View Single Post
Posts: 245 | Thanked: 915 times | Joined on Feb 2012
#242
Originally Posted by geneven View Post
It has been said that current members of Council need up to date devices to properly represent the membership. My proposal, that ownership be returned to Council when a recipient stops being a member of Council, is specifically designed to respond to that argument.
In a matter of weeks there won't be a council, and no one will be returning anything to anyone. Such a plan wouldn't be much of an improvement.

Originally Posted by woody14619 View Post
You want minutes? I gave them to you already, in the form of the process we used.

What you really want is exact, personal discussions on each person, which frankly no... you won't get. You don't get that at most competitions. Do you see the individual votes for every contestant, and the reasoning for it from each judge at every competition you see? This is not American Idol or Dancing with the Stars.
Meeting minutes and "the process" are two very different things.

Originally Posted by somedude View Post
Why would you ask me to compare to the real world and at the same time you refuse to do whats done on most of the real world competition.
Dead on. No competition that even pretends to have some level of legitimacy allows the judges to claim the awards for themselves.

It's a shame those involved aren't interested in rectifying this in a dignified fashion.
 

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to itsnotabigtruck For This Useful Post: