View Single Post
Posts: 840 | Thanked: 823 times | Joined on Nov 2009
#743
Originally Posted by Copernicus View Post
It is also true that many manufacturers set up their devices to be extremely tolerant of off-spec IR signals. (After all, most remote controls are constructed very cheaply.) I'm always amazed looking at the LIRC config files; some of the timings in them are off by more than 20 or 30 percent, and yet they still work fine. I have a sneaking suspicion that the problem with Sony devices is that Sony builds their equipment so well, they don't have to be tolerant of off-spec timing. And, therefore, they are unhappy with some aspect of my protocols that other devices just don't care about.

(Which reminds me; maybe an additional column for the controlled device's make and model would be useful.)
I have no background of IR spec but I've noticed that some of my remotes I can never get working on ANY other infra-red remote.
What I mean by that is I can never get any other universal remote or LIRC (on a PC) to learn commands from these 2 remotes I have.

The remote was for a DiSEqC (USALS) satellite receiver (made by echostar), I bought several universal remotes to to try and "teach" them from this remote and they would always fail to do so. This forced me to get another DiSEqC satellite receiver made by another company (don't remember the name but it wasn't echostar) and oddly they couldn't learn from it either. All other remotes worked except these. Is there some special protocol for DiSEqC receivers which make them incompatible with universal remotes and LIRC?

Last edited by Cue; 2012-09-27 at 01:42.
 

The Following User Says Thank You to Cue For This Useful Post: