Android vs. Maemo from development & strategic perspective
 

Thought some of you would find this interesting:

http://buruonbrails.blogspot.com/200...-vs-maemo.html

Android-vs-Maemo - Developer's Perspective
 

This was on reddit a few minutes ago:
http://buruonbrails.blogspot.com/200...-vs-maemo.html

I think it's a good read.

I'm unsure if this is the right forum to post this. Admin, if this needs to be moved to Development or any other, please do.

Re: Android-vs-Maemo - Developer's Perspective
 

Thanks. As someone who isn't a developer, I got a clearer picture from that article of what differentiates Maemo from Android, and how important the open-source community is specifically for the Maemo project.

Re: Android-vs-Maemo - Developer's Perspective
 

Interesting read. Except for the author's views on Gtk. ;)

Re: Android-vs-Maemo - Developer's Perspective
 

For the present he could mention Python since many apps rely on it.

For the future he could mention the Qt cross-platform strategy and the fact that Maemo/Symbian platforms can share a lot of application code.

I think the article is a bit obsolete already now. Read it again after the Maemo Summit and again at the end of the year.

I'm talking about the "facts" and "strategies" he mentions. Android is a great rival and there is no doubt about it.

Re: Android-vs-Maemo - Developer's Perspective
 

Which is good and healthy and will keep us on our toes.

Re: Android-vs-Maemo - Developer's Perspective
 

I posted it to "Competitors" some hours ago where nobody saw it, so General was a good call ;-).

Among other things, the blog post neglects to mention that for the next device it's already sensible to develop applications with Qt, creating the illusion that you are pretty much stuck with C.

And it's not like you can't use Gtk+ as-is in a C++ program...

Re: Android-vs-Maemo - Developer's Perspective
 

He says Android has an advantage in that XML is used for GUI building. That however, is also the purpose of GTK's Glade tool, which spits out an XML description of the GUI. The program itself can be written in C or any of the languages that have bindings, and in it you simply load the GUI from the XML. It may not be as fresh-faced as Android, but GTK isn't exactly Stone Age either.

Re: Android-vs-Maemo - Developer's Perspective
 

He also seems not to be aware of the fact that Maemo will not wait till 2011 to get Qt. Qt apps are here *today*, and, lo and behold, they use XML, dynamic state-based UIs, sqlite storage, internationalization and whatnot. Also, with Python you can't say even Scratchbox hinders you that much unless you really-really depend on some Maemo hardware or specific.

Re: Android-vs-Maemo - Developer's Perspective
 

Which is why I am dumping android like a hot potatoe