

The difference I hope for is that it may actually happen. Not just "soon" but really.

ste-phan 2015-09-08 13:26

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pichlo (Post 1481568)
The difference I hope for is that it may actually happen. Not just "soon" but really.

The world doesn't need another tablet / phone spying on its users.

So there is certainly place for "Sailfish Secure".

Hope Antti Saarnio continues to take the lead and makes that happen so that Sailfish is being used by those governments and corps that are looking to build a leak free fleet of devices based on this OS.

https://cdn.jolla.com/wp-content/upl...CURE_FINAL.PDF

romu 2015-09-08 15:14

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Certainly not related to the Marc's departure, but you can't buy the Jolla phone anymore on the Jolla web site.

HtheB 2015-09-08 15:23

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by romu (Post 1481579)
Certainly not related to the Marc's departure, but you can't buy the Jolla phone anymore on the Jolla web site.

You can: http://shop.jolla.com/eu_en/cat-joll...-edition.html/

Casanunda 2015-09-08 15:33

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Off Topic:
Quote:

Originally Posted by HtheB (Post 1481581)

Thanks, I'll pass on that one ;-)
I wonder how many of these "Angry Birds Stella Versions" have been sold?
Target audience seems to be a niche group within the niche of Sailfish users...

pichlo 2015-09-08 15:45

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
(Topicality questionable depending on whether you believe the phones' availability and Marc's departure are connected or not.)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Casanunda (Post 1481583)
Thanks, I'll pass on that one ;-)
I wonder how many of these "Angry Birds Stella Versions" have been sold?
Target audience seems to be a niche group within the niche of Sailfish users...

The normal one is also available: http://shop.jolla.com/eu_en/cat-jolla/jolla-1.html

My internet connection was very sporadic last week and I did not bother checking if the reports of the phones being "out of stock" were true or greatly exaggerated but it seems to be back to normal now.

romu 2015-09-08 18:43

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
No Pichlo, it's not. Go to the Jolla.com web site, click on Store, and you get only the Tablet, nothing more.

I guess it has been made a bit quick and dirty to remove the phone by deleting some web links. So of course, with a direct access you can still see the page, but with a normal browsing, that's not possible.

It may be a mistake on their side tough.

Copernicus 2015-09-08 18:52

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by romu (Post 1481628)
No Pichlo, it's not. Go to the Jolla.com web site, click on Store, and you get only the Tablet, nothing more.

Um, actually, you can get to the phone section of the store by simply clicking on the "Shop Jolla Smartphones and Accessories" link near the upper right-hand side of the page.

romu 2015-09-08 19:28

Re: Marc Dillon left Jolla
 
My mistake guys, you're right.


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:06.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8