View Single Post
Posts: 108 | Thanked: 120 times | Joined on Dec 2009
#7020
Originally Posted by kanishou View Post
I frankly don't see what you are getting it. I believe the N900 is the only other major smartphone without front facing buttons, but the N9 makes it a lot more powerful with the swipe gesture (as the N900 basically just forces applications to provide the button themselves, and you get stuck if they don't). Not having this button is cool, because it means more screen in the usable area of the phone. Of course you could cramp buttons in the small area below the screen, but that's not ergonomic in the least.

I believe that the swipe beats all current solutions in terms of ergonomics.



I said it could go on, not "on and on". There are things I don't know or can't think of which the N9 does better, and then there are smaller innovative details which you will learn to appreciate if you use the phone for a while (e.g. how to unlock the phone).



You know the back-story of the N9, it was meant to be Nokia's primary smartphone contender. You will have to forget about the N900 to truly appreciate it.

If it's not for you, then I'm sorry about that and you will have to move on. But I believe that most people will find the N9 a very enjoyable phone to use, and this time this includes all the demographics.
Lets calm down about the swiping gesture. It's fine and all but it is in no way more superior to Maemo's desktop full of icons and the multitasking grid of apps, and the list of available apps. The Fremantle experience was a pure powerful desktop experience that was very touch friendly and efficient. Swiping through windows and at times not knowing where you are swiping to is more hap-hazard then the way it is on the N900. Even the way it left notifications was superior and intuitive.

I am sure most on this board would agree as well.

Also what buttons does the N900 force you to have? A task switcher? A close button? They are just as important and necessary as well. Freeing up real estate for the screen is the tradeoff the N900 Maemo experience makes to getting things done quickly as well.
 

The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to MoJo For This Useful Post: