View Single Post
Posts: 52 | Thanked: 21 times | Joined on Jan 2008
#28
Originally Posted by sgosnell View Post
Yes, he's asking the wrong question. I agree with that. But people who have never seen a device saying that it's too slow, or too small, or won't do something, are out of line, IMO. The Eee is faster than my HP laptop. It certainly isn't for heavy graphics or gaming, but for the things most people do, including programming, it's better than a budget laptop, because it's faster, especially running Linux instead of Windows, it's smaller and lighter, and it's cheaper in the long run. Flash memory is getting cheaper, and you can plug a USB stick in and have plenty. Optical drives are only good for making permanent backups now, because you can get far more memory on a USB flash drive than is available on a CD or even a DVD for very little money, and it's easily and quickly rewritable. DVDs are going to be obsolete rather soon for most uses. Lack of a DVD drive isn't a major drawback any longer, and neither is lack of a hard drive, which uses battery power quickly. I've been looking for exactly what the Eee provides for some time, and would have been willing to pay more than double the price. It's not for everyone, and that's why they sell so many different types of computer, from handhelds to huge desktops. Everybody's needs and wants are different, and they vote with their pocketbooks, or at least their credit cards. The OP can use what he has to do what he needs, but doesn't want to. An Eee is the cheapest way to get a new computer that has the capabilities he needs. You don't need a huge screen for programming, or learning networking. If you want something you can use anywhere, anytime, and can easily take with you wherever you go, it fits the bill. You can get a new desktop much cheaper, and the one he has will do the job, but it's pretty much stuck in one place. Whether money or portability is more
important is an individual decision.
Flash drives are a non-starter for me, since I cannot use them at work, or take them anywhere I have work to do. The ONLY way for me to transfer files from one machine to another, or even from home to work, is via optical non-rewritable media. Hell, a floppy drive is still a bonus for me sometimes, as there are machines I work on that do not have a CD ROM. A hard drive might use battery power more quickly, but can store a heck of a lot more data than any SSD in a reasonable form factor. Plus, the form factor of the EEE makes it difficult to put a reasonable battery on it, so it's really not a matter of it being better, but a matter of necessity.

Also, I want XP on my laptop. I don't WANT to run Linux. I don't WANT to use openoffice. I want to run Windows XP, and office 2007. It's what I use at work, it's mostly what I use at home and it's what I want to use when I'm on the road. I have plenty of mobile-optimized devices for when I don't want to pull out a full-fledged device (Treo, n800, ipod etc). When I pull out a laptop, I want a full-fledged computer with all the capabilities of my desktop. I don't foresee a machine with 512MB of RAM and a very limited amount of storage being able to run a very robust XP desktop. My outlook mailbox alone is over 2GB.

I want an EEE, I'm not bashing it. I'm just saying, as most people do, that it's not a full-fledged desktop replacement for most people. It's a compromise at the moment, a good one at that, between capability, usability and form factor. It's somewhere between the n800 and a "real" computer. Maybe by EEE 2.0 they'll have addressed some of the limitations. I'm glad it fits your needs, but I can assure you that it doesn't come close to addressing mine at the moment.

As far as the OP, he hasn't defined the capabilities he needs, but I would presume that running a windows-based OS would be part of that, if he's looking to learn about how to fix computers, since 90%+ of the world uses MS products. You can learn networking or programming on an n800 too. Or a TI-92. Or an Atari 800. Heck, you really don't even need a computer to learn networking. I think, as others have posted, that what he really needs is a big beefy desktop that can run multiple OS images and can be tinkered around with quite a bit without the form factor limitations and concerns that come with a mobile device.

Last edited by gompers; 2008-01-21 at 04:23.