View Single Post
Saturn's Avatar
Posts: 1,648 | Thanked: 2,122 times | Joined on Mar 2007 @ UNKLE's Never Never Land
#5
Hi Mara,

Great! thanks a lot for the info.

It is nice to see that the nokia guys took extra care to protect our devices.

Your last sentence though is not 100% correct. This is not common practice and the specs don't require protection from overloading.

From the usb spec:
The purpose of the over current protection device is to limit the amount of current the USB port can draw, such as in a short circuit situation. It should not, however be design to function as a current cop when the downstream device power consumption reaches near the allowable port limits given its declared power requirement. The sizing of the over current protection device should be chosen mainly to protect user safety and against property damage. Over current protection should not be used to enforce the current limits (500mA) that USB devices are required to meet.
Actually, it is discouraged to add this kind of protection on the host (you can find this in other parts) because it might mistakenly disconnect during hot-plugging of compliant devices.

Anyway, now I am really curious to see why they chose this implementation. I am not at all familiar with the OTG and its advantages, but I suspect something about the portable/battery combination.

Chris