View Single Post
erendorn's Avatar
Posts: 738 | Thanked: 983 times | Joined on Apr 2010 @ London
#337
Originally Posted by momcilo View Post
What is relevant is that the majority of re-used external code is released under GPL and LGPL. Where LGPL is permissive in terms of linking propitiatory software against libraries covered by it, GPL is certainly not.

Irrelevant in my opinion, they have used the GPL software and linked their software against it, so we ask them to contribute back to the community(you know you borrow something from you neighbour, than one day you return the favour) . Please not that the definition of community is not Nokia community, but a greater of GPL.
By any other hardware I meant any other hardware than your own, but it's irrelevant.
Speaking about "permissive" is exactly the point. Nokia is not your neighbour, it's a company.
Either it's legal, or it's not. And if any programmer thinks its work shouldn't be used with closed source software at all, it can specify it. If he doesn't, then anyone can. Nokia included.

Plus, as Texrat mentioned, Nokia does contribute. And finally, you cannot "borrow code", open source code is non-rivalrous (and non-excludable) within what its licence permits.
 

The Following User Says Thank You to erendorn For This Useful Post: