View Single Post
Posts: 673 | Thanked: 856 times | Joined on Mar 2006
#43
Originally Posted by ericsson View Post
Caller ID is an idea. Nokia obviously owns one (of many other owned by others) patents for how to make a working Caller ID in a cell phone. Apple has shamelessly and unlawfully used Nokias patent. Now they must pay
Well, how do you prove the patent is broken? You may use official documentation, original source code, maybe disassemble?

Depending on how the patent applications were filled, it may be very difficult not to brake any patent while designing any type of device today.

Big corporations have a long history of filling applications that are almost equal to the general idea (or trivially different). You may check the IBM patent used to pin down Sun Microsystems over RISC?

In this particular case I can bet that is the case. It would be very interesting to see how they have proved their claims.

EDIT: I don't like Apple because of it's business model, but I dislike patents even more.