[ POLL ] What OS would you prefer on your N900? Maemo5, Meego or NitDroid?
 

With this month's launch of the Meego 1.1 'alpha' and the recent progress porting Android Froyo 2.2, it seems development of a replacement OS for the N900 has quickly become a two-horse race.

Once djsteve, e-yes, and the testing community resolve the few remaining hardware/driver-layer conundrums (phone, battery monitoring, charging, etc), they're done. They'll be 'first to market' with a feature-complete alternative OS for our beloved little N900. And don't forget that Google just open-sourced the whole thing.

So even though the Nokia-led Meego team is developing on the N900 (for future devices), their road-map indicates a comparable feature-complete release for the N900 won't ship until October.

If a feature-complete version of each were available today, which would you flash?

Re: Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 

I would keep all three of them.

Maemo for the Mobile computer aspects (easy debian, etc..)
Meego just to see what's happening in the future
Android for smartphone stuff.

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 

It would be nice to chroot into android and meego just to run their apps.

The only feature I am really missing from android is the phone support, but it's cool to see the device running different OSs

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 

there is a good chance we will be able to triple-boot. However when time comes i'll test both and then decide. we basically no nothing about Meego, we will only in a few days.froyo might be a good choice, since the same chipset is used in the Motorola Droid/Milestone making it already 'optimized' for the n900. Who knows, maybe we will see a really nice & fat P.R 1.3 dropped out of heavens upon us :D making meamo a thing to get envy looks on everywhere(not that its bad now, just all i get is confusion & laughter).

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 

I think most of us will put all the sh*t possible in n900 using bootmenu, just to see "how it works" in all cases

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 

The "few" remaining?

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 

I would only single-boot. The os would probebly be meego as it sounds so awesome, if meego is not that good I would go android 100%

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 

I would too trpleboot all of those but would brobably mainly use android (flash 10.1, games etc.).

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 

Well, yeah. Per the NitDroid's N900 port status page, the remaining hardware features to enable are:

• Charging
• Phone
• Accelerometers
• Unlock/Lock switch on the right side
• Microphone
• FM Transmitter
• FM Radio
• Camera

I'm not belittling the hard effort required to resolve those things. But (I'm assuming) that effort is significantly different/easier/less-time-consuming than coding/integrating new core features for Meego like Phone, Calendar, Contacts, Email, etc.

Re: [ POLL ] Developer Horse-Race: Who'll reach feature-parity with Maemo5 first: Meego or NitDroid?
 

Haha!

I would rather run Maemo 5 until the end of my N900's life than to pollute it with Google's s**t. (This is only my personal opinion about Google, I don't mean to insult the NITdroid developers.)

By the way, if the guys who port Android put their effort into MeeGo instead, it would be much better!