Thread: Jolla Tablet
View Single Post
Posts: 1,269 | Thanked: 3,961 times | Joined on May 2011 @ Brazil
#369
Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
Every time you talk about this TJC question, you are forgetting one crucial thing. The question wasn't about exFAT - that was already decided by Jolla and nothing to vote about. The question was about supporting open formats.
I have all Jolla Tablet announcements, no one cites exFAT. They cite microSD with 128GB support. A different thing.

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
The only way that would justify what you are advocating would be:
We are announcing a possibility to have SD card support >32GB, but you can vote for it on TJC until xx.xx. 2014 . Until the voting is over, we are terminating all pre-orders. Once the question is decided, we will update the Indiegogo campaign with the appropriate information and resume pre-orders.
No need to freeze the campaign just to decide about a stretch goal.

You forget the Indiegogo campaign terms, as it was already cited here before :
As in any crowdfunding campaign or product development, changes are possible. We reserve the right to make changes in described features, specifications, and delivery date estimations and to introduce software features and functionality at a later date.
As I've said : if somebody wants a tablet with frozen specs, just buy one that already is available in the market. Any Indiegogo campaign is not about frozen specs and risk-free products.

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
It is not about me or you voting. First, ~140 votes is a joke - thousands have voted since with their wallet. But even if those thousands-1 voted against exFAT, the 1 buyer who did not vote for it would have to be contacted and refunded.
More than 302 votes for no-exFAT as default, just 58 votes for exFAT default support in Jolla Tablet. Consider that Jolla sold about 7,200 tablets in Indiegogo campaign (until December), so 4,2% of active users is a lot greater than 0,8%.

Nobody selected a perk including exFAT/microSDXC support. No need to refund anybody. There was a stretch goal to have microSD > 32GB. With no exFAT or microSDXC words cited at all.

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
And why did I vote for the answer? Because I would appreciate btrfs support. exFAT was never the question, it was already decided.
The answer you have voted was excluding exFAT licensing as default. It is clearly written :
Support SDHC (up to 32GB, no exFAT licensing)
exFAT was not decided at all, read TJC topic cited by the pool (where exFAT = proprietary file system) :
We understand that many of you would not want to support a proprietary file system for good reasons. So here's a suggestion especially for you:
We have put up a specific poll here on TJC about better supporting open source file systems on microSD cards in Sailfish OS.
This is mainly for taking in suggestions from you on what we should practically do here.
Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
If it was a question, then I would vote for this answer again, because I prefer optional paid support (which would have to be refunded by Jolla to those who have bought the tablet expecting the support to be in place) to buying an exFAT license for every device.
You've voted for :
If possible, paid-for exFAT license package to support SDXC
See, "If possible". We don't know if it is or not.

As I've already said, Jolla hasn't cited exFAT or microSDXC support in the stretch goal. And any Indiegogo can have specs, delivery date, etc, changed. So no right to be refunded at all.

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
Me, you and TJC voting are absolutely irrelevant in this issue.
No, we are not irrevelant at all. Since Maemo 4 days, then Maemo 5, MeeGo Harmattan and now Sailfish OS, I see the community (here, in TJC, blogs, sites, etc) opinion makes indeed a difference, with many suggestions being adopted (by Nokia, Jolla, OTH builders, etc).

Originally Posted by nodevel View Post
The majority not reading TMO/TJC (and not giving a damn about filesystems) will be quite disappointed when their cards won't work as promised. And I'm not even talking about reviews.
All the Jolla Tablet perkers receive the emails about news, so they can be aware of any changes, vote for features, etc.
__________________
Python, C/C++, Qt and CAS developer. For Maemo/MeeGo/Sailfish :
Integral, Derivative, Limit - calculating mathematical integrals, derivatives and limits. SymPy - Computer Algebra System.
MatPlotLib - 2D & 3D plots in Python. IPython - Python interactive shell.
-- My blog about mobile & scientific computing ---
Sailfish : Sony Xperia X, Gemini, Jolla, Jolla C, Jolla Tablet, Nexus 4. Nokia N9, N900, N810.
 

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to rcolistete For This Useful Post: