View Single Post
danramos's Avatar
Posts: 4,672 | Thanked: 5,455 times | Joined on Jul 2008 @ Springfield, MA, USA
#53
Originally Posted by Kangal View Post
No it is the BEST decision. I used to agree with you, but after careful consideration I cannot.
If Nokia waited for MeeGo, then Nokia would only have Smartphones selling at the rate of Samsung's Bada (which isn't as bad as some think). But in the long run, WP7 would improve and surpass Bada and become the third largest ecosystem (or tied with RIM).

If Nokia chose Android, it would cause a monopoly and Nokia's gains would be short term as Samsung and other manufaturers would have enough leverage against Nokia.

If Nokia chose WP7, they have a shot at long-term victory. While it is a very narrow shot, it's the only one they have. And this time Microsoft has changed its game, it is beyond its Windows Mobile days, it knows the value in mobile systems, and the risks concerning ecosystems.

The BEST decision NOKIA could've made was to contribute (highly) to the MeeGo-Projekt and also buy Palm. As I've listed in this post, doing so would make them number three in the smartphone marketshare by the end of this year. But Nokia's internal miscommunications, misjudgements, and poor choices lead them to resort to a Microsoft assfuc!

Maemo + Moblin + WebOS = magic!
I'm pretty sure I can disagree with your assessment. Maemo/MeeGo COULD have done quite well with a persistent push and a strong backing from a company as big as Nokia HAD been at the time. The move toward Windows Phone 7 is precisely why Nokia is no longer the company it was and trending toward a less and less relevant player. So far, WP7 hasn't been a winner for anybody else, much less a company that, itself, is quickly losing brand loyalty and value.

Similarly, buying WebOS from HP would have done them no favors--it's the same dying, whithering atmosphere that surrounds Maemo/MeeGo right now. The same effects and discussions would have revolved around that, with the exception, maybe, of the possibility of being far more open-source leaning... but then, Nokia hasn't shown that they're interested in that aspect of Maemo before except as a PR stunt to puffer themselves up to developers and FOSS enthusiasts, why start now?

I would also question your judgement about labeling the use of Android as a monopoly. Is iOS suddenly irrelevant? What exactly makes the use of a highly customizable open system monopolistic? Is it the Android Market? Last time I checked, there are a myriad of Android devices that don't use it (including such well known brands as Archos and Amazon's new upcoming tablets). Certainly, it would be far less monopolistic and monoculturist than the Windows Phone 7 they chose to go with. I imagine an Ovistore on Android would be far easier to implement and far more sought after by even non-Nokia devices, if they played their cards right. What a missed opportunity by the shortsighted executive dunces at Nokia!

I, personally for all that's worth, think that Nokia would have done well to have stopped dribbling all over themselves as if they were developmentally challenged with the idiotic "this is step 4 of 5" and instead of putting so much effort into making SURE you couldn't separate the closed-source from the open-source to produce a hobbled closed-core trap... instead had placed all that time, resource and money into PROMOTION and actual DEVELOPMENT for an open-source friendly device and promoting it as the power of FOSS open-source servers in a tiny pocket-sized piece of kit... I'd bet THAT would have done wonders for everyone involved.

Well, so long as Eflop is in charge, that ship has sailed. Nokia, you could have been a contender... instead, you're sitting in the corner diddling yourself while everyone else is off learning, inventing and having fun. Windows Phone 7 isn't your savior... you watch.

__________________
Nokia's slogan shouldn't be the pedo-palmgrabbing image with the slogan, "Connecting People"... It should be one hand open pleadingly with another hand giving the middle finger and the more apt slogan, "Potential Unrealized." --DR