View Single Post
Guest | Posts: n/a | Thanked: 0 times | Joined on
#11
Originally Posted by Wikiwide View Post
It is possible the crash was coming with or without Elop. It would be difficult for one person to 'destroy' the company so thoroughly.
I cannot say anything about N9-Harmattan being worse or better than N900-Fremantle. However, I can point out that N9's interface (Swype) was praised to the extent of being copied by BlackBerry (another 'sinking' company).
I agree that Windows Phone is better choice than Android. Not because Microsoft is better than Google, but because Android is already ubiquitous, and Windows Phone is 'exotic'. In other words, supporting Windows Phone allowed Nokia to stand out, which would have been impossible with Android.
However, they were not the only choices available. Tizen, Firefox OS, MeeGo... Nokia simply decided that it needs another company to shoulder the burden of software development and blame for its shortcomings. Do you notice how some people say that Lumia's hardware is excellent, and the faults are in software?
At the same time, Nokia City Lens and Nokia Drive are envy of other platforms. And cinemagraphs are notable. For me, they are eye-candy, unnecessary but respectable for the amount of work needed to make this 'A.I.' suit tastes of majority of the users.
I wouldn't say Jolla members are incompetent. I would say that their vision was so different from expectations of Nokia's managers that they hadn't done much for Nokia. However, after separation they were able to choose their direction themselves. And it seems that the more time they see ahead of themselves due to hardware manufacturers doubting Jolla, the more ideas they solidify into workable concepts.
Yes, it is possible that BlackBerry waited for too long, and introduced nothing new in their latest operating system. It's like browsers: they copy each other, in user interface and functionality, rarely daring to innovate for fear of scaring away their users.
However, I wouldn't say that MeeGo or Maemo are dead. Nemo is young, like a nova, and vague and unshaped like a nebula; there is much potential in it, in Mer in general.
Yet, I can understand how an outsider (first non-Finnish director of Nokia?) decided that in-house code isn't good enough for him. Not that I would ever use Windows Phone... I would rather try to install Mer on Lumia. But for that, I would need to get my hands on Lumia, first. And it can happen only accidentally, since I am not going to deliberately spend effort on getting hardware (even if it is considered good) without software.
Best wishes.
Agree with many points you make. I need something that works, and I have no problem with open concepts or giving people ability to tinker with their devices. Hey, I bought more n900s and N9s than many people combined on this forum. However, when you sell the device, or try to sell it to masses, the basics of it have to work. And they have to work without tweaks, mods, or tears. And they have to work equivalent to your competition, iphone and Android. And they have to be an improvement on your preexisting product (going from N900 to N9). I could not, in my conscience, release a device like N9 to the masses. If I was the software engineer on that project, I would commit suicide or quit, rather than have my name associated with such inferior and overall buggy product. And now, these same coders have formed Jolla. good luck to them. I hope the new freedom will give them appreciation for discipline and good coding. They dont have NOKIA name to hide behind. They will have to be their own men now. That said, there is nothing revolutionary in what they show. There is nothing novel that will make it stand above and beyond competition. Yes, there are few gimmicks of swiping and some nuances on closing windows.......but that is a fine refinement, not a leap like iphone made. Every product since iphone, is pretty much iphone copycat with variations on the theme. As a startup you need something that is way beyond what the big boys are making. I just dont see it. And the average Joe, doesnt care how open it is.