Sorry, I don't have time to get involved in this discussion or find solutions. Nokia doesn't have an opinion about the Community QA process, neither is pushing or stopping any approach. It is entirely up to this community.

When that QA process was created Extras was the best destination for most individual developers since the Ovi Store was almost a no go. Now the situation is different, and individuals can publish easily apps as long as they pass through the QA requirements. In this context maybe having a Quality indicator as Felipe has indicated at maemo-community would be enough? As said, it is up to you.