Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

A SOFTWARE MARRIAGE?

Intel is expected to introduce new features for the Moblin operating system, give an update on its "Moorestown" platform due out in 2010, and discuss new tablet designs at its annual Intel Developer's Forum in San Francisco next week.

It could further extend its push into mobile by merging its Linux-based operating system with Nokia's, as part of the wide ranging co-operation pact the two had previously announced.

"That opportunity does present itself. We are open to it," Chandrasekher said.

Chandrasekher said the firms aim to bring Intel's Moblin and Nokia's Maemo software closer to each other and find synergies in software development.

"If I develop an application for Moblin, it should run on Maemo. If I develop an application for Maemo, it should run on Moblin," Chandrasekher said.

He said one of the biggest differences between two operating systems would then be their focus on different screen sizes -- Maemo for smaller and Moblin for larger

For the full article:
http://www.reuters.com/article/ousiv...58F0MF20090916

Re: Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

wow! This was big for me, surprised its not big here...

Re: Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

Kinda tired of Intel this Intel that... They can keep their buggy x86 arch. :)

I'll wait to see what the dominating arch after x86 will be :)

Re: Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

ruskie, what do you think of Nokia merging the Maemo OS with Moblin? Good idea or no?

Re: Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

The current Moblin UI incarnation is clearly targeting something like 6-10 inch displays, and quite much 'netbooks'. Maemo is obviously targeting smaller display sizes, i.e. pocketable devices.

I'm sure that under the hood there is lots of potential in merging SW elements - renderers, engines, decoders etc. - but as far as merging UI's, I wouldn't be too hopeful that one solution would fit all ideally. But then again, I would love to prove myself wrong on this.

Re: Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

It's not so big because it just makes sense, and has been hinted at before. They will still be entirely different UIs, but it makes sense to share components and aim for a common development platform (to some extend).

It is peculiar though, that this is coming up when Maemo is just on the verge of switching to Qt. Maemo 5 and Moblin are both built around Gtk and Clutter at the moment.

I wouldn't be entirely surprised if Maemo 5 would develop a life of its own, and at least for some time would coexist with the Qt branch of Maemo 6.

Re: Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

I sorta think this has legs too. Especially once I heard Anssi say that Maemo wouldn't be on netbooks anytime soon, and the russian guy (forget his name) said Maemo would never exceed screens over 4.5-5". I don't see Nokia sticking with Windows 7 for the netbooks for much longer. A Moblin booklet would be cheap and if its compatible with Maemo, we get all sorts of games going on with apps crossing platforms. Good idea, iyam.

Re: Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

christexaport well a common backend would certainly be nice. The problem comes with the UI. No matter how good you design a UI desigend for 6-10" displays will not work effectively on a 4" or smaller display.

Re: Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

Architecturally, Moblin and Maemo also serve two very different ends. Moblin is heavily targeted at Atom while Maemo targets ARM SoCs (TI SoCs in particular). These are two very different beasts with very different requirements for good battery life and good performance.

Both platforms are quite different in their goals and execution, so I can't see a merge happening at any point in the near future. Software compatibility, perhaps (although Intel's utterly bizarre move to Fedora makes that less feasible), but a platform merge, no.

Re: Maemo and Mobiln to align, possibly merge?
 

I don't think it meant combing the OSes into one, just making sure things work on both right out of the box, as if they run the same apps. I'm all for it. I don't see Maemo on a laptop either. The scope of each complements the other. I think the two aligning can help, though.