View Single Post
Traecer's Avatar
Posts: 165 | Thanked: 9 times | Joined on Jul 2007
#12
Originally Posted by HalSF View Post
I'd be happy if someone talked me out of this, but my impression is that the POS on the N800/N810 is worthless unless you already own a bunch of Palm software. The thousands of available programs that Garnet hyped when it announced the platform prove to be obsolete, expensive, or nonexistent, even if you could figure out which versions run under this VM. It's really cool that I can launch this alternate platform on my Nokia tablet, but as a productive/fun tool -- zilch. A vaporware come-on and a stone-cold dead end, at least so far.

Please tell me I'm wrong - I hope I am.
OK, look everybody: the Garnet VM is NOT a product. It's a cool piece of tech, and if you find it useful for something that's great. But all it is the Garnet (don't say "Palm OS!") compatibility layer from ACCESS's already failed mobile Linux OS. Both Palm and ACCESS have failed to create compelling Linux platforms, and they're toast. For ACCESS's part, they apparently thought they'd strip out Garnet and get it running on Maemo as a technology demonstration (Maemo has most of the underlying libraries already). Maybe they thought someone would find a use for it they hadn't thought of, I don't know. But you're right: there's no there there, because this thing's original reason for being (transition Palm users and their apps to a new seamlessly integrated OS) has gone away.

On the nonfunctional apps front, I can shed some nonspecific light on that too: Garnet VM pretends to be Palm OS 5.5, a version that never existed before on a device. Every version of Palm OS has tweaks and weirdnesses that breaks some things, even new devices that supposedly have the same OS version. Doubtless that's what has happened here; many apps will have to be tweaked to run on the new OS, and most of the Palm app developers have ceased to care.
 

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Traecer For This Useful Post: