maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N900 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=37098)

hm88 2009-12-14 01:21

N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
After about a week playing with my N900, I decided to give a more mature review on my N900. (this review was done and posted from the N900)

Once Again,
NO, Nokia didn't pay me for this. =D you can relax.
AND
if you're expecting 4 a perfect phone out of N900,
look around,
there is NO perfect phone (this isn't a perfect review either).
So again, relax. =)


First impression:

One thing that I like out of the box right away is the built. Solid, black, heavy (coming from Nokia N93 and Samsung Memoir, both lost earlier this year).

I put my sim, microsd, and battery in, didn't turn it on, charged it instead. Took apprx. 1.5 hrs for the notification light to turn green (meaning that the battery is full).

Turned it on, played a lot'a bit, trying to get used to it, got it connected to Tmobile 3g (see http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=36377 to figure it out)

Put my music, contacts (+hermes), some other apps in. Set alarm for the morning. Left it unplugged during the night. The battery was around 60% in the morning.

Q's on charging?
See http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?p=420265.


A lil' overview:

Phone- It takes a lot of getting used to with the phone functionality. It sounds crisp and clear. The integrated Skype calling is awesome. I could call my family overseas in no time at all. Bravo to the Maemo team.

Keypad: Awesome! Starting to get used to it. Im still learning the true potential and shortcuts. Pretty comfortable for me (I have long fingers).

Music- Sound quality's Good enough for me (both speakers/headsets). Good volume.
(Update) If you're a heavy music user that are interested in the N900, make sure that you have a decent headset. The standard one from nokia was OK. I have a sennhaiser PMX100 and it works awesome. My sony MDR710 on the other hand, wasn't performing good.

Camera- Lovin' it. Quick to snap, quick to share. It takes less than 2 minutes to snap a good looking picture then put in on Facebook. Quality's definitely acceptable.

Apps- Need more!
Portrait would be awesome (Nokia, hear this!)
For the time being, I like Hermes (contacts sync with facebook pictures and birthdays). As a college student, I think Xournal and the graph calculators' pretty tight.

Battery- It meets most of my day to day needs. Lots of browsing, email, txting, facebooking. Besides, I don't hesitate to bring the charger to places. Still a tad more mobile than bringing my laptop around.

Web experience- Pleased. I don't feel the need to carry around my laptop around for it. Some websites like megavideo/hulu is almost unusable. But it's still fine with me.


Verdict (will let you know if it changes in the near future):

Being a Nokia and S60 fan, definitely worth the price getting N900. Though there are lots of improvement still needed, the current functionality is good enough so far. If not on par, the functionality is better than competitors out there.

It has been pretty stable (with a few reboots like once or twice day) and served me good.

Many people comment that the N900 camera isn't better than their standalone cameras. But those standalone cameras don't play music, browse the web, upload to services in an instant, take notes, grah calculator, make a call like the N900 does!
Comparing it to other devices could be distracting sometimes.

I guess the best way determine whether the N900/any device out there is good enough/fit for you is to match the functionality of the device with your needs.

In this case , the N900 serves my needs well as a mini tablet phone that does a lot of things well (if not above average). It has the potential to break the boundaries between a smartphone and computer.
The N900 is definitely a keeper ;)

lorelei 2009-12-14 06:21

Re: N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hm88 (Post 426506)
It has been pretty stable (with a few reboots like once or twice day) and served me good.

Personally I don't think that two reboots a day can qualify a device as "pretty stable" (matter of fact, I would rather said that it's pretty unstable), but to each his own standards :)

In any case I did not have any unwanted reboots on my N900 so far, so I have nothing to add :)

franny87 2009-12-14 06:53

Re: N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
I haven't rebooted my n900 yet since i got it lol except the first day when i let it died out to charge. That was the only time my n900 was off haha is that a bad thing? Should i reboot it at least once a day lol?

chase15 2009-12-14 06:54

Re: N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
lol.. i already did a lot.. im doing it after downlaoding some apps... and transfering my sim on my other phone...

franny87 2009-12-14 07:02

Re: N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
Is it necessary to reboot the phone at least once a day though? lol i used to do it only like once a week or two week on my n95 and n97. Never seen to have a problem of slowness. I hear people saying is better for your phone but i never quite understood why. On a computer i see the diff but not on the phone. I see it run the same speed usually hahah

chase15 2009-12-14 07:08

Re: N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
yah.. i dont usually do that on my n97 too.. even i dont reboot it for couple of days.. it is still fine.. i think its already 5 days since the last time i rebooted my n900... and right now.. it works smoothly and nicely...

hm88 2009-12-15 15:47

Re: N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
update: it wasn't rebooting at all yesterday =) hope it's just a glitch. hate to send it back

Laughing Man 2009-12-15 15:54

Re: N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
If you installed apps from testing, devel, or any questionable repo it wouldn't be surprising to see a reboot. Otherwise it might be a device issue.

Rushmore 2009-12-15 15:58

Re: N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
I have not had a reboot issue yet. I must admit I would trade for a few reboots if my 2G reception was better in low signal areas;)

Use at least some "decent" ear buds and you will appreciate the good sound from the 3.5mm jack. N900 has the web and mulit-media locked - nothing touches it, and the 25 or so free gigs for media is a HUGE bonus:)

hm88 2009-12-15 16:00

Re: N900 Review: Not Just a Phone, Not Yet a Laptop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Laughing Man (Post 429127)
If you installed apps from testing, devel, or any questionable repo it wouldn't be surprising to see a reboot. Otherwise it might be a device issue.

none so far (just enabled the 3 default in catalog). well, maybe fennec is the only thing i installed that isn't there. But it seems to work alright so far. . finger crossed.


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:46.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8