View Single Post
Posts: 46 | Thanked: 285 times | Joined on Dec 2005
#1490
Originally Posted by zwer View Post
Slow (SFTP) and very slow (BT).

That being said, I connect my N9 in mass-storage mode only if I have to transfer >10GB of data.

Apart from speed, mass-storage is still very useful when you need to use your phone as a USB flash memory, especially with devices that have no idea of what MTP (which is also far slower than direct USB transfer) is like many 'smart'-TVs and such.

Well, apart from legacy reasons and "don't fix it if it ain't broken" mentality (and it is broken in this particular instance). Sure thing, allowing such thing won't make the above mass-storage problem (legacy) solved, but there is no real reason why ext4 cannot be extended (it just needs a bit smarter journaling) to allow mounting by multiple hosts. Then you can stick an ext4<->FAT translation layer on top of it for legacy purposes and be done with it.
I agree with the fact that USB mass -storage is usually more useful. However the mounting point is not moot as you state, neither is adding a FAT translation layer trivial. If it al was as simple as you state it would already be done.

Anyway there are a few different things in the pipeline to improve on this problem. You ask, we try to please:

https://github.com/nemomobile/usb-mo...635055679b742b

Just don't expect this to work for you perfectly yet. This needs more time for polishing and bugfixing. The whole fs mount handling needs to be reviewed in detail as tests show there are still some issues there.


And atm MTP does work on most current OSes with the notable exception of the "ever broken when it comes to widely accepted standards" OS X. So the plugging in USB to exchange files use case works.
 

The Following 10 Users Say Thank You to Philippe For This Useful Post: